12.0.0.1 The Implementation Schedules have been prepared in accordance with the format contained in Appendix 3 of the Study Brief. Each of the Implementation Schedules have the following column headings:
EIA Ref:
12.0.0.2 This denoted the section number or reference from the EIA Report Main text.
EM&A Log Ref:
12.0.0.3 This denotes the sequential number of each of the recommended mitigation measures specified in the Implementation Schedule.
Environmental Protection Measures
12.0.0.4 This denotes the recommended mitigation measures, courses of action or subsequent deliverables that are to be adopted, undertaken or delivered to avoid, minimise or ameliorate predicted environmental impacts.
Location/Duration of Measures/Timing of Completion of Measures
12.0.0.5 This indicates the spatial area in which the recommended mitigation measures are to be implemented together with details of the programming or timing of their implementation.
Implementation Agent
12.0.0.6 This denotes where the responsibility lies for the implementation of the recommended mitigation measures.
Implementation Stage
12.0.0.7 This denotes the stage at which the recommended mitigation measures are to be implemented; either during the Design, Construction, Operation or Decommissioning.
Relevant Legislation & Guidelines
12.0.0.8 This section defines the controlling legislation or guidelines that are either required to be complied with, or should be complied with as good practice.
12.0.0.9 The Implementation Schedules for recommended mitigation measures are summarized in Table 12.1.
Table 12.1 Implementation Schedule for Recommended Mitigation Measures
EIA* Ref. |
EM&A Log Ref |
Recommended Mitigation Measures |
Objectives of the Recommended Measure & Main Concerns to Address |
Location of the Measure |
Who to Imple-ment the Measure? |
When to Implement the Measure? |
What Requirements or Standards for the Measure to Achieve? |
S2.6 |
S2 |
Air Quality and Dust Mitigation Measures |
APCO (Cap. 311); Air Pollution Control (Construction Dust) Regulation; EIAO-TM |
||||
During Construction Phase Relevant dust control requirements set out in Parts I, III and IV of Schedule 1 of the Air Pollution Control (Construction Dust) Regulation should be met. The Contractor is required to adopt dust reduction measures while carrying out construction works. Reference is made to the Section 2.7 of the EIA Report. |
To ensure that dust emission is minimised during the construction phase of the road works |
All Construction Sites |
HyD |
Construction Phase |
|||
S3.5.1 |
S3 |
Construction Noise Mitigation Measures |
NCO (Cap. 400); EIAO (Cap. 499); EIAO-TM; PP-TM; GW-TM; DA-TM |
||||
The following construction phase mitigation measures should be considered and adopted during construction phase by the Contractor:
For details, please refer to Section 3.5.1 of the EIA Report. |
To reduce construction noise impact |
All Construction Sites |
HyD |
Construction Phase |
|||
Special Measures to be Carried Out To minimize the potential of adverse impact, the following measures are specifically recommended to be adopted for DBL: i) Purpose-built construction site hoardings are to be installed in such a way to act as an acoustic screen/noise barrier for active carriageway construction work proximity to NSRs in locations shown in Figure 3.20(A, B). The boundary wall or hoarding shall:
Temporary noise barriers should be placed close to the noisy mechanical equipment in case the purpose-built site hoarding could not effectively screen the NSRs. ii) Quiet plant/power mechanical equipment of sound power level lowered than those listed in Table 3 of the GW-TM shall be used for all construction sites as far as possible. |
To protect affected NSRs from construction noise impacts |
All Construction Sites |
HyD |
Construction Phase |
|||
Specific Measures at NSRs In dealing with the construction noise at the four critical NSRs (E8, E13, E4 and E12), the mitigation measures as outlined in the Table 3.12 of the EIA report should be followed. The contractor is required to submit a construction noise mitigation proposal in consultant with the Environmental Team for Independent Environmental Checker and EPD's approval. The Contractor shall also liaise with the NSR E4 Lam Tei Gospel School for proper arrangement of construction work during examination periods and non-school dates.
