SA1 to Agreement No. CE 54/2001 (CE)
WAN CHAI
DEVELOPMENT PHASE II
PLANNING AND
ENGINEERING REVIEW
ENVIRONMENTAL
IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORT
for
WAN CHAI DEVELOPMENT PHASE II AND CENTRAL-WAN CHAI
BYPASS
CONTENTS
Page
VOLUME 1 – WDII Project
Schedule 3 DP: Engineering
Feasibility Study of WDII Project
1.1 Project
Background........................................................................................... 1-1
1.2 WDII
Review................................................................................................... 1-2
1.3 Harbour-Front
Enhancement Review.................................................................. 1-3
1.4 Environmental
Impact Assessment..................................................................... 1-4
1.5 Objectives
and Scope of the EIA Study............................................................... 1-5
1.6 Designated
Projects under the EIAO.................................................................. 1-6
1.7 Relevant
Approved EIA Reports...................................................................... 1-10
1.8 Structure
of this EIA Report............................................................................. 1-10
2.1 Site Location..................................................................................................... 2-1
2.2 EIA
Study Area................................................................................................ 2-1
2.3 Review
of Previous EIAs................................................................................... 2-2
2.4 Project
Requirements, Scope and Benefits......................................................... 2-13
2.5 Consideration
of Alternatives and Development of Preferred Option................... 2-17
2.6 Construction
Methods and Engineering Requirements......................................... 2-33
2.7 Operation
of the Project................................................................................... 2-37
2.8 Works
Programme........................................................................................... 2-37
2.9 Related
Projects.............................................................................................. 2-38
3.1 Introduction....................................................................................................... 3-1
3.2 Environmental
Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Criteria......................... 3-1
3.3 Description
of the Environment........................................................................... 3-2
3.4 Sensitive
Receivers............................................................................................ 3-3
3.5 Identification
of Environmental Impacts............................................................... 3-6
3.6 Assessment
Methodology................................................................................... 3-8
3.7 Prediction
and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts........................................... 3-36
3.8 Mitigation
of Adverse Environmental Impacts.................................................... 3-49
3.9 Evaluation
of Residual Impacts......................................................................... 3-52
3.10 Environmental
Monitoring and Audit.................................................................. 3-55
3.11 Conclusion....................................................................................................... 3-56
4.1 Introduction....................................................................................................... 4-1
4.2 Environmental
Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Criteria......................... 4-1
4.3 Description
of the Environment........................................................................... 4-6
4.4 Sensitive
Receivers............................................................................................ 4-7
4.5 Assessment
Methodology................................................................................... 4-9
4.6 Identification
of Environmental Impacts............................................................. 4-17
4.7 Prediction
and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts........................................... 4-18
4.8 Mitigation
of Adverse Environmental Impacts.................................................... 4-22
4.9 Evaluation
of Residual Impacts......................................................................... 4-28
4.10 Construction
Activities during Restricted Hours................................................. 4-30
4.11 Environmental
Monitoring and Audit.................................................................. 4-32
4.12 Conclusion....................................................................................................... 4-33
5 HYDRODYNAMICS AND WATER QUALITY...................................................... 5-1
5.1 Introduction....................................................................................................... 5-1
5.2 Water
Sensitive Receivers................................................................................. 5-1
5.3 Environmental
Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Criteria......................... 5-2
5.4 Description
of the Environment........................................................................... 5-6
5.5 Identification
of Environmental Impact.............................................................. 5-10
5.6 Assessment
Methodology................................................................................. 5-13
5.7 Prediction
and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts........................................... 5-53
5.8 Mitigation
of Adverse Environmental Impacts.................................................... 5-83
5.9 Evaluation
of Residual Impacts......................................................................... 5-99
5.10 Environmental
Monitoring and Audit................................................................ 5-100
5.11 Conclusion..................................................................................................... 5-100
6.1 Introduction....................................................................................................... 6-1
6.2 Environmental
Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Criteria......................... 6-1
6.3 Assessment
Methodology................................................................................... 6-3
6.4 Baseline
Conditions............................................................................................ 6-6
6.5 Identification
