MTR Corporation Limited

 

South Island Line (East)

 

Monthly EM&A Report No. 41

 

December 2014

 

 

 

 

 

 

Certified by: Environmental Team Leader

                        (please refer to submitted true copy)

Verified by:    Independent Environmental Checker

                        (please refer to submitted true copy)

 

 


EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

 

With the main civil works contracts of the South Island Line (East) (SIL(E)) Project awarded in May 2011, the commencement date of construction of the Project was on 25 June 2011. The Environmental Monitoring and Audit (EM&A) programme of the Project also commenced on 25 June 2011. This is the forty-first Monthly EM&A Report for SIL(E) Project. The Report presents the results of EM&A works undertaken during the period of 1 to 30 November 2014. The major construction activities in the reporting period included piling, excavation, slope stabilization works, shaft excavations, tunnel excavation as well as construction of stations and depot. Operation of magazine at Chung Hom Shan has been terminated in October 2014. 

 

Impact monitoring for air quality, noise and water quality were conducted in the reporting period.  No exceedance was found and there was no breach of Action / Limit Levels for air quality and noise monitoring.

 

No complaint referred by EPD was received in the reporting month.

 

No notification of summon or prosecution related to the environmental issue was received in the reporting period.

 

Regular site inspections were conducted by the Environmental Team (ET) to check the implementation of environmental mitigation measures. No non-conformance to the environmental requirements was identified in the reporting period.

 

Future key issues envisaged in the coming month include noise and dust emission from site works. The ET will continue the implementation of the EM&A programme in accordance to the EM&A Manual.

 

 

 


 

 

TABLE OF CONTENTS

 

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

 

1.                INTRODUCTION

1.1         Project Background

1.2         Project Programme

1.3         Coverage of EM&A Report

2.                PROJECT INFORMATION

2.1         Project Organization and Management Structure

2.2         Construction Activities in the Reporting Month

2.3         Construction Activities for the Coming Month

2.4         Project Areas and Environmental Monitoring Locations

2.5         Summary of EM&A Requirements

3.                IMPACT MONITORING

3.1         Air Quality

3.2         Noise

3.3         Water Quality

3.4         Action taken in Event of Exceedance

4.                LANDSCAPE AND VISUAL

4.1         EM&A Requirements

4.2         Site Audit Results

5.                ECOLOGY

5.1         EM&A Requirements

5.2         Site Audit Results

6.                WASTE MANAGEMENT

7.                RECORD OF ENVIRONMENTAL COMPLAINTS

8.                RECORD OF NON-COMPLIANCES

9.                RECORD OF NOTIFICATIONS OF SUMMONS AND PROSECUTIONS

10.              STATUS OF STATUTORY SUBMISSIONS

10.1      Submissions required under Environmental Permit

10.2      Statutory Permits and Licenses

11.              SITE INSPECTIONS

11.1      Implementation of Environmental Mitigation Measures

11.2      Observations

11.3      Solid and Liquid Waste Management Status

11.4      Other Notable Events

12.              FUTURE KEY ISSUES

13.              CONCLUSIONS

 

 

 

 


 

List of Tables

 

Table 1           Summary of impact dust and noise monitoring stations

 

Table 2           Summary of impact water quality monitoring stations

 

 

List of Figures

 

Figures 1 to 2                                                                                                                                                           Works Areas of the Project

 

Figures 3 to 6                                                                                                                                                           Location of Construction Air Quality Monitoring Stations

 

Figures 7 to 8                                                                                                                                                           Location of Construction Noise Monitoring Stations

 

Figures 9         Air Quality and Noise Monitoring Locations for Telegraph Bay Barging Point

 

Figures 10      Water Quality Monitoring Locations for Telegraph Bay Barging Point

 

 

List of Appendices

 

Appendix A1     Project Organization

 

Appendix A2     Contact List of Key Personnel of the Project

 

Appendix B1     Action and Limit Levels for Construction Noise and Air Quality

 

Appendix B2     Action and Limit Levels for Water Quality

 

Appendix C       Calibration Details

 

Appendix D       Graphical Plots of Air Quality, Noise & Water Quality Monitoring and Monitoring Results for Water Quality

 

Appendix E        Review of Exceedance in Environmental Monitoring

 

Appendix F        Implementation of Environmental Mitigation Measures

 

 

 

 


 

1.                           INTRODUCTION

 

1.1                        Project Background

 

The South Island Line (East) (SIL(E)) of 7.0km approximately is a new medium capacity railway with stations at South Horizons (SOH), Lei Tung (LET), Wong Chuk Hang (WCH), Ocean Park (OCP) and Admiralty (ADM), comprising underground and elevated structures. A depot is required at Wong Chuk Hang to provide maintenance support for the SIL(E).

 

 

1.2                        Project Programme

 

Main civil works contracts of the SIL(E) were awarded in May 2011. The commencement date of construction of the Project was on 25 June 2011. The construction of the Project is expected to complete in 2016.

 

 

1.3                        Coverage of EM&A Report

 

The Environmental Monitoring and Audit (EM&A) programme of the Project commenced on 25 June 2011. This is the forty-first Monthly Environmental Monitoring and Audit (EM&A) Report for the Project. The Report presents the results of EM&A undertaken during the period of 1 to 30 November 2014.

 

 

2.                           PROJECT INFORMATION

 

2.1                        Project Organization and Management Structure

 

The project organization is shown in Appendix A1. Contacts of key personnel of the Project are shown in Appendix A2.

