TABLE OF CONTENTs
4.2 Environmental
Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Criteria
4.5 Identification of
Pollutant Sources
4.6 Construction Noise
Impact Assessment
4.7 Traffic Noise
Impact Assessment
4.9 Fixed Plant Noise
Assessment
4.10 Helicopter Noise
Impact Assessment
4.11 Environmental Acceptability of Schedule 2 Designated Projects
APPENDICES
Appendix 4.2.1 The
Locations of Background Noise Measurement
Appendix 4.2.2 The
Locations of Background Noise Measurement
Appendix 4.4.1 Photographs
of Existing NSRs outside NDA Boundary
Appendix 4.4.2 Photographs
of Existing NSRs inside NDA Boundary
Appendix 4.5.1 Plant
inventory (Unmitigated Scenario)
Appendix 4.5.2 Construction
Programme, Locations of Works Areas and Distance to Notional Sources
Appendix 4.6.1 Predicted
Construction Noise Levels at Representative NSRs (Unmitigated Scenario)
Appendix 4.6.2 Quiet
items of PME
Appendix 4.6.3 Schematic
Diagram for Construction Noise Barrier and Noise Enclosure
Appendix 4.6.4 Plant
Inventory (Mitigated Scenario)
Appendix 4.6.5 Predicted
Construction Noise Levels at Representative NSRs (Mitigated Scenario)
Appendix 4.6.6 Grouping
of PME for Different Works Area and Works Activities
Appendix 4.6.8 Minimum
Separation between Schools and Critical Works Areas During Examination Period
Appendix 4.6.9 Grouping
of PME Required during Examination Period
Appendix 4.6.10 Construction
Noise Assessment during Examination Period
Appendix 4.7.2 Road
Plot and Traffic Speed of Road Links
Appendix 4.7.3 Detailed
Results of Road Traffic Noise Assessment (Unmitigated Scenario)
Appendix 4.7.4 Detailed
Results of Road Traffic Noise Assessment (Mitigated Scenario)
Appendix 4.7.5 Eligibility
Testing for Indirect Noise Mitigation Measures
Appendix 4.7.6 Determination
of Traffic Noise Impact on Existing Road due to the Project
Appendix 4.8.1 West
Rail Viaduct Noise Propagation Model
Appendix 4.8.2 Rail
Noise Model Validation Report
Appendix 4.8.3 Predicted
Noise Level for West Rail (Unmitigated)
Appendix 4.8.4 Predicted
Noise Level for Light Rail (Unmitigated)
Appendix 4.8.5 Predicted
Noise Level for West Rail and Light Rail (Mitigated)
Appendix 4.8.6 EFTS
Track Enhancement Reference
Appendix 4.9.1 Detailed
Calculations of Fixed Plant Noise
Appendix
4.10.1 Detailed
Calculations of Helicopter Noise
FIGURES
Figure 4.4.52 Locations
of Helipad and Representative Noise Sensitive Receivers for Helicopter Noise
Figure 4.7.1 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures ¡V Key Plan
Figure 4.7.2 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 1 of 14)
Figure 4.7.3 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 2 of 14)
Figure 4.7.4 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 3 of 14)
Figure 4.7.5 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 4 of 14)
Figure 4.7.6 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 5 of 14)
Figure 4.7.7 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 6 of 14)
Figure 4.7.8 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 7 of 14)
Figure 4.7.9 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 8 of 14)
Figure 4.7.10 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 9 of 14)
Figure 4.7.11 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 10 of 14)
Figure 4.7.12 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 11 of 14)
Figure 4.7.13 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 12 of 14)
Figure 4.7.14 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 13 of 14)
Figure 4.7.15 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures (Sheet 14 of 14)
Figure 4.7.16 Locations