of Potential Sources of Impact...................................................... 6-10
6.6 Prediction
and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts........................................... 6-10
6.7 Mitigation
Measures......................................................................................... 6-16
6.8 Evaluation
of Residual Impacts......................................................................... 6-21
6.9 Environmental
Audit......................................................................................... 6-21
6.10 Conclusion....................................................................................................... 6-22
7.1 Introduction....................................................................................................... 7-1
7.2 Environmental
Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Criteria......................... 7-1
7.3 Assessment
Methodology................................................................................... 7-1
7.4 Review
of Previous WDIICFS EIA Study........................................................... 7-1
7.5 Potential
Contaminative Land Uses..................................................................... 7-3
7.6 Sensitive
Receivers............................................................................................ 7-5
7.7 Identification
of Environmental Impacts............................................................... 7-5
7.8 Land
Contamination Assessment........................................................................ 7-7
7.9 Evaluation
and Prediction of Impacts................................................................. 7-12
7.10 Mitigation
Measures......................................................................................... 7-12
7.11 Residual
Environmental Impact......................................................................... 7-14
7.12 Environmental
Monitoring and Audit (EM&A) Requirements.............................. 7-14
7.13 Conclusion....................................................................................................... 7-14
8 SEWERAGE IMPACT AND SEWAGE TREATMENT
IMPLICATIONS............. 8-1
8.1 Introduction....................................................................................................... 8-1
8.2 Development
Proposals and Future Population..................................................... 8-1
8.3 Design
Criteria and Assumptions........................................................................ 8-1
8.4 Assessment
of Impact....................................................................................... 8-3
8.5 Proposed
Upgrading Works................................................................................ 8-6
9.1 Introduction....................................................................................................... 9-1
9.2 Environmental
Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Criteria......................... 9-1
9.3 Assessment
Methodology................................................................................... 9-2
9.4 Description
of the Environment........................................................................... 9-5
9.5 Identification
of Ecological Impacts................................................................... 9-14
9.6 Evaluation
of Ecological Impacts....................................................................... 9-16
9.7 Mitigation
of Adverse Environmental Impact..................................................... 9-21
9.8 Evaluation
of Residual Impacts......................................................................... 9-22
9.9 Evaluation
of Cumulative Impacts..................................................................... 9-23
9.10 Environmental
Monitoring and Audit.................................................................. 9-23
9.11 Conclusion....................................................................................................... 9-24
9.12 References...................................................................................................... 9-24
10. LANDSCAPE AND VISUAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT........................................ 10-1
10.1 Introduction..................................................................................................... 10-1
10.2 Environmental
Legislation, Standards and Guidelines.......................................... 10-2
10.3 Assessment
Methodology................................................................................. 10-3
10.4 Scope
and Content of the Study........................................................................ 10-7
10.5 Review
of Planning and Development Control Framework................................. 10-9
10.6 Comments
on Landscape and Visual Issues received during Consultations......... 10-12
10.7 Baseline
Study............................................................................................... 10-14
10.8 Landscape
Impact Assessment....................................................................... 10-35
10.9 Visual
Impact Assessment.............................................................................. 10-49
10.10 Conclusion..................................................................................................... 10-62
11.1 Introduction..................................................................................................... 11-1
11.2 Environmental
Legislation and Standards........................................................... 11-1
11.3 Assessment
Methodology................................................................................. 11-2
11.4 Baseline
Conditions.......................................................................................... 11-2
11.5 Geophysical
Survey.......................................................................................... 11-3
11.6 Mitigation
of Adverse Impacts.......................................................................... 11-4
11.7 Residual
Environmental Impact......................................................................... 11-4
11.8 Environmental
Monitoring and Audit Requirements............................................ 11-4
11.9 Conclusion....................................................................................................... 11-4
12 ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING AND AUDIT.............................................. 12-1
12.1 Introduction..................................................................................................... 12-1
12.2 Air