 

2.2                        Construction Activities in the Reporting Month

 

Major construction activities carried out by the respective SIL(E) civil works contractors during the reporting period include:

 

Contract No. 901

Site

Construction Activities

Harcourt Garden

-          Excavation, blasting works at cavern, tunnels and station box

-          Construction works at station box, cavern and tunnels

-          Underpinning works at station box

-          Re-setup of skip hoist

-          ABWF works at station box

-          Vent shaft modification work

-          A&A works at Admiralty Station

 

 

 

Contract No. 902

Site

Construction Activities

Hong Kong Park Ventilation Shaft

-          Construction of shaft

 

Nam Fung Portal

-          Construction for transition box

-          Tunnel excavation by drill and blast

-          Construction of ventilation building

Chung Hom Shan Magazine

-          Reinstatement works

Telegraph Bay Barging Point

-          Reinstatement works

 

Contract No. 903

Site

Construction Activities

Zone B (Ex-Canadian Site to OCP Station)

-          Reinstatement works in Zone B (B2-B6)

-          Noise Barrier Installation in Zone B (B4)

OCP Station

-          Louvers Installation

-          Glazed panels of the glass façade

-          Door flame installation

-          Ceiling Installation

-          Mosaic tiles on wall and columns

-          Installation of glass balustrade

-          Dismantling of tower crane

Zone C

(OCP Station to WCH Station)

-          PSR and HYR East Road and Drainage works

WCH Station

-          Installation of Glass balustrade

-          Construction of openable window at concourse level

-          Entrance A-ABWF works

-          Entrance B Footbridge construction

-          Erection of Vehicular Portal for Wong Chuk Hang Footbridge across Wong Chuk Hang Road

-          Removal of Vehicular Portal Frame for Wong Chuk Hang Footbridge across Heung Yip Road

 

Zone D (WCH Station to WCH nullah) and External Works

-          Pedestrian Link Bridge Installation (D17 and Kun Hoi Path)

-          HYR/NLS Road and Drainage works

-          Reinstatement Works

 

Zone E (ACB)

-          Remaining works of Pavement

 

 

Contract No. 904

Site

Construction Activities

Ex-Harbour Mission School

-          Backfilling

-          Tunnel box construction

Lee Wing Street

-          Construction of main tunnel

-          Construction of ventilation building

LET Station Entrance A

-          Construction of adit

-          Construction of station

LET Station Entrance B

-          Shaft and adit excavation and construction

South Horizons

-          Station structure construction

South Horizons Plant Building

-          Slope protection

-          Plant building structure construction

Project site office at Ap Lei Chau Bridge Playground

-          Handover to LCSD completed

Lee Wing Street Barging Point

-          Reinstatement works

 

                        Contract No. 908

Site

Construction Activities

WCH Depot

-          Architectural builders works and finishes

-          Road Works

 

 

 

2.3                        Construction Activities for the Coming Month

 

The scheduled major construction activities in the next reporting month are as follows:

 

Contract No. 901

Site

Construction Activities

Harcourt Garden

-          Excavation, blasting works at cavern, tunnels and station box

-          Construction works at station box, cavern and tunnels

-          Underpinning works at station box

-          Re-setup of skip hoist

-          ABWF works at station box

-          Vent shaft modification work

-          A&A works at Admiralty Station

 

Contract No. 902

Site

Construction Activities

Hong Kong Park Ventilation Shaft

-          Construction of shaft

Nam Fung Portal

-          Construction for transition box

-          Tunnel excavation by drill and blast

-          Construction of ventilation building

Chung Hom Shan Magazine

-          Reinstatement works

Telegraph Bay Barging Point

-          Reinstatement works

 

                    Contract No. 903

Site

Construction Activities

Zone B (Ex-Canadian Site to OCP Station)

-          Reinstatement works in Zone B (B2-B6)

-          Remaining works of Noise Barrier Installation

 

OCP Station

-          Glazed panels of the glass façade

-          Door flame installation

-          Ceiling Installation

-          Mosaic tiles on wall and columns

-          Construction of footbridge to Ocean Park

Zone C

(OCP Station to WCH Station)

-          PSR and HYR East Road and Drainage works

 

WCH Station

-          Ceiling Installation

-          Steel work & glazed panel for external façade

-          Door flame installation

-          Entrance A-ABWF works

-          Entrance B Footbridge construction

-          Removal of Vehicular Portal for Wong Chuk Hang Footbridge across Wong Chuk Hang Road

 

Zone D (WCH Station to WCH

nullah) and Exteranl Works

-          Pedestrian Link Bridge Installation (D17 and Kun Hoi Path)

-          HYR/NLS Road and Drainage works

-          Noise Barrier Installation

-          Reinstatement Works

 

Zone E (ACB)

-          Remaining works of Pavement

 

Contract No. 904

Site

Construction Activities

Ex-Harbour Mission School

-          Backfilling

-          Tunnel box construction

-          Retaining wall construction

Lee Wing Street

-          Construction of main tunnel

-          Construction of ventilation building

LET Station Entrance A

-          Construction of adit

-          Construction of station

LET Station Entrance B

-          Shaft and adit excavation and construction

South Horizons

-          Station structure construction

-          Landscape works at EPIW Footbridge to Ap Lei Chau Esate

South Horizons Plant Building

-          Slope protection

-          Plant building structure construction

Lee Wing Street Barging Point

-          Reinstatement works

 

Contract No. 908

Site

Construction Activities

WCH Depot

 

-          Architectural builders works and finishes

-          Road Works

 

2.4                        Project Areas and Environmental Monitoring Locations

 

The works areas of the Project are shown in Figures 1 and 2. Impact dust and noise monitoring has been conducted at designated monitoring locations during operation of the Telegraph Bay barging point in accordance with the Construction and Demolitions Materials Management Plan (C&DMMP) approved under EP. Operation of barging point has been terminated by 30 September 2014.  Reinstatement of barging point commenced in October 2014 while marine-based demolition works started on 14 November 2014.  The impact dust and noise monitoring during the restatement works at the barging point at Telegraph Bay will be carried out in accordance with the environmental review report submitted for variation to SIL(E) Environmental Permit EP-407/2010 in November 2011.  Regular site audits will continue to be carried out in parallel to ensure that the recommended mitigation measures are properly implemented.  Marine water quality monitoring has been conducted during the period of marine-based demolition in accordance with Silt Curtain Plan for Marine-based Decommissioning of Temporary Pier at Telegraph Bay submitted under the EP.

 

The locations of environmental monitoring stations are shown in Figures 3 to 10. Tables 1 and 2 below shows the details of the active monitoring stations as reported in Sections 3.1 to 3.3 below.