of Proposed Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures ¡V Summary
Figure 4.7.17 Locations
of Proposed Additional Road Traffic Noise Mitigation Measures ¡V Key Plan
Figure 4.8.1 Schematic
Drawing of Proposed Hung Shui Kiu Station Platform
Figure 4.8.2 Proposed
Noise Mitigation Measures for Site 4-22
Figure 4.8.3 Proposed
Noise Mitigation Measures for Site 5-7b
Figure 4.8.4 Proposed
Noise Mitigation Measures for Site 5-9
Figure 4.8.5 Proposed
Noise Mitigation Measures for Site 4-29
Figure 4.8.6 Proposed
Noise Mitigation Measures for Site 5-21
Figure 4.8.7 Alignment
of EFTS
¡P Construction of new primary distributor road (Road P1) (DP1)
¡P Construction of eight new distributor roads (Road D1 to D8) (DP2)
¡P Construction of slip roads between: Road D8 Junction and existing Castle Peak Road; Junction of D8/P1 and Junction of D7/P1; and Kong Sham Western Highway (KSWH) connection to Road D3 (DP5)
¡P Construction of partly depressed and partly decked-over roads located at Road D2, Road D4 and Road D6 (DP6)
¡P Construction of four new SPSs at Sites 2-34, 3-41, 3-48 and 4-35 (DP9)
¡P Construction of Road P1 and a slip-road from KSWH to Road D3 partly located within the ¡§CA¡¨ of Yuen Tau Shan (DP12)
¡P Construction of new West Rail Hung Shui Kiu (HSK) Station (Site 4-34) (DP3)
¡P Construction of environmentally friendly transport services (EFTS) (DP4) ¡V Potential DP subject to further review
¡P Construction of a new container back-up and storage area (Sites 3-1, 3-4, 3-5, 3-13 and 3-14) (DP7) ¡V Potential DP subject to further review
¡P Construction of new HSK sewage treatment works (STW) (Site 3-26 and part of existing San Wai STW) (DP8)
¡P Construction of one refuse transfer station (RTS) (Site 3-12) (DP11)
¡P Construction of flushing water service reservoirs for reuse of reclaimed water at Tan Kwai Tsuen and Fung Kong Tsuen (Sites 3-3 and 5-40) (DP10)
General
¡P EIAO-TM;
¡P TM on Noise from Construction Work other than Percussive Piling (GW-TM);
¡P TM on Noise from Percussive Piling (PP-TM);
¡P TM on Noise from Construction Work in Designated Areas (DA-TM); and
¡P TM on Noise from Places other than Domestic Premises, Public Places or Construction Sites (IND-TM).
Table 4.1 Area Sensitivity
Ratings
Type of Area Containing NSR |
Degree to which NSR is Affected
by Influencing Factor |
||
Not Affected |
Indirectly Affected |
Directly Affected |
|
Rural area |
A |
B |
B |
Urban area |
B |
C |
C |
Low density residential area consisting of low-rise
or isolated high-rise developments |
A |
B |
C |
Area other than those above |
B |
B |
C |
Construction Noise
Table 4.2 Noise Criteria for
Daytime Construction Noise
Uses |
Daytime Noise Criteria in Leq(30min), dB(A)) |
Domestic premises |
75 |
Educational Institution |
70 |
Educational Institution (during
examination) |
65 |
Note: The above
standards apply to uses which rely on opened windows for ventilation.
Table 4.3 Basic Noise Levels
(BNLs)
Time Period |
Basic Noise Level (BNLs), dB(A) |
||
ASR A |
ASR B |
ASR C |
|
Evening (1900 to
2300 hours) (1) |
60 |
65 |
70 |
Night (2300 to 0700
hours) |
45 |
50 |
55 |
Note: (1) Includes Sundays and Public
Holidays during daytime and evening.
¡P Erecting or dismantling of formwork or scaffolding;
¡P Loading, unloading or handling of rubble, wooden boards, steel bars, wood or scaffolding material; and
¡P Hammering.
Road Traffic Noise
¡P 70 dB(A) at 1 m from the external façades of residential dwellings, hotels, offices;
¡P 65 dB(A) at 1 m from the external façades of schools, places of public worship, courts of law, places where unaided voice communication is required; and
¡P 55 dB(A) at 1 m from the external façades of hospital or clinics.