Quality Impact........................................................................................... 12-1
12.3 Noise
Impact................................................................................................... 12-3
12.4 Water
Quality Impact....................................................................................... 12-3
12.5 Waste
Management......................................................................................... 12-3
12.6 Land
Contamination......................................................................................... 12-4
12.7 Marine
Ecology............................................................................................... 12-4
12.8 Landscape
and Visual...................................................................................... 12-4
12.9 Cultural
Heritage............................................................................................. 12-5
14 EIA FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS..................................................... 14-1
14.1 Introduction..................................................................................................... 14-1
14.2 DP1 -
Central-Wanchai Bypass including its road tunnel..................................... 14-2
14.3 DP2 -
WDII major roads (including Road P2).................................................. 14-11
14.4 DP3 -
Reclamation works including associated dredging works......................... 14-15
14.5 DP4 -
Temporary typhoon shelter................................................................... 14-23
14.6 DP5 -
Wan Chai East Sewage Outfall............................................................. 14-26
14.7 DP6 -
Cross harbour Water Mains from Wan Chai To Tsim Sha Tsui............... 14-29
15.1 Introduction..................................................................................................... 15-1
15.2 Environmental
Outcomes................................................................................ 15-19
15.3 Air
Quality Impact......................................................................................... 15-29
15.4 Noise
Impact................................................................................................. 15-31
15.5 Water
Quality Impacts................................................................................... 15-33
15.6 Waste
Management Implications..................................................................... 15-34
15.7 Land
Contamination Impact............................................................................ 15-35
15.8 Marine
Ecological Impact............................................................................... 15-35
15.9 Landscape
and Visual Impact......................................................................... 15-36
15.10 Cultural
Heritage Impact................................................................................ 15-37
15.11 Environmental
Monitoring and Audit................................................................ 15-38
15.12 Overall
Conclusion......................................................................................... 15-38
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1.1 Schedule 2
Designated Projects under this Project
Table 2.1 Comparison of Trunk
Road Tunnel Variations
Table 2.2 Comparison of
Tunnel and Flyover Options
Table 3.1
Table 3.2 Tunnel Air Quality
Guidelines (TAQG)
Table 3.3 Annual Average
Concentrations of Pollutants in 2006
Table 3.4 Details of Air
Sensitive Receivers
Table 3.5 Emission Factors
for Construction Activities and Wind Erosion
Table 3.6 Different Major
Dust Generating Activities in The Worst Case Scenarios During Construction
Phase
Table 3.7 Annual Average
Concentrations of Pollutants in Past Five Years
Table 3.8 Vehicle Classes In
EMFAC-HK Model
Table 3.9 Emission Factors
for Year 2016 for Different Vehicle Classes (EMFAC-HK)
Table 3.10 Portal and
Table 3.11 Design of
Ventilation Buildings
Table 3.12 Summary of Odour
Patrol Results in Year 2006 Survey
Table 3.13 Summary of Odour
Patrol Results in Year 2007 Survey
Table 3.14 Results of Olfactometry
Analysis (Year 2006)
Table 3.15 Results of
Olfactometry Analysis (Year 2007)
Table 3.16 Existing Odour
Emission Inventory for the Worst Case Scenario
Table 3.17 Conversion Factors
to 5-Second Mean Concentration
Table 3.18 Predicted Cumulative
Maximum 1-Hour Average TSP Concentrations At
Table 3.19 Predicted
Cumulative Maximum 24-Hour Average TSP Concentrations for at
Table 3.20 Predicted
Cumulative Maximum 1-Hour Average TSP Concentrations at
Table 3.21 Predicted
Cumulative Maximum 24-Hour Average TSP Concentrations at
Table 3.22 Predicted
Cumulative Maximum 1-Hour Average NO2 Concentrations at the Representative ASRs
at Different Elevations
Table 3.23 Predicted Cumulative
Maximum 24-Hour Average NO2 Concentrations at the Representative ASRs at
Different Elevations
Table 3.24 Predicted
Cumulative Maximum 24-Hour Average RSP Concentrations at the Representative
ASRs at Different Elevations
Table 3.25 Predicted Odour Concentrations
at the Representative ASRs (Based on the Existing Odour Emission Rates) under
the Worst Case Condition
Table 3.26 Predicted Odour
Concentrations at the Representative ASRS (Mitigated Scenario) under the Worst
Case Condition
Table 3.27 Number of Hour
Exceeding the Odour Criterion at the Representative ASRs (Mitigated Scenario)
in a Year
Table 4.1 Construction Noise
Criteria for Activity other than Percussive Piling
Table 4.2 Acceptable Noise
Levels for Percussive Piling
Table 4.3 Permitted Hours of
Operation for Percussive Piling
Table 4.4 Acceptable Noise
Level for Fixed Plant Noise
Table 4.5 Representative
Existing and Planned Noise Sensitive Receivers
Table 4.6 Summary of
Construction Tasks and Stages
Table 4.7 Number of
Ventilation Fans required for the Proposed Ventilation Buildings under
Congestion Condition
Table 4.8 Summary of
Unmitigated Construction Noise Levels at Representative NSRs During
Table 4.9 Summary of
Mitigated Construction Noise Levels at Representative NSRs during
Table 4.10 Construction Noise
Residual Impacts
Table 4.11 Summary of
Unmitigated Construction Noise Levels at Representative NSRs During Restricted
Hours
Table 4.12 Summary of
Mitigated Construction Noise Levels at Representative NSRs During Restricted
Hours
Table 5.1 Summary of Water
Quality Objectives for
Table 5.2 WSD’s Water Quality
Criteria for Flushing Water at Sea Water Intakes
Table 5.3 Summary Statistics of
2005 Marine Water Quality in
Table 5.4 Summary Statistics
of 2005 Marine Water Quality at the
Table 5.5 Summary of
Information of Water Cooling Systems
Table 5.6 Flow Rates of Water
Cooling Systems for Thermal Plume Modelling.