 

 

Table 1     Summary of impact dust and noise monitoring stations

ID

Monitoring Station

Dust

CD1

Wong Chuk Hang San Wai

CD2

Police College ¡V Police Quarters

CD3

San Wui Commercial Society of HK Chan Pak Sha School

CD4

Shan On House

CD5*

South Horizons Phase IV ¡V Block 25

DTB1

Site boundary of Telegraph Bay barging point

Noise

CN1

San Wui Commercial Society of HK Chan Pak Sha School (Educational Institution)

CN2

Holy Spirit Seminary (Education Institution)

CN3*

Shun Fung Building (Residential)

CN4*

South Horizons Phase IV ¡V Block 25 Dover Court (Residential)

CN5*

TWGHs Jockey Club Rehabilitation Complex Block A (Convalescent Home)

NTB1

Outside Aegean Terrace

* Location updated due to site access problem, or as per the agreement with the premises landlord, and agreed with EPD

 

Table 2     Summary of impact marine water quality monitoring stations

 

Monitoring Stations

Coordinates

Easting

Northing

Control Stations

 

 

CE (Ebb)

830026

814956

CF (Flood)

831778

812420

Impact Stations

 

 

I1

831088

813654

I2

831105

813582

Intake A

831610

812931

Intake B

830606

814583

 

 

 

2.5                        Summary of EM&A Requirements

 

The EM&A programme as specified in the EM&A Manual has been implemented during the construction stage.

 

In the reporting period, impact monitoring of LAeq, 30min noise levels was carried out at the monitoring locations as shown in Table 1 once a week. Also, 24-hour TSP monitoring was conducted at the monitoring locations as shown in Table 1 once a week. Impact water quality monitoring at Telegraph Bay was also undertaken at the monitoring locations as shown in Table 2 three working days per week at mid-ebb and mid-flood tides.

 

Action and Limit Levels for construction noise and air quality as well as water quality are shown in Appendices B1 and B2 respectively. Should non-compliance of the criteria occurs, action in accordance with the respective Event and Action Plans for construction noise, air quality and water quality in the EM&A Manual / Updated EM&A Manual / Silt Curtain Plan should be carried out.

 

Monthly monitoring of the ardeid night roost location beside Wong Chuk Hang Nullah by qualified ecologist was also conducted.

 

In addition, regular site inspection to active works areas was carried out. The areas of inspection included the pollution control and mitigation measures within the site. Waste management and landscape and visual aspects were covered.

 

 

3.                           IMPACT MONITORING

 

3.1                        Air Quality

 

Monitoring Methodology

24-hour TSP samples were collected by High Volume Sampler (Graseby-Andersen) following United Sates Environmental Protection Agency regulations.

The sampling procedure follows to that described in the App. B of Pt 50 in 40CFR Ch.1 (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency). TSP is sampled by drawing air through a conditioned, pre‑weighed filter paper inside the high volume sampler at a controlled rate. After 24‑hour sampling, the filter paper with retained particles is collected and returned to the laboratory for drying in a desiccators followed by weighing. TSP levels are calculated from the ratio of the mass of particulate retained on the filter paper to the total volume of air sampled.

 

The samplers have been properly maintained. Prior to dust monitoring commencing, appropriate checks have been made to ensure that all equipment and necessary power supply are in good working condition.

 

Calibration Requirements

The flow rate of the high volume sampler with mass flow controller is calibrated using an orifice calibrator. Initial calibration (five points) is conducted upon installation and prior to commissioning. Calibration will be carried out every six months. The calibration records are shown in Appendix C.

 

Monitoring Results

To examine the construction dust levels, 24-hour TSP monitoring was undertaken at the monitoring locations as shown in Table 1 according to the EM&A Manual.

 

Monitoring results are presented in the following table (see Appendix D for graphical plots). The 24-hour TSP levels were within the Action Level. No exceedance was found. This indicates that the construction activities did not have a noticeable adverse effect on the general air quality of the project areas.  However, excavation and reinstatement works by other Project were observed in the vicinity of monitoring station DTB1 at Telegraph Bay barging point during the reporting month, which have generated fugitive dust emitting to the local environment. The dust suppression measures, such as water spraying on the haul road and tipping hall, for the barging point operation were ongoing.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Date

TSP (µg/m3)

Action Level (µg/m3)

Limit Level (µg/m3)

Compliance

Weather Condition

(Yes/No)

CD1  Wong Chuk Hang San Wai 

6-Novt

120.1

173

260

Yes

Cloudy

13-Nov

134.0

173

260

Yes

Fine

20-Nov

89.1

173

260

Yes

Fine

27-Nov

78.5

173

260

Yes

Fine

CD2  Police College ¡V Police Quarters 

3-Nov

94.9

184

260

Yes

Cloudy

10-Nov

122.7

184

260

Yes

Cloudy

17-Nov

130.5

184

260

Yes

Fine

24-Nov

75.7

184

260

Yes

Fine

CD3  San Wui Commercial Society of HK Chan Pak Sha School

3-Nov

84.6

169

260

Yes

Cloudy

10-Nov

59.4

169

260

Yes

Cloudy

17-Nov

82.9

169

260

Yes

Fine

24-Nov

44.1

169

260

Yes

Fine

CD4  Shan On House

7-Nov

41.0

176

260

Yes

Fine

13-Nov

55.2

176

260

Yes

Cloudy

20-Nov

54.9

176

260

Yes

Fine

27-Nov

64.5

176

260

Yes

Cloudy

CD5  South Horizons Phase IV ¡V Block 25

7-Nov

44.5

169

260

Yes

Fine

13-Nov

69.2

169

260

Yes

Cloudy

20-Nov

66.2

169

260

Yes

Fine

27-Nov

63.3

169

260

Yes

Cloudy

DTB1  Site boundary of Telegraph Bay barging point

7-Nov

47.2

156

260

Yes

Fine

13-Nov

76.8

156

260

Yes

Cloudy

20-Nov

61.7

156

260

Yes

Fine

27-Nov

79.7

156

260

Yes

Cloudy

Note: Please refer to Figures 3 to 6 and 9 for the location of construction air quality monitoring stations

 

 

 

3.2                        Noise

 

Monitoring Methodology

Monitoring was conducted using B&K sound analysis equipment ¡V B&K SLM 2250.  Microphone was extended 1 meter from building facades and oriented towards the works area.