Rail Noise
Table 4.4
Rail Noise Criteria
NSR Description |
ANL on Different Area Sensitivity Rating for Rail Noise, (Leq, 30min, dB(A)) |
||||||
Daytime and Evening time (0700 to 2300 hrs) |
Night-time |
||||||
A |
B |
C |
A |
B |
C |
||
Domestic premises, hotel, hostel and
hospitals |
60 |
65 |
70 |
50 |
55 |
60 |
|
Churches, school, medical clinics, and
performing arts centre [b] |
60 |
65 |
70 |
[a] |
|||
Note:
[a] No sensitive use/activities during this period.
[b] Churches, school,
performing arts centre and clinics are considered to be noise sensitive during daytime and evening time only.
Fixed Plant Noise
Table
4.5 Noise
Criteria for Fixed Noise Sources
Time Period |
Fixed Plant Noise for Different Area
Sensitivity Rating (Leq 30 min, dB(A)) |
|||||
ANL, dB(A) |
ANL-5, dB(A) for Fixed Plant Noise Criteria |
|||||
ASR A |
ASR B |
ASR C |
ASR A |
ASR B |
ASR C |
|
Day (0700 to 1900 hrs) |
60 |
65 |
70 |
55 |
60 |
65 |
Evening (1900 to 2300 hrs) |
60 |
65 |
70 |
55 |
60 |
65 |
Night (2300 to 0700 hrs) |
50 |
55 |
60 |
45 |
50 |
55 |
¡P The type of area within the concerned NSR is located;
¡P The Influencing Factor (IF) identified;
¡P The Degree to which the NSR is affected by IF; and
¡P If applicable, nearby OZP ¡§Industrial¡¨ or ¡§Industrial Estates¡¨ zone.
Table 4.6 Summary of Measured Prevailing
Background Noise Level
ID |
Measurement Location |
Minimum Measured Noise Level, Leq (30 min)
dB(A) |
||
Daytime |
Evening |
Night-time |
||
M01 |
San
Lee Uk Tsuen (Along
Tin Ha Road, outside the Zion Church of U.B. in Christ) |
68 |
68 |
58 |
M02 |
Tin
Sum Tsuen (Outside
Tin Sum Playground) |
49 |
49 |
39 |
M03 |
San
Sang Tsuen (Along
Tin Ha Road, opposite to San Sang Tsuen Sitting-out Area) |
53 |
50 |
40 |
M04 |
Sha
Chau Lei Tsuen |
52 |
49 |
42 |
M05 |
Sik
Kong Tsuen (Near
Long View Garden Block 9 & 10) |
52 |
50 |
45 |
M06 |
Tseung
Kong Wai (Near
Tseung Kong Wai Public Toilet) |
55 |
55 |
46 |
M07 |
Fung Kong Tsuen |
51 |
46 |
39 |
Helicopter Noise
4.2.15
There is an existing helipad near Ha Tsuen Interchange in the vicinity
of the Project. According to Table
1A of Annex 5 ¡§A Summary of Noise Criteria¡¨ in the EIAO-TM, the criteria for
helicopter noise is Lmax 90 dB(A) for offices and Lmax 85
dB(A) for domestic premises, hotels, hostels, education institutes, places of
worship, hospital and clinics during 0700-1900 hours. The standards apply to uses that rely on
openable windows for ventilation and the standards should be viewed as the
maximum permissible noise levels assessed at 1 m from the external façade.