Table 5.7 Summary of
Parameters for Thermal Plume Model (Delft3D-FLOW)
Table 5.8 Summary of
Parameters for Modelling of Residual Chorine (Delft3D-PART)
Table 5.9 Summary of
Parameters for Sediment Plume Model (Delft3D-PART)
Table 5.10 Maximum Dredging
Rates of WDII and CWB - Scenario
Table 5.11 Maximum Dredging
and Filling Rates of WDII and CWB - Scenario 2B (late 2009 to 2010)
Table 5.12 Maximum Dredging
and Filling Rates of WDII and CWB - Scenario
Table 5.13 Coastal
Developments Incorporated in the Construction and Operational Phase Coastline
Configurations
Table
Table 5.14 Pollution Loading
from Stonecutters Sewage Treatment Works under HATS
Table 5.15 Locations and
Pollution Loadings Survey Results (in 2000) of Wan Chai Stormwater Outfalls
Table 5.16 Pollution Loading
Inventory for Wan Chai,
Table 5.17 Pollution Loading
Inventory for Wan Chai,
Table 5.18 Pollution Loading
Inventory for Wan Chai,
Table 5.19 Pollution Loading
Inventory for Wan Chai,
Table 5.20 Discharge Rates at
Sections to the East and West of
Table 5.21 Operation Scenario
– Temperature Elevations at Cooling Water Intakes
Table 5.22 Construction
Scenario
Table
Table 5.23 Construction
Scenario 2B – Suspended Solids Concentrations at Sensitive Receivers
Table 5.24 Construction
Scenario
Table 5.25 Predicted Water
Quality at Temporary Embayment at Interim Construction Stage - Wet Season
Table 5.26 Predicted Water
Quality at Temporary Embayment at Interim Construction Stage - Dry Season
Table 5.27 Comparison of Phase
I Marine Site Investigation Sediment Elutriate Test Results with the Water
Quality Standards
Table 5.28 Comparison of Phase
II Marine Site Investigation Sediment Elutriate Test Results with the Water
Quality Standards
Table 5.29 Comparison of
WDIICFS Marine Site Investigation Sediment Elutriate Test Results with the
Water Quality Standards
Table 5.30 Calculation of the
Effects of Increased Suspended Sediment Concentrations on Dissolved Oxygen
Concentrations under Scenario
Table
Table 5.31 Calculation of the
Effects of Increased Suspended Sediment Concentrations on Dissolved Oxygen
Concentrations under Scenario 2B
Table 5.32 Calculation of the
Effects of Increased Suspended Sediment Concentrations on Dissolved Oxygen
Concentrations under Scenario
Table 5.33 Maximum Elevations
of Nutrient Concentrations under Scenario
Table 5.34 Maximum Elevations
of Nutrient Concentrations under Scenario 2B
Table 5.35 Maximum Elevations
of Nutrient Concentrations under Scenario
Table 5.36 Maximum Elevations
of PCBs
Table 5.39 Application of Silt
Screens at Interim Construction Stages
Table 5.40 Construction
Scenario
Table
Table 5.41 Construction
Scenario 2B – Predicted SS levels at the Seawater Intakes after the
Implementation of Mitigation Measures
Table 5.42 Construction
Scenario
Table 5.43 Predicted SS
Elevations at Corals for Construction Scenario
Table 5.44 Predicted SS
Elevations at Corals for Construction Scenario
Table 5.45 Predicted SS
Elevations at Corals for Construction Scenario 2B – Mitigated
Table 5.46 Predicted SS
Elevations at Corals for Construction Scenario
Table 5.47 Recommended Maximum
Dredging Rates
Table 5.48 Cumulative Impact
on
Table 6.1 Sediment Quality
Criteria for the Classification of Sediment
Table 6.2 Test Species for
Biological Testing
Table 6.3 Test Endpoints and
Decision Criteria for Biological Testing
Table 6.4 Results of
Biological Screening of Category M and Category H (>10xlcel) Samples
Table 6.5 Record of Floating
Refuse Collected wthin the Project Area
Table 6.6 Summary of Waste
Handling Procedures and Disposal Routes
Table 7.1 Potential
Contaminative Land Use Within the Study Area
Table 7.2 List of Aerial Photographs
Reviewed (A King Marine)
Table 7.3 Details of Existing
Potential Contaminative Land Use
Table 7.4 Estimated Quantity
of Contaminated Soil
Table 7.5 Findings of Site
Reconnaissance
Table 8.1 Peaking Factors
Table 8.2 Minimum Pipe
Gradients for Sewer Design
Table 8.3 Flow Estimate for
New Developments
Table 8.4 WDII Flows to Deep
Trunk Sewer
Table 9.1 Criteria and
Evaluation of Ecological Importance of Marine Habitats in the Assessment Area.
Table 9.2 Species of
Conservation Interests Recorded in the Assessment Area.