 

Calibration Requirements

B&K 2250 sound level meters and B&K 4231 calibrators which complied with the International Electrotechnical Commission Publication 651:1979 (Type 1) and 804:1985 (Type 1), specification as referred to in the Technical Memoranda to the NCO were used for the impact monitoring. The sound level meters and calibrators are verified by the certified laboratory or manufacturer once every two years to ensure they perform to the same level of accuracy as stated in the manufacturer¡¦s specifications. The calibration records are shown in Appendix C.

 

Immediately prior to and following each set of measurements at any NSR, the accuracy of the sound level meter was checked using an acoustic calibrator generating a known sound pressure level at a known frequency.  If the calibration levels before and after the measurement differs by more than 1.0dB, the measurement shall be repeated to obtain a reliable result (note: maximum deviation during this initial baseline monitoring period was 0.3dB). Periods of prolonged or repeated overloading of the sound level meter detector were avoided by setting the meter with adequate headroom prior to commencing measurements.  Measurements were recorded to the nearest 0.1 dB, with values of 0.05 being rounded up. 

 

Monitoring Results

Impact monitoring of LAeq, 30min noise levels was undertaken to measure construction noise levels in accordance with the Updated EM&A Manual at the monitoring locations as shown in Table 1. The monitoring was conducted during the course of construction works, please refer to S2.2 for major construction activities of the respective SIL(E) civil works contracts in the reporting month. Weather conditions throughout the monitoring period were mild with light wind of not exceeding 2-3m/s on average.

 

Noise monitoring results are presented in the following table and graphical plot for are presented in Appendix D.

 

Date

Time

LAeq (dBA)

Limit Level (dBA)

Compliance

(Yes/No)

Weather Condition

CN1  San Wui Commercial Society of HK Chan Pak Sha School 

5-Nov

15:30

65.2

70#

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

11-Nov

15:25

66.1

70#

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

18-Nov

14:45

68.0

70#

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

25-Nov

14:55

67.6

70#

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

CN2  Holy Spirit Seminary 

4-Nov

16:01

64.1

70#

Yes

Cloudy, wind <5m/s

11-Nov

16:05

65.5

70#

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

18-Nov

16:15

63.1

70#

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

25-Nov

16:03

64.2

70#

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

CN3  Shun Fung Building 

7-Nov

09:30

68.1

75#

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

13-Nov

10:40

70.2

75#

Yes

Cloudy, wind <5m/s

20-Nov

10:50

69.1

75#

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

27-Nov

10:45

67.6

75#

Yes

Cloudy, wind <5m/s

CN4  South Horizons Phase IV ¡V Block 25 Dover Court

7-Nov

11:00

69.5

75#

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

13-Nov

11:15

68

75#

Yes

Cloudy, wind <5m/s

20-Nov

11:10

67.5

75#

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

27-Nov

10:50

68.6

75#

Yes

Cloudy, wind <5m/s

CN5  TWGHs Jockey Club Rehabilitation Complex Block A 

4-Nov

15:10

64.2

75

Yes

Cloudy, wind <5m/s

11-Nov

15:20

63.1

75

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

18-Nov

15:25

64.5

75

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

25-Nov

15:05

63.2

75

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

NTB1  Outside Aegean Terrace 

7-Nov

10:15

61.3

75

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

13-Nov

10:00

59.6

75

Yes

Cloudy, wind <5m/s

20-Nov

10:05

60.5

75

Yes

Fine, wind <5m/s

27-Nov

10:00

59.6

75

Yes

Cloudy, wind <5m/s

(#) Or updated prediction of noise levels as contained in Construction Noise Mitigation Measures Plan

 

3.3                        Water Quality

 

In accordance with the Silt Curtain Plan for Marine-based Decommissioning of Temporary Pier at Telegraph Bay submitted under EP condition 2.16(a), water quality monitoring will be carried out during the marine-based demolition works at the Telegraph Bay barging point. The baseline water quality monitoring at Telegraph Bay was scheduled and completed in August 2014. The Water Quality Baseline Monitoring Report for Marine-based Demolition work of the temporary pier at Telegraph Bay was submitted to EPD on 26 November 2014 and deposited at the EIAO Register OFfice on 4 December 2014.

 

Monitoring Methodology

 

Water quality was monitored in terms of the following parameters: Dissolved Oxygen (DO, mg/L) and Dissolved Oxygen Saturation (DO %), temperature (oC), pH, turbidity (NTU), salinity (ppt), suspended solids (mg/L) and water depth (m) in accordance with the EM&A Manual of the HKWDT project. All parameters were measured in-situ whereas SS shall be determined by the laboratory.

 

Water samples were taken with a water sampler, consisting of a transparent PVC cylinder of 2 litres that can be effectively sealed with cups at both ends. The water sampler has a positive latch system to keep it open and prevent premature closure until released by a messenger when the sampler arrives is at the pre-determined depth.

 

Measurement was taken at 3 water depths, namely, 1m below water surface, mid-depth and 1m above sea bed, except where the water depth less that 6m, the mid-depth station may be omitted. Should the water depth be less than 3m, only the mid-depth station was monitored.

 

Duplicate in-situ measurements and samples were collected and analyzed to ensure a robust statistically interpretable dataset. Where the difference in value between the first and second measurement of DO or turbidity parameters is more than 25% of the value of the first reading, the reading was discarded and further readings were taken.

 

Water samples were stored in high-density polythene bottles, packed in ice and delivered to the laboratory of ALS Technichem (HK) Ltd., a HOKLAS accredited laboratory. The SS analyses followed the standard method APHA 2540D with a detection limit of 1mg/L.

 

A digital depth detector was employed to determine the water depth at selected stations when flows permit.

 

Calibration Requirements

 

On-site monitoring equipment namely the salinity meter, pH meter, turbidity meter, dissolved oxygen meter and temperature meter were calibrated before use. The methodologies for the calibration are referred to the instruction manual provided by the manufactures respectively.  The calibration records are shown in Appendix C. Response of sensors and electrodes was checked with certified standard solutions before each use.    

 

 

Monitoring Results

 

Impact water quality monitoring was undertaken in accordance with the Silt Curtain Plan at the respective designated monitoring locations at Telegraph Bay as shown in Table 2 during the reporting period. Monitoring results and graphical plots are presented in Appendix D.