¡P Ha Tsuen OZP No. S/YL-HT/10
¡P Lam Tei and Yick Yuen OZP No. S/TM-LTYY/8
¡P Tong Yan San Tsuen OZP No. S/YL-TYST/12
¡P Ping Shan OZP No. S/YL-PS/16
¡P Lau Fau Shan and Tsim Bei Tsui OZP No. S/YL-LFS/7
¡P Tin Shui Wai OZP No. S/TSW/12
Table 4.7 Identified Existing, Committed and
Planned Noise Sensitive Receivers
NSR ID |
NSR Description |
Existing / Planned Use |
Existing NSRs |
||
E1-OA |
Tin Wah Estate |
Existing Residential |
E1-OB_R |
Tin Shing Court |
Existing Residential |
E1-OB_E0 |
Q.E.S. Old Students' Association Branch
Primary School |
Existing Educational |
E1-OB_E1 |
YLPMSAA Tang Siu Tong Secondary School |
Existing Educational |
E1-OB_E2 |
Lions Clubs International Ho Tak Sum Primary School |
Existing Educational |
E2-OA |
Village House at Lau Fau Shan |
Existing Village |
E2-OB |
San Hing Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E2-OC |
Sha Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
E2-OD |
Tin Yan Estate |
Existing Residential |
E4-OA |
Tsing Cheun Wai |
Existing Village |
E4-OB |
Nai Wai |
Existing Village |
E4-OC |
Sun Fung Wai |
Existing Village |
E4-OD |
Chung Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-OA |
Tong
Fong Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-OB |
Hang Mei Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-OC |
Tai Tao Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-OD |
Uptown |
Existing Residential |
E5-OE |
Shung Tak Catholic English College |
Existing Educational |
E5-OF |
Treasure Court |
Existing Residential |
E5-OG |
Lai Hung Garden |
Existing Residential |
E5-OH |
Bauhinia Garden |
Existing Residential |
E1-IA |
Tseung Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
E1-IB |
Hong Mei Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IC |
Tung Tau Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-ID |
Lo Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IE |
Sik Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
E1-IF |
Ha Tsuen Shi |
Existing Village |
E1-IG |
San Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IH |
Sha Chau Lei |
Existing Village |
E1-II |
Kau Lee Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IJ |
San Sang Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IK |
Shek Po Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E2-IA |
Fung Kong Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E4-IA |
Tin Sum Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E4-IB |
Tsing Chuen Wai |
Existing Village |
E5-IA |
Kiu Tau Wai |
Existing Village |
E5-IB_R |
Hung Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-IB_C |
Chinese Mission Seminary |
Existing Church |
E5-IC |
San Lee Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-26 |
Existing Homes for the Elderly (Yeung Chun Pui
and Ching Chung) |
IC |
E4-30 |
Ling Liang Worldwide Evangelistic Mission HSK Ling
Liang Church (located at the junction of Castle Peak Road and Yick Yuen Road) |
IC |
E5-23 |
Sheffield Villas |
R3 |
E5-25 |
Hung
Fuk Estate |
RSc |
E5-31 |
Existing Residential Development |
R2 |
E5-35 |
Bellevue Court |
R4 |
E5-39 |
Existing Residential Development |
R3 |
E5-44 |
The Church of Jesus Christ of
Latter-Day Saints (Hung Shui Kiu)
(located at the junction of Castle Peak Road and Tin Ha Road) |
R3 |
Committed NSRs by Other Projects |
||
O5-06 |
Planned Subsidised Sales Flat |
R2(SSF)c |
O5-33 |
