14.             Summary of Environmental Outcomes and Overall Conclusions

14.1          Key Environmental Outcomes

14.1.1      The key environmental outcomes of the Upgrading of Cheung Chau Sewage Collection, Treatment and Disposal Facilities are summarized below.

14.1.2      Environmental benefits of the Project and the environmental protection measures recommended:  The sewage treatment level of the Cheung Chau STW will be upgraded from primary to secondary and the capacity will be expanded to cope with the population growth and future developments.  Discharge of low quality effluent to the receiving water body will be reduced and hence will improve the coastal water quality of Cheung Chau.  Furthermore, hygiene problems within the catchment areas arising from the use of septic tanks will be largely relieved with provision of public sewers to currently unsewered villages, where practicable.

14.1.3      Population and environmentally sensitive area protected:  The marine waters near the Project site are protected by the improved treatment standard and treatment capacity of the Cheung Chau STW and the elimination of overflow from Pak She SPS.  The residential areas and village houses which are currently unsewered are also protected by provision of new sewers under this Project.

14.1.4      Environmentally friendly designs recommended:  The Deep Sewer Option instead of Kwun Yam Wan SPS would reduce impacts arising from the construction of a new SPS adjacent to Kwun Yam Wan Beach and the need of private land resumption.  Hand Shield construction method would be proposed for the deep sewers construction to reduce the extent of road opening works along Tung Wan Road and Cheung Chau Sports Road.  For Cheung Chau STW and Pak She SPS, the provision of standby parts and standby power sources improve the reliability of the sewage treatment and disposal system, while the provision of deodorizing units could reduce the possible odour impact to adjacent sensitive receivers.  In the design of Cheung Chau STW, non-potable reuse of treated effluent within the STW site will be proposed to reduce the consumption of potable water.  Energy efficiency measures such as adoption of solar panel, skylight and natural ventilation, etc. will also be explored to reduce energy consumption. The facilities of the upgraded Cheung Chau STW are so arranged as to minimize disturbance to the existing trees within the STW and more trees will be planted within the upgraded STW to enhance greenings and improve the visual appearances.

14.1.5      Key environmental problems avoided:  Potential deterioration of effluent quality of the existing Cheung Chau STW due to ageing problem of the facilities will be avoided by the proposed upgrading of the sewage treatment level and increasing the existing capacity of the STW.  The hygiene problems arising from the use of septic tanks will also be largely relieved by the provision of public sewers to currently unsewered village, where practicable.  Furthermore, potential sewage overflow to Cheung Chau receiving water body will be eliminated by the proposed upgrading works for Pak She SPS.

14.1.6      Compensation areas:  There is no significant habitat loss as a consequence of the Project.  Thus no specific compensation areas are required.

14.2          Overall Conclusions

14.2.1      The EIA Report has provided an assessment of the potential environmental impacts associated with the Project.  All environmental issues including air quality, noise, water quality, waste management, land contamination, ecology, fisheries, cultural heritage and landscape and visual have been undertaken in accordance with the EIA Study Brief (No. ESB-212/2009).

14.2.2      The nature and extent of different environmental impacts arising from the construction and operation of the Project have been addressed and quantified in the previous sections.  In addition, a summary of assessment findings of these individual issues is provided at the end of each section.  Appropriate mitigation measures have also been recommended for incorporation into the design, construction and operation phases of the Project for compliance of relevant environmental legislation and standards.  The Implementation Schedules of the recommended mitigation measures are provided in Section 13.

14.2.3      In conclusion, the Project would provide an overall improvement in water quality for marine waters near the Project site.  It would comply with environmental legislation and standards with the implementation of the recommended mitigation measures and good site practice.  An EM&A programme has also been recommended to be implemented before and during the construction and operation phases of the Project to check the implementation and effectiveness of the recommended mitigation measures.