Table 9.3 Evaluation of
Ecological Impacts on Marine Resources During Construction Phase
Table 9.4 Summary of
Evaluation of Marine Ecological Impacts During Operation Phase.
Table 10.1 Relationship
between Receptor Sensitivity and Impact Magnitude in Defining Impact
Significance
Table 10.2 List of the
Landscape Resources / Landscape Character Zones and their Sensitivity to Change
Table 10.3 Visual Sensitive
Receivers (VSRs) and their Sensitivity to Change
Table 10.4 Significant Landscape
Impacts of the Proposed Works During Construction Phase
Table 10.5 Proposed
Construction Phase Landscape Mitigation Measures
Table 10.6 Proposed Operation
Phase Landscape Mitigation Measures
Table 10.7 Significance of
Landscape Impacts In the Construction and Operation Phases
Table 10.8 Significance of
Visual Impacts in the Construction and Operation Phases (Note: All Impacts
Adverse Unless Otherwise Noted.)
Table 12.1 Event and Action
Plan for Landscape and Visual Impact – Construction Phase
Table 13.1 Implementation
Schedule for Air Quality Control
Table 13.2 Implementation
Schedule for Noise Control
Table 13.3 Implementation
Schedule for Water Quality Control
Table 13.4 Implementation
Schedule for Waste Management
Table 13.5 Implementation
Schedule for Land Contamination
Table 13.6 Implementation
Schedule for Marine Ecology
Table 13.7 Implementation
Schedule for Landscape and Visual
Table 14.1 Summary of EIA
Impacts and Recommendations for DP1
Table 14.2 Summary of Eia Impacts
and Recommendations For DP2
Table 14.3 Summary of Eia
Impacts and Recommendations For DP3
Table 14.4 Summary of Eia
Impacts and Recommendations For DP4
Table 14.5 Summary of Eia
Impacts and Recommendations For DP5
Table 14.6 Summary of Eia
Impacts and Recommendations For DP6
Table 15.1 Summary of
Environmental Impacts Associated with the Project
Table 15.2 Summary of Key
Environmental Outcomes/ Benefits
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure
1.1 Wan Chai Development
Phase II and Central-Wan Chai Bypass – Site Plan
Figure
1.2 Designated Projects
Figure
1.2b Designated Project 2 -
Road P2 and Other Roads which are classified as Primary/District Distributor
Roads
Figure
1.2c Designated Project 3 -
Reclamation works including associated Dredging Works
Figure
1.2d Designated Project 4 -
Temporary Typhoon Shelter
Figure
1.2e Designated Project 5 - Wan
Chai East Sewage Outfall
Figure
1.3 General Layout of The CWB
From Central to North Point
Figure
2.1 Trunk Road Tunnel
Variation 1
Figure
2.2 Trunk Road Tunnel
Variation 2
Figure
2.3 Trunk Road Tunnel
Variation 3
Figure
2.5a Recommended Outline
Development Plan
Figure
2.6 Proposed Dredged Areas
Figure
2.8 Construction Stages (Sheet
1 of 12)
Figure
2.9 Construction Stages
(Sheet 2 of 12)
Figure
2.10 Construction Stages (Sheet
3 of 12)
Figure
2.11 Construction Stages (Sheet
4 of 12)
Figure
2.12 Construction Stages (Sheet
5 of 12)
Figure
2.13 Construction Stages (Sheet
6 of 12)
Figure
2.14 Construction Stages (Sheet
7 of 12)
Figure
2.15 Construction Stages (Sheet
8 of 12)
Figure
2.16 Construction Stages (Sheet
9 of 12)
Figure
2.17 Construction Stages (Sheet
10 of 12)
Figure
2.18 Construction Stages (Sheet
11 of 12)
Figure
2.19 Construction Stages (Sheet
12 of 12)
Figure
3.1 Study Area of Air Quality
Assessment
Figure
3.2 Locations of
Representative Air Sensitive Receivers (Causeway Bay & IECL section)
Figure
3.3 Locations of
Representative Air Sensitive Receivers (Wan Chai section)
Figure
3.4 Locations of the
Different Reclamation Sites
Figure
3.5 Locations of Portals and
Ventilation Buildings Emissions
Figure
3.21 Proposed Dredging Area for
Mitigation of Odour
Figure
4.1 Extent of ‘New’ Roads
under the Project (Sheet 1 of 6)