Planned Residential Development |
R2 |
NSR ID |
NSR Description |
Existing/Planned Use |
Planned NSRs under HSK Project |
||
P1-02 |
Site 1-02 |
R2(SSF)c |
P1-03 |
Site 1-03 |
E |
P1-04 |
Site 1-04 |
R2c |
P1-05 |
Site 1-05 |
R2c |
P1-06 |
Site 1-06 |
R2c |
P1-08 |
Site 1-08 |
R2c |
P1-09 |
Site 1-09 |
R2c |
P1-12 |
Site 1-12 |
R2 |
P1-15 |
Site 1-15 |
E |
P1-17 |
Site 1-17 |
R2 |
P1-18 |
Site 1-18 |
E |
P1-19 |
Site 1-19 |
R2 |
P1-21 |
Site 1-21 |
R2c |
P1-22 |
Site 1-22 |
E |
P2-02 |
Site 2-02 |
R3 |
P2-03 |
Site 2-03 |
R3 |
P2-07 |
Site 2-07 |
R3 |
P2-09 |
Site 2-09 |
E |
P2-10 |
Site 2-10 |
R3 |
P2-11 |
Site 2-11 |
R3c |
P2-14 |
Site 2-14 |
R3 |
P2-15 |
Site 2-15 |
E |
P2-16 |
Site 2-16 |
E |
P2-18 |
Site 2-18 |
RR4 |
P2-19 |
Site 2-19 |
RR4 |
P2-24 |
Site 2-24 |
E |
P2-25 |
Site 2-25 |
G |
P2-26 |
Site 2-26 |
E |
P2-28 |
Site 2-28 |
E |
P2-30 |
Site 2-30 |
RSc |
P2-31 |
Site 2-31 |
R2(SSF)c |
P4-01 |
Site 4-01 |
G |
P4-03 |
Site 4-03 |
R2(SSF)c |
P4-04 |
Site 4-04 |
RSc |
P4-05 |
Site 4-05 |
RSc |
P4-06 |
Site 4-06 |
R2(SSF)c |
P4-08 |
Site 4-08 |
E |
P4-09 |
Site 4-09 |
R1c |
P4-17 |
Site 4-17 |
OU |
P4-20 |
Site 4-20 |
RR4 |
P4-22 |
Site 4-22 |
RSc |
P4-24 |
Site 4-24 |
R2(SSF)c |
P4-25a |
Site 4-25a |
OU(C&R) |
P4-25b |
Site 4-25b |
OU(C&R) |
P4-25c |
Site 4-25c |
OU(C&R) |
P4-26 |
Site 4-26 |
R1c |
P4-28 |
Site 4-28 |
RSc |
P4-29 |
Site 4-29 |
OU(C&R) |
P4-32 |
Site 4-32 |
G |
P4-33 |
Site 4-33 |
E |
P4-36 |
Site 4-36 |
E |
P5-07a |
Site 5-07a |
OU(C&R) |
P5-07b |
Site 5-07b |
OU(C&R) |
P5-08 |
Site 5-08 |
OU(C&R) |
P5-09 |
Site 5-09 |
OU(C&R) |
P5-14 |
Site 5-14 |
E |
P5-16 |
Site 5-16 |
R2(SSF)c |
P5-17 |
Site 5-17 |
RSc |
P5-21 |
Site 5-21 |
E |
P5-22 |
Site 5-22 |
R3 |
P5-24 |
Site 5-24 |
R2(SSF)c |
P5-26 |
Site 5-26 |
R2(SSF) |
P5-28 |
Site 5-28 |
G |
P5-32 |
Site 5-32 |
OU(C&R) |
P5-34 |
Site 5-34 |
E |
P5-37 |
Site 5-37 |
E |
Note: Full names of the abbreviations of
uses should be referred to the List of Abbreviations.
Construction Noise
Table 4.8 Representative Noise Sensitive
Receivers and Noise Assessment Points for Construction Noise Impact Assessment
(Existing NSRs outside Project Area)
NSR ID |
NSR Description |
Land Use |
No. of Storeys |
NAP ID |
E4-OA |
Tsing Cheun Wai |
Residential |
3 |
ETCW02 |
E4-OA |
Tsing Cheun Wai |
Residential |
3 |
ETCW03 |
E4-OB |
Nai Wai |
Residential |
3 |
ENW02 |
E4-OD |
Chung Uk Tsuen |
Residential |
3 |
ESFW01 |
E4-OC |
Sun Fung Wai |
Residential |
3 |
ESFW02 |
E4-OC |
Sun Fung Wai |
Residential |
3 |
ESFW03 |
E4-OC |
Sun Fung Wai |
Residential |
3 |
ESFW04 |
E4-OD |
Chung Uk Tsuen |
Residential |
3 |
ECUT01 |
E4-OD |
Chung Uk Tsuen |
Residential |
3 |
ECUT02 |
E5-OE |
Shung Tak Catholic English College |
Educational
Institution |
7 |
ESTC51 |
E5-OD |
Uptown |
Residential |
17 |
EUPT02 |
E2-OA |
Village House at Lau Fau Shan |
Residential |
3 |
ELFS01 |
E2-OB |
San Hing Tsuen |
Residential |
3 |
ELFS02 |
E2-OC |
Sha Kong Wai |
Residential |
3 |
ELFS03 |
E2-OD |
Wing Jan School/Wing Jan Lutheran Church |
Educational
Institution |
1 |
ELFS04 |
E2-OB |
San Hing Tsuen |
Residential |
3 |
ELFS05 |
E1-OA |
Tin Wah Estate |
Residential |
21 |
ETSW01 |
E1-OB_E1 |
YLPMSAA Tang Siu Tong Secondary School |
Educational
Institution |
7 |
ETSW02 |
E1-OC |
Tin Shui Estate |
Residential |
39 |
ETSW03 |
E1-OD |
The Yuen Institute MFBM Nei Ming Chan Lui
Chung Tak Memorial College |