 

 

3.4                        Action taken in Event of Exceedance

 

There was no exceedance in air quality, noise and water quality monitoring parameters recorded in the reporting period, therefore no action was taken. 

 

 

4.                           LANDSCAPE AND VISUAL

 

4.1                        EM&A Requirements

 

The landscape and visual mitigation measures undertaken by the contractors during the construction phase have been audited on a regular basis according to the EM&A Manual.

 

4.2                        Site Audit Results

 

Regular inspections and audits were conducted by the Certified Arborist as required by the EP and it was found that the transplanting works and the tree protection works being carried out by the civil works and transplantation contractors were in accordance with the EP/ EIA. Necessary tree removal or protection works were being carried out in accordance with the EP/ EIA or approved Tree Removal Application.  No non-compliance was identified in the reporting period.

 

Retained Trees

 

No immediate hazards were noted for any of the OVTs during reporting period.

Health conditions of the two retained and pruned trees, Ficus elastica, located at Wong Chuk Hang San Wai have been monitored. The contractor had enhanced the tree protection zone and was reminded to properly maintain the protection zone.

 

Transplanted Tree

 

Total of 464 trees of the SIL(E) had been transplanted as of the reporting month. They were mostly transplanted to the holding nursery at Chung Hom Shan and Kellett Bay, permanent receptor sites such as Lok Ma Chau, Telegraph Bay or in-situ under project areas.

 

 

5.                           ECOLOGY

 

5.1                        EM&A Requirements

 

Auditing of the ecological mitigation measures during the construction phase have been carried out on a regular basis according to the EM&A Manual.

 

5.2                        Site Audit Results

 

Ardeid Night Roost

 

Regular inspections to the works areas around the ardeid night roost have been conducted by the ecologist to check the ecological mitigation measures with regard to the ardeids at Wong Chuk Hang Nullah. Inspections of the ardeid night roost have been made for any active ardeid nests. Whilst ardeids have never been recorded nesting at this site, precautionary checks for active nests or signs of breeding have been made.

 

Monthly monitoring of the ardeid night roost location was also conducted by the ecologist from a vantage point, at Ap Lei Chau Bridge (on the Wong Chuk Hang side), with an unobstructed view over the area. According to the EM&A Manual, the surveys will commence approximately one hour before sunset and continue for 20 minutes after sunset, or until nightfall, which comes sooner. Any aggregation of night roosting ardeid in the degraded woodland or adjacent area have been located and counted.

 

During the reporting month, the monthly night ardeid survey was conducted on 21st November 2014 commenced at 1635hr. No ardeids was observed roosted at this location.

 

Nevertheless, the roosting site at Wong Chuk Hang shall be maintained in good condition, and proper mitigation measures will be kept for the tree protection within the site. Proper tree protection measures have been implemented as far as practicable by the contractor to the current and potential roost trees retained on site.

 

Plant Species of Conservation Interest

 

Detailed field survey led by the ecologist was undertaken in March and early May 2011 to ascertain the presence of any rare or protected flora species to be affected. The surveys covered all above ground works areas of the project and the survey results were presented in the Detailed Transplanting Baseline Survey Report submitted under the Environmental Permit.

 

As in the Detailed Transplantating Baseline Survey Report, two plant species of conservation interest recorded in the degraded woodland to the south of Wong Chuk Hang Nullah, namely herb Houttuynia cordata and tree Aquilaria sinensis (including seedlings), and planted young tree Ailanthus fordii (including seedlings) recorded in a plantation area near Hong Kong Park will be influenced by the project works. Other plant species of conservation interest identified will be protected on-site and appropriate tree protection measures would be established if needed. Health condition of the most plant species protected in-situ generally remained unchanged as in the Detailed Transplanting Baseline Survey Report. However, it is noted that health condition of Ailanthus fordii (tree no. OCP-T2231), which is outside the active works area at Wong Chuk Hang San Wai, was found to remain in generally fair physiologically condition. Two Aquilaria sinensis, which are located outside the active works area to the north of Nam Fung Road, were found in very poor health condition and suspected to be dead specimens. The two transplanted Aquilaria sinensis have been removed in Nov 2013.

 

Regular monitoring on the transplanted A. fordii within the works area has been conducted. The transplanted A. fordii were in fair health condition and protection fences have been maintained around the receptor sites. Condition of one transplanted young seedling A. fordii has grown satisfactorily with new leaves developed from the apical bud. while the retained tree T3 has remained in satisfactory condition.

 

According to the Transplanting Proposal for H. cordata submitted in Sep 2011, post transplantation maintenance period were undertaken throughout the 12-month and have been completed.

6.                           WASTE MANAGEMENT

 

Mitigation measures on waste management have been implemented in accordance with the site waste management plans for the respective civil works contracts. The C&D materials have been disposed of at the public fill reception facilities while C&D wastes have been disposed of at the landfills. Operation of the barging point at Telegraph Bay has been terminated by September 2014. Quantities of wastes disposed in the reporting period are summarized in the following table:

 

Contract No

Inert C&D Materials Disposed at Public Fill (m3)

Inert C&D Materials Reused (m3)

Non-inert Waste Disposed at Landfill (m3)

Chemical Waste

to Designated Treatment Facility (litre/ kg)

Reporting Period: November 2014

Contract 901

11,674

3,040

90

0

Contract 902

3,197

4,338

624

404

Contract 903

1,631

14

90

500

Contract 904

284

0

122

0

Contract 908

98

0

516

0

 

7.                           RECORD OF ENVIRONMENTAL COMPLAINTS

 

There was no environmental complaint referred by EPD in the reporting period.

 

 

8.                           RECORD OF NON-COMPLIANCES

 

There was no non-compliance identified in the reporting period. 

 

 

9.                           RECORD OF NOTIFICATIONS OF SUMMONS AND PROSECUTIONS

 

No summon or prosecution related to environmental issue was received or made against the Project in the reporting period. 

 

 

10.                      STATUS OF STATUTORY SUBMISSIONS

 

10.1                    Submissions required under Environmental Permit

 

A summary of the status of submissions required under the SIL(E) Environmental Permit as of 30 November 2014 is shown below:

 

EP Clause No.