|
To protect critical NSRs |
Near NSRs (E8, E13, E4 and E12) |
HyD |
Construction Phase |
|||
**The above measures are to be followed and complied in the area at Ngau Hom Shek entrusted to SWC Project. Particular attention is drawn to the purpose-built site hoarding in Figure 3.20A and the requirement for quiet plant. |
Area at Ngau Hom Shek entrusted to SWC Project |
HyD & HyD(SWC) |
Construction Phase |
||||
A detailed review of the construction noise assessment shall be carried out by the Construction Contractor and the Environmental Team prior to the construction work commencement during the construction stage to re-conform the requirements for construction noise mitigation. The review should be carried out using contemporary information regarding construction equipment and construction programme. | To review the construction noise assessment and noise mitigation measures | All construction site | HyD | Construction Phase | |||
S3.5.2 |
S3 |
Operation Noise Mitigation Measures |
EIAO-TM |
||||
Details of proposed noise barriers can be referred to Figure 3.2 and are summarized as Table 3.13 of the EIA Report. These noise barriers shall be designed and constructed to comply with the Guidelines On Design of Noise Barriers - Environmental Protection Department & Highways Department of the Government of the Hong Kong SAR, First Issue March, 2001. The setup for typical type of proposed noise barriers is given in Figures 10.6.3.6 & 10.6.3.7. |
To protect against road traffic noise impact on various existing and future sensitive receivers in HSKNDA areas. |
Alignment of DBL |
HyD |
Design Phase and Operation Phase |
|||
S3.5.2 |
S3 |
Future Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures for Yuen Long Highway Dual-4 Widening Project |
EIAO-TM |
||||
For the future Yuen Long Highway Widening Project, the project shall consider and investigate for the proposed noise barriers as given in Table 3.14 "Summary of Additional Noise Barriers Likely Required for Dual-4 Configuration of YLH (assumed dual-4-lanes)" Mitigation measure at source listed out in S3.5.2.9 to S3.5.2.13 is to be investigated and provided to protect HSKNDA Area 3C NSRs. |
To protect NSRs against the road traffic noise from future dual-4 widening of YLH |
Yuen Long Highway |
HyD (DBL project and YLH widening dual-4 project) |
EIA stage for YLH Dual-4 Widening |
|||
S3.5.3 |
S3 |
Measures for Consideration by HSKNDA Project |
EIAO-TM |
||||
HSKNDA Project Team to consider measures list out in S3.5.3 together with the Table 3.15 "Summary of Noise Barriers to be Considered by Future HSKNDA Project" and Table 3.19 "Summary of Mitigation Measures and Constraints for HSKNDA"
|
To protect future NSRs in HSKNDA against cumulative noise impacts with the planned roads of HSKNDA |
Within planned roads of HSKNDA |
TDD & PlanD |
||||
S4.5 |
S4 |
Construction Water Mitigation Measures |
WPCO (Cap. 358); EIAO-TM; ProPECC Note PN1/94 |
||||
Local Stream Courses, Pipeworks and Drains
|
To mitigate the impact of construction and wastewater to local stream courses, pipeworks and drains. |
All DBL Construction Sites |
HyD |
Design and construction phase |
|||
Excavation and Filling Recommendations on mitigation measures are:
|
To minimise water quality impacts arising from excavation and filling activities |
All construction sites |
HyD |
Construction phase |
|||
Construction of Foundation and Road Sections
|
To minimise impacts to Deep Bay waters and mudflat arising from foundation and road section construction |
Construction sites and at bored piling sites located approx. 15m to the northwest of Deep Bay Road |
HyD |
Tender and construction phase |
|||
On Site Sewage Generation |
To avoid water pollution due to sewage generated from workforce |
All construction sites |
HyD |
Construction phase |
|||
Clean Site Policy |
To minimise water quality impacts through implementation of clean site policy |
All construction sites |
HyD |
Construction phase |
|||
Design and Planning The following items should be focused on:
|
To minimise water quality impacts through a good design and planning of the project |
All construction sites |
HyD |
Design and planning |
|||
Environmental Team and Site Management |
To monitor performance of water pollution control |
All construction sites |
HyD |
Construction phase |
|||
Good Housekeeping The following areas need to be implemented to achieve good housekeeping on site:
|
To minimise water quality impacts through good housekeeping |
All construction sites |
HyD |
Construction phase |
|||
Monitoring and Audit
|
To minimise water quality impacts through monitoring and audit |
All construction sites and works area near Ngau Hom Shek |
HyD |
Construction phase |
|||
S4.5 |
S4 |
Water Pollution Mitigation Measures Under Operation |
WPCO (Cap. 358); EIAO-TM; |
||||
Storm Runoff from Road Sections
|
To minimise water quality impacts from road runoff |
End section of the DBL alignment near Ngau Hom Shek |
HyD |
Operation phase |
|||
**Road Runoff from SWC Bridge |
To collect runoff from the SWC bridge |
SWC alignment |
HyD (SWC) |
Design and operation phase |
|||
|
To determine the effectiveness of the mitigation measure |
SWC alignment |
HyD (SWC) |
Operation phase |
|||
|
To collect road runoff |
SWC alignment |
HyD (SWC) |
Design phase |
|||
|
To prevent build-up of the pollutant load on the road surface and to prevent the pollutants from entering the Deep Bay waters and to Deep Bay mudflat |
SWC alignment |
HyD (SWC) |
Operation phase |
|||
**Accidental Spillage of Chemicals During Accidents An emergency response plan should be prepared. |
To prevent water pollution from accidental spillage of chemicals during accidents |