Educational
Institution |
7 |
ETSW04 |
E1-OC |
Tin Shui Estate |
Residential |
37 |
ETSW05 |
E1-OE |
Tin Oi Court |
Residential |
39 |
ETSW06 |
E1-OF |
Locwood Court |
Residential |
27 |
ETSW07 |
E1-OG |
VTC Youth College |
Residential |
6 |
ETSW08 |
E1-OI |
Tin Shing Court |
Residential |
40 |
ETSW09 |
E1-OB_R |
Tin Shing Court |
Residential |
40 |
ETSW10 |
E1-OB_E1 |
YLPMSAA Tang Siu Tong Secondary School |
Educational
Institution |
7 |
ETSW11 |
Table 4.9 Representative Noise Sensitive Receivers
and Noise Assessment Points for Construction Noise Impact Assessment (Existing
and Planned NSRs within Project Area)
NSR ID |
NSR Description |
Use |
No. of |
NAP ID |
Planned NSRs within Project area |
||||
P5-26 |
Site 5-26RSc |
R2(SSF) |
21 |
52602,52604 |
P5-24 |
Site 5-24R2(SSF)c |
R2(SSF)c |
29 |
52401,52407,52408 |
P2-18 |
Site 2-18RR4 |
RR4 |
- |
21801,21802,21803 |
P2-19 |
Site 2-19RR4 |
RR4 |
- |
21901 |
R4-20 |
Site 4-20RR4 |
RR4 |
- |
42001,42005,42006 |
P4-22 |
Site 4-22RSc |
RSc |
33 |
42203,42216,42251 |
P4-28 |
Site 4-28RSc |
RSc |
38 |
42806,42853,42859 |
P5-32 |
Site 5-32OU(C&R) |
O(C&R) |
28 |
53208 |
P5-16 |
Site 5-16R2(SSF)c |
R2(SSF)c |
28 |
51601,51602 |
P5-17 |
Site 5-17RSc |
RSc |
29 |
51702,51703 |
P5-21 |
Site 5-21E |
E |
- |
52151 |
P4-03 |
Site 4-3R2(SSF)c |
R2(SSF)c |
26 |
40305 |
P4-06 |
Site 4-6R2(SSF)c |
R2(SSF)c |
38 |
40602 |
P1-03 |
Site 1-3E |
E |
- |
10353,10354 |
P2-31 |
Site 2-31R2(SSF)c |
R2(SSF)c |
32 |
23101 |
P1-12 |
Site 1-12R2 |
R2 |
30 |
11203 |
P1-15 |
Site 1-15E |
E |
- |
11556 |
P1-17 |
Site 1-17R2 |
R2 |
31 |
11702 |
Existing NSRs within Project area |
||||
E4-IB |
Tsing Chuen Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
ETCW01 |
E5-39 |
Existing Residential Development |
Existing
Residential |
3 |
E53902 |
E5-39 |
Existing Residential Development |
Existing
Residential |
3 |
E53903 |
E4-IA |
Tin Sum Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ETST02 |
E4-IA |
Tin Sum Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ETST04 |
E4-IA |
Tin Sum Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ETST05a |
E4-IA |
Tin Sum Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ETST05b |
E4-IA |
Tin Sum Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ETST06 |
E5-IC |
San Lee Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESLUT01 |
E5-IC |
San Lee Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESLUT03 |
E5-IC |
San Lee Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESLUT04 |
E5-IC |
San Lee Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESLUT05 |
E5-35 |
Bellevue Court |
Existing Village |
3 |
EBC01 |
E5-39 |
Existing Residential Development |
Existing
Residential |
3 |
E53905 |
E5-39 |
Existing Residential Development |
Existing
Residential |
3 |
E53906 |
E5-31 |
Existing Residential Development |
Existing
Residential |
10 |
E53104 |
E5-31 |
Existing Residential Development |
Existing
Residential |
10 |
E53106 |
E5-25 |
Hung
Fuk Estate |
Existing
Residential |
41 |
E52503 |
E5-25 |
Hung
Fuk Estate |
Existing
Residential |
41 |
E52504 |
E5-25 |
Hung
Fuk Estate |
Existing
Residential |
41 |
E52505 |
E5-25 |
Hung
Fuk Estate |
Existing
Residential |
41 |
E52506 |
E5-IB_R |
Hung Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
EHUT01 |
E5-IB_R |
Hung Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
EHUT02 |
E5-IA |