Description of Submission

Status

1.11

Commencement date of construction

Submitted on 25 May 2011

 

1.14

Commencement date of operation

To be submitted no later than 2 months prior to commencement of operation of the Project

 

 

2.1 & 2.2

Employment of IEC & ET

Submitted on 6 Apr 2011

 

2.3

Employment of Qualified Ecologist

Submitted on 6 Apr 2011

 

2.4

Employment of Certified Arborist

Updated Certified Arborist submitted on 19 Aug 2013

 

2.5

Management organization of main construction companies

 

Updated main construction companies submitted on 15 Jun 2012

2.6

Construction programme & EP submission schedule

 

Submitted on 10 Jun 2011

 

2.7

Set up of Community Liaison Group

Submitted on 20 Apr 2011

 

2.8

Updated EM&A Manual

 

EP Condition fulfilled dated 13 February 2012

 

2.9

Construction Noise Mitigation Measures Plan

Updated Construction Noise Mitigation Measures Plan submitted on 11 May 2012 and EP Condition fulfilled date 22 May 2012

2.11

Construction & demolition materials management plan for barging points

Revised Construction & Demolition Materials Management Plan re-submitted on 7 January 2014.

 

2.13 (a )

Ecological planting & landscape plan

Revised plan submitted on 22 May 2014

, EP Condition fulfilled dated 27 Jun 2014

 

2.13 (b )

As built drawings of ecological planting & landscape works

To be submitted no later than 1 month after completion of planting works (at Wong Chuk Hang nullah)

 

2.13 (c )

Final monitoring report of ecological planting & landscape works

To be submitted no later than 1 month after completion of the 3-year post planting care and maintenance period

 

2.14 (a )

Detailed transplanting baseline survey report for plant species of conservation interest

Resubmitted on 8 Sep 2011 and no further comment received

 

2.14 (b )

Transplantation proposal for plant species of conservation interest

H. cordata:

EP Condition fulfilled dated 15 Sep 2011

Aq. sinensis:

EP Condition fulfilled dated 21 Feb 2012

Ai. fordii:

EP Condition fulfilled dated 18 Oct 2011

2.14 (c )

As built drawings of transplanting works for plant species of conservation interest

H. cordata:

EP Condition fulfilled dated 15 Sep 2011

Aq. sinensis:

EP Condition fulfilled dated 2 May 2012

Ai. fordii:

EP Condition fulfilled dated 22 Dec 2011

 

2.15

Tree protection plan

Updated Tree protection plan submitted on 4 May 2012 and EP Condition fulfilled dated 30 May 2012

 

2.16(a )

Silt curtain plan

For Aberdeen Channel:

EP Condition fulfilled dated 12 Aug 2011

For Telegraph Bay:

EP Condition fulfilled dated 14 Dec 2011

Water Quality Baseline Monitoring Report for Marine-based Demolition work of the temporary pier at Telegraph Bay was submitted to EPD on 26 Nov 2014 and deposited in EIAO Registered Office on 4 Dec 2014

 

2.17(b)

Sample test results for on-site re-use of marine sediment

 

EP Condition fulfilled dated 26 Apr 2013

 

2.17(c)

Sediment Sampling Report

EP Condition fulfilled dated 11 Jun 2014

 

2.25

Operational groundborne noise review plan

Resubmitted on 2 Jul 2014 and EP Condition fulfilled dated 22 Jul 2014

 

2.26

Operational groundborne noise mitigation measures plan

Resubmitted on 2 Jul 2014 and EP Condition fulfilled dated 22 Jul 2014

 

2.27

As built drawings for operational groundborne noise mitigation measures

To be submitted no later than 1 month after completion of tracks installation

 

2.29

As built drawings for operational airborne noise mitigation measures on viaduct section

To be submitted no later than 1 month after completion of noise mitigation measures installation on viaduct section

 

2.30

Noise performance test report

To be submitted no later than 1 month prior to commencement of operation of the Project

 

2.31

Fixed plant noise audit report

To be submitted no later than 1 month prior to commencement of operation of the Project

 

2.32

Visual & landscape plan

Part1-Site No.6 Nam Fung Portal:

EP Condition fulfilled dated 25 Jun 2013

Part2- Chung Hom Shan Magazine Site:

EP Condition fulfilled dated 13 Oct 2014

Part3- EPIW Footbridge to Ap Lei Chau Esate:

Submitted on 28 Nov 2014

 

3.1

Environmental Monitoring and Audit Requirements

Termination of water quality monitoring at Aberdeen Channel approved on 23 Dec 2013

 

Requirements of noise and air quality impact monitoring at Telegraph Bay as recommended in the C&DMMP was fulfilled on 6 Nov 2014.

 

3.3

Baseline monitoring report

EP Condition fulfilled dated 21 Feb 2012

 

3.4

Monthly EM&A reports

Submit within 2 weeks after the end of the reporting month

 

4.2

Internet address of EM&A and project data

Submitted on 25 Jul 2011

 

 

 

10.2                    Statutory Permits and Licenses

A summary of the status of all relevant environmental permit and licenses as of 30 November 2014 is shown below:

 

Description

Effective Date

Expiry Date

Environmental Permit for South Island Line (East)

EP-407/2010/E

29/8/2014

 

N/A

 

 

 

 

Contract 901

 

 

 

Chemical Waste Producer Licence

5213-124-K3004-01

23/5/2011

N/A

Waste Disposal (Trucks)

7012859

1/6/2011

N/A

Water Discharge Licence

WT00015547-2013

26/3/2013

31/7/2016

CNP for SEE Shaft and Stationbox

GW-RS0873-14

1/9/2014

28/2/2015

CNP for Large Plants Delivery

GW-RS0864-14

11/9/2014

9/3/2015

CNP for Ventilation Shaft Dismantling

GW-RS0560-14

27/6/2014

25/12/2014

CNP for Ventilation Shaft Dismantling (Renewal)

submitted on 19 Nov 2014

 

 

CNP for A&A works at Admiralty Station

GW-RS0497-14

10/6/2014

8/12/2014

CNP for A&A works at Admiralty Station (Renewal)

GW-RS1337-14

9/12/2014

19/5/2015

CNP for crane operation for ventilation fan

GW-RS1308-14

23/11/2014

30/11/2014

 

 

 

 

Contract 902

 