Figure
4.2 Extent of ‘New’ Roads
under the Project (Sheet 2 of 6)
Figure
4.3 Extent of ‘New’ Roads
under the Project (Sheet 3 of 6)
Figure
4.4 Extent of ‘New’ Roads
under the Project (Sheet 4 of 6)
Figure
4.5 Extent of ‘New’ Roads
under the Project (Sheet 5 of 6)
Figure
4.6 Extent of ‘New’ Roads
under the Project (Sheet 6 of 6)
Figure
4.7 Locations of Representative
Noise Sensitive Receivers
Figure
4.8 Extent of Low Noise Road
Surface on Existing Island Eastern Corridor within Study Area
Figure
4.9 Location of Temporary
Noise Barriers During Construction Phase (NPR2W, NPR1 & NPR2E)
Figure
4.10 Corresponding Noise Impact
Section in Demolition Works along IEC
Figure
4.10a Corresponding Noise Impact
Section in Construction of Superstructure along IEC
Figure
4.11 Locations of Direct Noise
Mitigation Measures
Figure
4.12 Section of Direct Noise
Mitigation Measures (Sheet 1 of 3)
Figure
4.13 Section of Direct Noise
Mitigation Measures (Sheet 2 of 3)
Figure
4.14 Section of Direct Noise
Mitigation Measures (Sheet 3 of 3)
Figure
4.15 Indicative Layout of
Re-provisioned Tin Hau Temple
Figure
5.1 Locations of Water
Quality Sensitive Receivers (Sheet 1 of 2)
Figure
5.2 Locations of Water
Quality Sensitive Receivers (Sheet 2 of 2)
Figure
5.3A Locations of Cooling Water
Discharges
Figure
5.3B Locations of Existing
Stormwater Outfalls
Figure 5.4 (Not
In Use)
Figure
5.5 Temporary Typhoon Shelter
Figure
5.6 Details of Temporary
Breakwater and Piled Wave Wall
Figure
5.7 Construction Phase
Modelling Scenario 2A (Sheet 1 of 2)
Figure
5.7a Construction Phase
Modelling Scenario 2A (Sheet 2 of 2)
Figure
5.8 Construction Phase
Modelling Scenario 2B
Figure
5.9 Construction Phase
Modelling Scenario 2C
Figure
5.10 Temporary Embayment under
Construction Scenario 3B
Figure
5.11 Temporary Embayment under
Construction Scenario 3C
Figure
5.12 Coastline Configuration
for 2011
Figure
5.13 Coastline Configuration
for 2016
Figure
5.14a Locations of Monitoring
Stations and Cross Sections
Figure
5.15 Typical Configuration of
Silt Curtains and Screens
Figure
6.1 Marine Sediment Sampling
Locations
Figure
7.1 Potential Contaminative
Land Uses within Study Area
Figure
7.3 Estimated Extent of Soil
Contamination
Figure
8.1 Proposed Sewerage Works
(Sheet 1 of 3)
Figure
8.2 Proposed Sewerage Works
(Sheet 2 of 3)
Figure
8.3 Proposed Sewerage Works
(Sheet 3 of 3)
Figure
9.2 Proposed Coral Recipient
Site in Junk Bay
Figure
10.1 Landscape and Visual
Impact Study Area
Figure 10.1.1 Review
of Planning framework Plan (Sheet 1 of 3)
Figure 10.1.2 Review
of Planning framework Plan (Sheet 2 of 3)
Figure 10.1.3 Review
of Planning framework Plan (Sheet 3 of 3)
Figure
10.2 Baseline Landscape
Resources during Construction
Figure
10.2A Baseline Landscape Resources
during Operation
Figure 10.2.1 Baseline
Landscape Resources Photos (Sheet 1 of 6)
Figure 10.2.2 Baseline
Landscape Resources Photos (Sheet 2 of 6)
Figure 10.2.3 Baseline
Landscape Resources Photos (Sheet 3 of 6)
Figure 10.2.4 Baseline
Landscape Resources Photos (Sheet 4 of 6)
Figure 10.2.5 Baseline
Landscape Resources Photos (Sheet 5 of 6)
Figure 10.2.6 Baseline
Landscape Resources Photos (Sheet 6 of 6)
Figure
10.3 Baseline Landscape
Character Areas during Construction
Figure
10.3A Baseline Landscape
Character Areas during Operation
Figure
10.4 Key VSRs and Primary
Zone of Visual Influence during Construction
Figure
10.4A Key VSRs and Primary Zone
of Visual Influence during Operation
Figure
10.4B Key VSRs and Secondary
Zone of Visual Influence
Figure 10.4.1 VSRs
Photos (Sheet 1 of 10)
Figure 10.4.2 VSRs
Photos (Sheet 2 of 10)
Figure 10.4.3 VSRs
Photos (Sheet 3 of 10)
Figure 10.4.4 VSRs
Photos (Sheet 4 of 10)
Figure 10.4.5 VSRs