Kiu Tau Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
EHUT03 |
E5-IA |
Kiu Tau Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
EHUT04 |
E1-IK |
Shek Po Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESPT01 |
E1-IK |
Shek Po Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESPT04 |
E1-IK |
Shek Po Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESPT05 |
E1-IK |
Shek Po Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESPT06 |
E1-IJ |
San Sang Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESST01 |
E1-IJ |
San Sang Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESST06 |
E1-IJ |
San Sang Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESST07 |
E1-II |
Kau Lee Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
EKLUT01 |
E1-IH |
Sha Chau Lei |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESCL01 |
E1-IH |
Sha Chau Lei |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESCL03 |
E1-IH |
Sha Chau Lei |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESCL04 |
E1-IG |
San Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E12501 |
E1-IG |
San Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E12502 |
E1-IG |
San Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E12503 |
E1-IF |
Ha Tsuen Shi |
Existing Village |
3 |
EHTS01 |
E1-IE |
Sik Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
ELUT01 |
E1-IE |
Sik Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
ESKT02 |
E1-IA |
Tseung Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
ETKW01 |
E1-IB |
Hong Mei Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
EHMT01 |
E1-IC |
Tung Tau Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ETTT01 |
E1-IC |
Tung Tau Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
ETTT02 |
E2-IA |
Fung Kong Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
EFKT01 |
E2-IA |
Fung Kong Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
EFKT03 |
E2-IA |
Fung Kong Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
EFKT04 |
Note: Full names of the abbreviations of uses should be referred to
the List of Abbreviations.
Road Traffic Noise
Table 4.10
Representative Noise Sensitive Receivers and Noise Assessment Points for
Traffic Noise Impact Assessment (Existing NSRs outside Project Area)
NSR ID |
Description |
Existing / Planned Use |
No. of Storey |
NAP ID |
E1-OA |
Tin Wah Estate |
Existing Residential |
35-40 |
E1-OA_R01 |
E1-OB_R |
Tin Shing Court |
Existing Residential |
35-40 |
E1-OB_R01 |
E1-OB_E2 |
Lions Clubs International Ho Tak Sum Primary
School |
Existing Educational |
8 |
E1-OB_E21 |
E1-OB_E1 |
YLPMSAA Tang Siu Tong Secondary School |
Existing Educational |
8 |
E1-OB_E11 to E1-OB_E12 |
E1-OB_E0 |
Q.E.S. Old Students' Association Branch Primary
School |
Existing Educational |
8 |
E1-OB_E01 to E1-OB_E02 |
E2-OA |
Village House at Lau Fau Shan |
Existing Village |
1-3 |
E2-OA_R01 |
E2-OB |
San Hing Tsuen |
Existing Village |
1-3 |
E2-OB_R01 to E2-OB_R03 |
E2-OC |
Sha Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
1-3 |
E2-OC_R01 to E2-OC_R04 |
E5-OD |
Uptown |
Existing Residential |
1-19 |
E5-OD_R01 |
E5-OE |
Shung Tak Catholic English College |
Existing Educational |
8 |
E5-OE_E01 |
E5-OF |
Treasure Court |
Existing Residential |
4-6 |
E5-OF_R01 |
E5-OG |
Lai Hung Garden |
Existing Residential |
10 |
E5-OG_R01 |
E5-OH |
Bauhinia Garden |
Existing Residential |