 

 

Chemical Waste Producer Licence (Nam Fung)

5213-175-N2206-12

24/6/2011

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer Licence (HK Park)

5213-124-N2345-02

28/10/2011

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer Licence (Telegraph Bay)

5213-171-N2206-24

17/4/2012

N/A

Waste Disposal (Trucks)

7012912            

26/5/2011

N/A

Waste Disposal (Vessels)

7015920

14/5/2014

2/9/2014

Water Discharge Licence for HK Park

WT00009688-2011

22/7/2011

31/7/2016

Water Discharge Licence for Nam Fung Path

WT00009749-2011

22/7/2011

31/7/2016

Water Discharge Licence for CHS Magazine

WT00009842-2011

11/8/2011

31/8/2016

Water Discharge Licence for Telegraph Bay Barging Point

WT00010649-2011

27/10/2011

31/10/2016

CNP for Nam Fung 24-hour Tunnel Excavation (Drop Gate at CH1200)

GW-RS1233-14

3/11/2014

2/5/2015

CNP for HK Park 24-hour Shaft Excavation

GW-RS1240-14

13/11/2014

12/2/2015

CNP for Telegraph Bay reinstatement

GW-RS1134-14

15/10/2014

14/4/2015

CNP for Chung Hom Shan Magazine site reinstatement

GW-RS1085-14

6/10/2014

5/01/2015

 

 

 

 

Contract 903

 

 

 

Chemical Waste Producer Licence

(Ocean Park Station)

5213-175-L2174-31

14/6/2011

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer Licence

(Ap Lei Bridge)

5213-175-L2174-32

30/6/2011

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer Licence

(Zone D)

5213-175-L2174-33

30/6/2011

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer Licence

(Nam Long Shan Sitting Out Area)

5213-175-L2174-34

30/6/2011

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer Licence

(Wong Chuk Hang Station)

5213-175-L2174-35

30/6/2011

N/A

Waste Disposal

7012721

12/5/2011

N/A

Water Discharge Licence for Ap Lei Chau  Bridge

WT00009838-2011

5/8/2011

31/8/2016

Water Discharge Licence for for all pier areas Zone B

WT00009931-2011

16/8/2011

31/8/2016

Water Discharge Licence for OCP station

WT00010501-2011

3/10/2011

31/10/2016

Water Discharge Licence for Zone D

WT00010319-2011

3/10/2011

31/10/2016

Water Discharge Licence for Zone C

WT00010648-2011

24/10/2011

31/10/2016

Water Discharge Licence for WCH Station

WT00014046-2012

24/9/2012

31/8/2016

Water Discharge Licence for Utilities Work Area Along Heung Yip Road

WT00014047-2012

25/9/2012

30/9/2017

Water Discharge Licence for Kwun Hoi Path

WT00015968-2013

2/5/2013

31/5/2018

Water Discharge Licence for Nam Long Shan Road Sitting out area

WT00018070-2013

2/1/2014

31/1/2019

Water Discharge Licence for Yip Kan Street

WT00018301-2014

18/2/2014

28/2/2019

CNP for ABWF in WCH Station

Renewal of GW-RS1453-13

GW-RS0588-14

27/06/2014

26/12/2014

CNP for Noise Barrier Installation in Zone E Viaduct (E3-E4)

GW-RS0824-14

05/08/2014

31/12/2014

CNP for Noise Barrier Installation in Zone C Viaduct (C9-C16) (Renewal of GW-RS0118-14)

GW-RS0829-14

11/08/2014

31/12/2014

CNP for Noise Barrier Installation in Zone D Viaduct (D0-D4) (Renewal of GW-RS0134-14)

GW-RS0845-14

12/08/2014

31/12/2014

CNP for WCH Footbridge Construction

GW-RS0793-14

31/07/2014

31/12/2014

CNP for Noise Barrier Installation in Zone B

GW-RS0993-14

12/09/2014

11/03/2015

CNP for ABWF works in OCP Station (Renewal of GW-RS0119-14)

GW-RS0878-14

20/08/2014

18/02/2015

CNP for Noise Barrier Installation in Zone D Viaduct (D8-D12) (Renewal of GW-RS0332-14)

GW-RS1137-14

19/10/2014

12/04/2015

CNP for Zone D (Water pump for D13 Stoplog) (Renewal of GW-RS0354-14)

GW-RS1186-14

29/10/2014

28/04/2015

CNP for Noise Barrier Installation in Zone B (B4)

GW-RS1180-14

29/10/2014

31/12/2014

 

 

 

 

Contract 904

 

 

 

Chemical Waste Producer License for

ALC Bridge Rd near Sham Wan Towers

5111-174-L2758-04

4/8/2011

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer License for

ALC Bridge Rd near Harbour Mission School

5111-174-L2758-03

4/8/2011

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer License for

ALC Main Street near Sunny Court

5111-174-L2758-05

4/8/2011

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer License for

Lei Tung Estate Rd near Kaifong Primary School

5111-174-L2758-02

4/8/2011

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer License for

Lee Nam Rd Sitting Out Area

5111-174-L2758-01

4/8/2011

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer License for

Lee Nam Rd Sitting Out Area No. 2

5111-174-L2758-07

4/8/2011

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer License for

Yi Nam Rd intersect with Lee Nam Rd & SOH Drive

5111-174-L2758-06

4/8/2011

N/A

Waste Disposal (Trucks)

7012979

25/6/2011

N/A

Waste Disposal (Vessels)