Photos (Sheet 5 of 10)
Figure 10.4.6 VSRs
Photos (Sheet 6 of 10)
Figure 10.4.7 VSRs
Photos (Sheet 7 of 10)
Figure 10.4.8 VSRs
Photos (Sheet 8 of 10)
Figure 10.4.9 VSRs
Photos (Sheet 9 of 10)
Figure 10.4.10 VSRs
Photos (Sheet 10 of 10)
Figure
10.5 Landscape Master Plan
Figure
10.5A Proposed Landscape
Mitigation Measures
Figure 10.5.1 Section
(Sheet 1 of 5)
Figure 10.5.2 Section
(Sheet 2 of 5)
Figure 10.5.3 Section
(Sheet 3 of 5)
Figure 10.5.4 Section
(Sheet 4 of 5)
Figure 10.5.5 Section
(Sheet 5 of 5)
Figure 10.6.1 Residual
Impacts on Landscape Resources during Construction
Figure 10.6.2 Residual
Impacts on Landscape Character Areas during Construction
Figure 10.6.3 Residual
Impacts on Landscape Resources during Operation
Figure 10.6.4 Residual
Impacts on Landscape Character Areas during Operation
Figure 10.6.5 Residual
Visual Impacts within Primary ZVI during Construction
Figure 10.6.6 Residual
Visual Impacts within Secondary ZVI during Construction
Figure 10.6.7 Residual
Visual Impacts within Primary ZVI during Operation
Figure 10.6.8 Residual
Visual Impacts within Secondary ZVI during Operation
Figure
10.7 Key Plan for
Photomontage Viewpoint
Figure
10.7A Key Plan for Photomontage
Viewpoint from the Hinterland
Figure 10.7.1 Viewpoint
No. 1 Photomontage (Sheet 1 of 2)
Figure 10.7.2 Viewpoint
No. 1 Photomontage (Sheet 2 of 2)
Figure 10.7.3 Viewpoint
No. 2 Photomontage
Figure 10.7.4 Viewpoint
No. 3 Photomontage
Figure 10.7.5 Viewpoint
No. 4 Photomontage
Figure 10.7.6 Viewpoint
No. 5 Photomontage
Figure 10.7.7 Viewpoint
No. 6 Photomontage
Figure 10.7.7a Viewpoint
No. 6a Photomontage
Figure 10.7.8 Viewpoint
No. 7 Photomontage
Figure 10.7.9 Viewpoint
No. 8 Photomontage
Figure 10.7.10 Viewpoint
No. 9 Photomontage
Figure 10.7.11 Viewpoint
No. 10 Photomontage
Figure 10.7.12 Viewpoint
No. 11 Photomontage
Figure 10.7.13 Viewpoint
No. 12 Photomontage
Figure 10.7.14 Illustrations
showing Views within the Proposed Open Spaces
LIST OF APPENDICIES
Appendix 2.3 (Not used)
Appendix 2.4 Discussion Paper: Slip Road 8 Alignment Options
Appendix 2.5 Construction Programme
Appendix 3.1 Calculation of Dust Emission
Appendix 3.2 Year 2031 Traffic Flow Forecast
Appendix 3.3 Classification of Road Type
Appendix 3.4 2016 Vehicle Population
Appendix 3.5 Adopted Daily Trips and Vehicle-Mile-Travelled (VMT) in
Year 2031
Appendix 3.7 Summary Results of Comparing the Total Emission from Year
2016 to 2031
Appendix 3.8 Calculation of Vehicle Emission Factors
Appendix 3.9 Calculation of Emission Factor in Year 2031 (Open Road)
Appendix 3.10 Calculation of Emission Factor in Year 2031 (Portal &
Ventilation Building)
Appendix 3.11 Caline4 Road Plot and ISC3 Portal Location
Appendix 3.12 In-tunnel Air Quality Assessment
Appendix 3.13 Details of Odour Survey
Appendix 3.14 Locations of Potential Odour Emission Source and Odour
Contour Plots
Appendix 3.15 Tunnel Ventilation Schematic Diagram
Appendix 4.1 Projected Traffic Data With and Without the Project in
Year 2031
Appendix 4.2 Projected Traffic Data for Year 2008
Appendix 4.4 Photographs of Representative Noise Sensitive Receivers
Appendix 4.6 Powered Mechanical Equipment (PME) for CRIII Project (With
Mitigation Measures)
Appendix 4.9 Sample Output File for Road Traffic Noise Model
Appendix 4.9a Road-Plot of Road Traffic Noise Model
Appendix 4.10 Ventilation Noise Assessment
Appendix 4.11 (Not used)
Appendix 4.12 Helicopter Noise Assessment
Appendix 4.18 Eligibility Assessment for Indirect Technical Remedies
Appendix 5.1 Refined Model Grid Layout
Appendix 5.1a Derivation of Heat Re-circulation Factor
Appendix 5.1b Pile Layout for East Bridge, West Bridge and Seafront
Promenade
Appendix 5.2 Mathematical Expressions for Pile Friction