DBL alignment |
HyD and HyD (SWC) |
Design and Operation phase |
|||
S5.5 |
S5 |
**Construction Waste Management Measures |
At all construction sites
|
HyD
|
Design and Construction phase |
EIAO-TM; WDO, Waste Disposal (Chemical Waste)(General) Regulation (Cap 354); Land (Miscellaneous Provision) Ordinance (Cap. 28); Public Health and Municipal Services Ordinance (Cap. 132); Dumping at Sea Ordinance; PELB’s Waste Reduction Framework Plan (1998-2007); HKPSG; New Disposal Arrangements for Construction Waste; Code of Practice on the Packaging; Works Branch Technical Circular No. 6/92, No. 22/92, No. 2/93, No. 2/93B, No. 16/96, No.4/98, No.4/98A, No. 5/98, No. 5/99, No. 5/99A, No.19/99, No.5/99, No. 25/99A, No.25/99C, No. 3/00 & No. 12/00; ProPECC PN 1/94; EPD-TC No. 1-1-92 |
|
The Contractor should incorporate the recommendations in the EIA Report into a comprehensive on-site waste management plan. Such a management plan should incorporate site specific factors such as the designation of areas for the segregation and temporary storage of reusable and recyclable materials. Training and instruction of construction staff should be given at the site to increase awareness and draw attention to waste management issues and the need to minimise waste generation. The training requirement should be included in the site waste management plan. |
To ensure proper waste management |
All construction sites |
HyD |
Construction Phase |
|||
Waste management, control and mitigation measures shall be adopted for:
as recommended in Section 5.5.3 of the EIA Report |
To ensure proper waste management |
All construction sites |
HyD |
Construction Phase |
|||
Handling of Surplus and Deficient Fill Materials Other potential demands or of fill for each year during the period works shall be check against and identified in the Public Fill Committee (PFC) database of Annual Fill and Surpluses. Given the changing nature of the database and the resource requirements of other concurrent projects, the sources of demand for fill at the actual time of construction should be established during detailed design in consultation with the PFC. |
To identify the best ways to handle surplus or deficient fill materials
|
All construction sites |
HyD |
Design and Construction Phases |
|||
S6.4, 6.5, 6.6 |
S6 |
Land Contamination Mitigation Measures
|
EIAO-TM; ProPECC PN 3/94; EPD’s 1999 Guidance Notes for Investigation and Remediation of Contaminated Sites of: Petrol Filling Stations; Boatyards, and Car Repair/Dismantling Workshops (Guidance Notes) |
||||
Considering the rapid changing of landuses in the areas, the CAP should be updated with reference to concurrent site conditions. It shall be necessary to carry out a site appraisal to review the findings of the EIA, including the number and location of sampling points and testing parameters. Such revised CAP should be submitted to EPD for approval before the actual sampling works begin. This should be included in the finalised CAP in agreement with EPD. Upon receipt of the EPD’s approval, the CAP shall be implemented and the findings of the investigations shall be reported in the Contamination Assessment Report (CAR). If land contamination is confirmed, a Remediation Assessment Plan (RAP) shall be prepared, and both the CAR and the RAP shall be submitted as a combined report to the EPD for approval prior to the implementation of any remedial technology. If applicable and required in consultation with the EPD, the contaminated site shall be remediated in accordance with the approved CAR/RAP. Implementation of the RAP can begin once the CAR and RAP submissions are approved by the EPD. The CAP together with the sampling and testing work should be planned to start after the land is available to DBL through early negotiations or resumption and the subsequent CAR and RAP should be approved by the EPD before commencement of any construction work which may disturb the ground of the concerned sites. Contaminated soil should be remediated before construction work could be started on the concerned sites. |
To review the findings of EIA and formulate CAP and CAR to assess the land contamination |
At identified sites: Areas C1, C3, D, F, G, J, L M, B and K as in Section 6.4 of the EIA Report |
HyD |
After land resumption and during Construction Phase |
|||
During Construction Phase Standard good practice shall be implemented during the construction phase to minimise any potential exposure to contaminated soil or groundwater. These measures are outlined in Section 6.5.1 of the EIA Report. |
To minimize exposure to contaminated soil and groundwater during construction phase |
Identified contaminated sites in the CAR |
HyD |
Construction Phase |
|||
S7.5 S8.3 |
S7 |
Mitigation Measures on Ecological Impacts
|
EIAO (Cap. 499); EIAO-TM; Wild Animals Protection Ordinance (Cap. 170); Forests and Countryside Ordinance (Cap.96); Marine Parks Ordinance (Cap. 476); The Animals and Plants (Protection of Endangered Species) Ordinance (Cap. 187); PELB’s Technical Circular 1/97; CITES; Ramsar Convention; Bonn Convention; Convention on Biological Diversity |
||||
**Recommended mitigation measures should be implemented as shown in Table 7.32. Proposed Mitigation for Ecological Impacts. These measures are specified for construction phase and operation phase. |
Mitigation for ecological impacts
|
At all DBL Facilities
|
HyD
|
Construction and Operation Phase
|
|||
**A compensatory wetland is proposed to compensate for the habitat loss as given in Table 7.33. Details of proposed DBL wetland compensation area. A Habitat Creation and Management Plan should be prepared for the approval by AFCD.