7015570

23/7/2012

N/A

Water Discharge License for

ALC Bridge Rd near Sham Wan Towers

WT00009781-2011

5/8/2011

31/8/2016

Water Discharge License for

ALC Bridge Rd near Harbour Mission School

WT00009778-2011

5/8/2011

31/8/2016

Water Discharge License for

ALC Main Street near Sunny Court

WT00009777-2011

5/8/2011

31/8/2016

Water Discharge License for

Lei Tung Estate Rd near Kaifong Primary School

WT00009780-2011

5/8/2011

31/8/2016

Water Discharge License for

Lee Nam Rd Sitting Out Area

WT00009779-2011

5/8/2011

31/8/2016

Water Discharge License for

Lee Nam Rd Sitting Out Area No. 2

WT00009783-2011

5/8/2011

31/8/2016

Water Discharge License for

Yi Nam Rd intersect with Lee Nam Rd & SOH Drive

WT00009775-2011

5/8/2011

31/8/2016

Water Discharge License for Barging Point at Lee Nam Road J/O Lee King Street

WT00014348-2012

5/11/2012

30/11/2017

CNP for LET Ent B Structure Works

GW-RS0833-14

8/8/2014

7/11/2014

CNP for SOH Package 2 and 3 Pumping Test and grouting station near HK Electric

GW-RS0690-14

20/7/2014

19/1/2015

CNP for LWB Tunnel and associated tunnel work ¡V tunnel breakthrough

GW-RS0844-14

16/8/2014

15/11/2014

CNP for Anti-skid work at Lei Tung Estate Road

GW-RS1059-14

6/10/2014

14/11/2014

CNP for drainage work at Lee Wing Street

GW-RS1057-14

6/10/2014

31/12/2014

CNP for 24hr PCW at Lei Tung Station (Concourse Level), Adit B and Lei Tung Entrance Shaft

GW-RS1155-14

21/10/2014

16/4/2015

 

 

 

 

Contract 908

 

 

 

Waste Disposal

7014839

20/3/2012

N/A

Chemical Waste Producer Licence

5211-175-H2913-42

11/4/2012

N/A

Water Discharge Licence

WT000013232-2012

29/6/2012

31/5/2017

CNP for water pumping, water jetting unit, water treatment plant, Grout mixer, Grout pump, Hand drill and mobile platform

GW-RS0463-14

10/5/2014

9/11/2014

CNP for water pumping, water jetting unit, water treatment plant, Grout mixer, Grout pump, Hand drill and mobile platform (Renewal)

GW-RS1255-14

10/11/2014

9/5/2015

 

 

11.                      SITE INSPECTIONS

 

11.1                    Implementation of Environmental Mitigation Measures

 

Regular site inspections were undertaken by the ET in accordance with the EM&A Manual to check the implementation of environmental mitigation measures in the EIA. The contractors' performance on environmental matters was assessed. The environmental mitigation measures are being implemented by the civil works contractors where appropriate. A schedule of the implementation of mitigation measures identified in the SIL(E) EIA is given in Appendix F.

 

11.2                    Observations 

        

The findings from the site inspections and the associated recommendations on improvement to the environmental protection and pollution control works were raised to the contractors for reference and/ or action. Observations against the implementation of the mitigation measures recommended in the EP/ EIA are summarized as follows:

 

Item

Description

Follow up Status

 

Contract 901

 

1

The contractor was reminded to provide drip trays for chemicals and clear the content in drip trays as chemical waste.

On-going

2

The contractor was reminded to repair the pH neutralization unit of wastewater treatment system and improve the effluent quality.

On-going

 

3

The contractor was reminded to keep machineries away from Tree Protection Zone to avoid damages to trees..

Improved and standard to be maintained

4

The contractor was reminded to cover the stock of over 20 bags cement entirely by impervious sheeting.

Improved and standard to be maintained

5

The contractor was reminded to clear refuse and silt deposited in drainage.

On-going

 

Contract 902

 

1

The contractor was reminded to properly maintain the site drainage system and provide adequate silt removal facilities.

Improved and standard to be maintained

2

The contractor was reminded to maintain dust suppression measures.

Improved and standard to be maintained

3

The contractor was reminded to properly maintain the dust and noise control measures at barging point

Improved and standard to be maintained

4

The contractor was reminded to maintain proper tree protection works

On-going

 

Contract 903

 

1

The contractor was reminded to maintain proper mitigation measures in the nullah for the effluent control.

On-going

2

The contractor was reminded to maintain dust suppression measures.

On-going

3

The contractor was reminded to maintain the access and egress free from dust and keep good housekeeping.

 

On-going

4

The contractor was reminded to handle the chemical wasteon site properly

 

On-going

5

The contractor was reminded to maintain tree protection works.

On-going

 

Contract 904

 

1

The contractor have provided the noise mitigation measures for the noisy works and was reminded to properly maintain the noise mitigation measures.

Improved and standard to be maintained

2

The contractor was reminded to provide drip tray to chemicals being used on site.

Improved and standard to be maintained

3

The contractor was reminded to maintain good housekeeping.

Improved and standard to be maintained

4

The contractor was reminded to provide adequate silt removal facilities, as well as properly maintain the site drainage system and discharge.

Improved and standard to be maintained

5

The contractor was reminded to cover the stockpile and provide frequent watering.

Improved and standard to be maintained

6

The contractor was reminded to maintain proper tree protection and maintenance works.

Improved and standard to be maintained

 

 

 

Contract 908

 

1

The contractor was reminded that the stockpiles should be covered entirely by impervious sheetings.

On-going

2

The contractor was reminded to remove C&D wastes in a timely manner

On-going

 

11.3                    Solid and Liquid Waste Management Status

 

Base on the findings of the site inspections, the Contractors¡¦ performance in solid and liquid waste management were acceptable and compliance with the EIA requirements were demonstrated. The current management standard should be maintained.

 

11.4                    Other Notable Events

 

IEC Site Inspections

 

The IEC conducted site inspections for respective works areas on 12, 25 and 27 November 2014. Minor irregularities including provision of movable noise barriers as necessary and enhancing site drainage system and dust suppression measures were observed during the site inspections. Follow up actions had been taken by the respective civil works contractors.

 

 

12.                      FUTURE KEY ISSUES

 

Future key issues envisaged in the coming month include noise, dust and wastewater from site works, disposal of C&D wastes arising as well as tree protection on site. The ET will continue the implementation of the EM&A programme in accordance to the EM&A Manual. 

 

 

13.                      CONCLUSIONS

 

It is concluded from the environmental monitoring and audit works for the SIL(E) Project that the construction works were undertaken in an appropriately environmentally sensitive manner in the reporting period. The environmental protection and pollution control measures provided by the respective civil works contractors were generally acceptable apart from some minor irregularities which were rectified timely by the contractors.

 

The ET will continue the implementation of the EM&A programme in accordance to the EM&A Manual and to a level consistent with MTRCL's Corporate Sustainability Policy.