Appendix 5.3 Pollution Loading Inventory
Appendix 5.4a Surface Flow Pattern – Dry Season
Appendix 5.4b Surface Flow Pattern – Wet Season
Appendix 5.4c Depth-averaged Flow Speed – Dry Season
Appendix 5.4d Depth-averaged Flow Speed – Wet Season
Appendix 5.5 Operational Phase Water Quality Modelling Results – Annual
Simulations
Appendix 5.6 Predicted Water Quality at Sensitive Receivers in 2016
Appendix 5.7a Surface Water Temperature Elevation – Dry Season Spring Tide
Appendix 5.7b Surface Water Temperature Elevation – Dry Season Neap Tide
Appendix 5.7c Surface Water Temperature Elevation – Wet Season Spring Tide
Appendix 5.7d Surface Water Temperature Elevation – Wet Season Neap Tide
Appendix 5.8 Tidal and Depth Averaged Residual Chlorine Concentration –
Dry and Wet Seasons
Appendix 5.9a Construction Phase Sediment Plume Modelling Results -
Scenario 2A - Dry Season
Appendix 5.9b Construction Phase Sediment Plume Modelling Results -
Scenario 2A - Wet Season
Appendix 5.9c Construction Phase Sediment Plume Modelling Results - Scenario
2B - Dry Season
Appendix 5.9d Construction Phase Sediment Plume Modelling Results -
Scenario 2B - Wet Season
Appendix 5.9e Construction Phase Sediment Plume Modelling Results - Scenario
2C- Dry Season
Appendix 5.9f Construction Phase Sediment Plume Modelling Results -
Scenario 2C - Wet Season
Appendix 5.9g Construction Phase Sediment Plume Modelling Results -
Sensitivity Test - Dry Season
Appendix 5.9h Construction Phase Sediment Plume Modelling Results -
Sensitivity Test - Wet Season
Appendix 5.10a Construction Phase Water Quality Modelling Results - Scenario
3B - Dry Season
Appendix 5.10b Construction Phase Water Quality Modelling Results - Scenario
3B - Wet Season
Appendix 5.10c Construction Phase Water Quality Modelling Results - Scenario
3C - Dry Season
Appendix 5.10d Construction Phase Water Quality Modelling Results - Scenario
3C - Wet Season
Appendix 5.10e Maximum Mixing Zone for Contaminated Release – Scenario 2A
Appendix 5.10f Maximum Mixing Zone for Contaminated Release – Scenario 2B
Appendix 5.10g Maximum Mixing Zone for Contaminated Release – Scenario 2C
Appendix 6.1 Results of Sediment Quality Analysis
Appendix 6.2 Field Trials of Geoynthetic Containers ACE Report (to be
endorsed by ACE)
Appendix 7.1 Contamination Assessment Plan for A King Marine
Appendix 7.2 Contamination Assessment Report / Remediation Action Plan
for A King Marine
Appendix 9.1 Spot-check Reconnaissance Dives and Rapid Ecological
Assessment Survey
Appendix 9.2 Intertidal Communities Survey
Appendix 9.3 Photographs of Different Marine Environments in the
Assessment Area
Appendix 9.4 Photographs of Different Marine Habitats in the Assessment
Area
Appendix 9.5 Intertidal Faunal Species Recorded in Different Habitats
of the Assessment Area
Appendix 9.6 Avifaunal Species and Relative Abundance Recorded in the
Assessment Area
Appendix 10.2 Illustrations of the Landscaped Deck extending Victoria Park
to the Waterfront
Appendix 10.3 Affected Trees in Victoria Park
Appendix 10.4 Nine New Pedestrian Linkages to the Waterfront
Appendix 11.1 Marine Archaeological Investigation
Appendix 15.1 Key Assessment Assumptions and Methodologies
volume 2 – road works
Part A - Schedule
2 DP1 : Central-Wanchai Bypass (CWB)
including its road tunnel and slip roads
volume
3 – marine works
Part C - Schedule
2 DP3 : Reclamation works including
associated dredging works
Part D - Schedule
2 DP4 : Temporary typhoon shelter
Part E - Schedule
2 DP5 : Wan Chai East Sewage Outfall
Part F - Schedule
2 DP6 : Dredging for the Cross-harbour
Water Mains from Wan Chai to Tsim Sha Tsui
volume
5 – appendices (1 of 2)
volume
6 – appendices (2 of 2)