|
Compensate for habitat loss
|
Ngau Hom Shek
|
Design & Construction by HyD and maintained by AFCD |
Design & Construction & Operation Phase
|
|||
S9.5 |
S8 |
Mitigation Measures on Cultural Heritage Impacts |
EIAO (Cap. 499); EIAO-TM; A&MO |
||||
The Chung Shan Cemetery (Permitted Burial Ground No. 22) The entire cemetery and each grave in the cemetery shall be recorded in details to the satisfaction of AMO of LCSD. The form of the recording should include written text, photographs, basic measurements and location plans. The content of the recording should include:
The recording of the graves should be undertaken by a qualified archaeologist and the results submitted to the AMO for study and record before the commencement of grave relocation. |
Record the affected Chun Shan Cemetery |
Burial Ground No. 22 affected by DBL |
HyD |
Before construction of the Burial Ground No.22 |
|||
**The Ngau Hom Shek Beach Site with Archaeological Significance
|
Archaeological Survey and Salvage Excavation |
Ngau Hom Shek Beach Site |
HyD (SWC) |
Before construction of the site |
|||
The Ngau Hom Shek Hill Site with Archaeological Significance |
Protect Ngau Hom Shek Hill Site |
Ngau Hom Shek Hill Site |
HyD |
During Construction Phase |
|||
The Lam Tei Site with Archaeological Significance The size of the Lam Tei Site is around 3,200 square metres and the site is entirely located within the impact zone of the DBL alignment (Figure 9.32 – 2). A rescue excavation therefore should be carried out in the project area with earthworks and building works in this area by the project proponent before the commencement of the DBL project. It is recommended to allocate 20 small test pits of 2 m x 2 m first in the excavation to locate the central area of the site with concentrated structural features. The initial test pits with important findings will then be expanded. The total size of salvage excavation is estimated 200 square metres and fieldwork will be completed within two months. |
Salvage Excavation |
Lam Tei Site |
HyD |
Before construction of the site |
|||
The Tsing Chuen Wai Site with Archaeological Significance |
Salvage Excavation |
Tsing Chuen Wai Site |
HyD |
Before construction of the site |
|||
S10.5.2 |
S9 |
Mitigation Measures on Visual and Landscape Impacts
|
EIAO (Cap.499.S.16); EIAO- TM; HKPSG; PELB-TC No. 3/94: WBTC No. 14/2002, no. 7/2002, 25/93, NO. 17/2002; 19/98; Geo Publication no.1/2000; HyD Guidance Note No. LU/GN/001; HyD practice Note No. LU/PN/001; HyDTC No. 10/2001 – Visibility of Directional Signs. |
||||
**During Construction Phase Recommended landscape and visual mitigation measures for impacts caused during the construction process are summarized as follows:
Note: * Denotes general good working practices to be employed. |
To minimize landscape and visual impacts during construction phase |
At all construction sites and DBL
|
HyD
|
Construction and Operation phase |
|||
**During Operation Phase Recommended landscape and visual mitigation measures for impacts caused during the operation phase are summarized as follows: |
To minimize landscape and visual impacts during construction phase |
At all construction sites and DBL
|
HyD
|
Construction and Operation phase |
|||
|
|||||||
S11 |
All |
Environmental Monitoring and Audit |
With reference to EM&A Manual |
||||
The following areas identified in the impact assessments shall require EM&A during construction and/or operational phase:
|
To monitoring and audit the construction and operational phase of the Project |
Areas covered DBL Project and Sensitive Receivers |
HyD |
Construction Phase and Operation Phase |
Note:
** highlighted DBL mitigation measures for SWC Project of Highways Department to
observe and comply with when carried out works at the entrusted area at Ngau Hom
Shek.
Measures Special/Critical mitigation measures in this DBL Project are bold and
underlined.
HyD Highways Department
TDD Territory Development Department
PlanD Planning Department
AFCD Agricultural, Fisheries and Conservation Department