6 |
E5-OH_R01 |
E4-OA |
Tsing Cheun Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
E4-OA_R01 to E4-OA_R04 |
E4-OB |
Nai Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
E4-OB_R01 |
E4-OC |
Sun Fung Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
E4-OC_R01 to E4-OC_R03 |
E4-OD |
Chung Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E4-OD_R01 to E4-OD_R04 |
Table 4.11
Representative Noise Sensitive Receivers and Noise Assessment Points for
Traffic Noise Impact Assessment (Existing and Planned NSRs within Project area)
NSR ID |
Description |
Use |
No. of Storey |
NAP ID |
Existing
NSRs within Project Area |
||||
E1-IA |
Tseung Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
E1-IA_R01 |
E1-IB |
Hong Mei Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E1-IB_R01 |
E1-IC |
Tung Tau Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E1-IC_R01 to |
E1-ID |
Lo Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E1-ID_R01 |
E1-IE |
Sik Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
E1-IE_R01 |
E1-IF |
Ha Tsuen Shi |
Existing Village |
3 |
E1-IF_R01 to |
E1-IG |
San Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E1-IG_R01 to |
E1-IH |
Sha Chau Lei |
Existing Village |
3 |
E1-IH_R01 to |
E1-IJ |
San Sang Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E1-IJ_R01 to |
E1-IK |
Shek Po Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E1-IK_R01 to |
E2-IA |
Fung Kong Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E2-IA_R01 to |
E4-IA |
Tin Sum Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E4-IA_R01 to |
E4-IB |
Tsing Chuen Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
E4-IB_R01 |
E5-IA |
Kiu Tau Wai |
Existing Village |
3 |
E5-IA_R01 |
E5-IB_R |
Hung Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E5-IB_R01 to |
E5-IB_C |
Chinese Mission Seminary |
Existing Church |
1 |
E5-IB_C01 |
E5-IC |
San Lee Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
3 |
E5-IC_R01 |
E1-26 |
Existing Homes for the Elderly (Yeung Chun Pui and Ching Chung) |
IC |
3 |
E1-26_H01 to |
E4-30 |
Ling Liang Worldwide Evangelistic Mission Hung Shui Kiu Ling
Liang Church |
IC |
1 |
E4-30_C01 |
E5-23 |
Sheffield Villas |
R3 |
6 |
E5-23_R01 to |
E5-25 |
Hung Fuk Estate |
RSc |
24 |
E5-25_R01 to |
E5-31 |
Coronet Court |
R2 |
11 |
E5-31_R01 |
Park Nara |
11 |
E5-31_R05 |
||
Beauty Court |
9 |
E5-31_R11 |
||
Aster Court |
10 |
E5-31_R21
to E5-31_R22 |
||
E5-35 |
Bellevue Court |
R4 |
3 |
E5-35_R01 |
E5-39 |
Parkview Garden |
R3 |
3 |
E5-39_R01 |
Li Fong Yuen |
2 |
E5-39_R02 |
||
Casa De Oro |
6 |
E5-39_R03 |
||
Tin Sum Villa |
7 |
E5-39_R04 |
||
Tak Cheung Building |
6 |
E5-39_R05 |
||
E5-44 |
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (Hung Shui Kiu) |
R3 |
1 |
E5-44_C01 to |
O5-06 |
Planned Subsidised Sales Flat |
R2(SSF)c |
33 |
O5-06_R01 to |
O5-33 |
Planned Residential Development |
R2 |
13 |
O5-33_R01 to |
Planned
NSRs within Project Area by Project |
||||
P1-02 |
Site 1-02 |
R2(SSF)c |
27 |
P1-02_R01 to P1-02_R31 |
P1-03 |
Site 1-03 |
E |
8 |
P1-03_E01 to P1-03_E11 |
P1-04 |
Site 1-04 |
R2c |
30 |
P1-04_R01 |
P1-05 |
Site 1-05 |
R2c |
31 |
P1-05_R01 to P1-05_R11 |
P1-06 |
Site 1-06 |
R2c |
34 |
P1-06_R01 to P1-06_R11 |
P1-08 |
Site 1-08 |
R2c |
34 |
P1-08_R01 to P1-08_R22 |
P1-09 |
Site 1-09 |
R2c |
32 |
P1-09_R01 to P1-09_R12 |
P1-12 |
Site 1-12 |
R2 |
31 |
P1-12_R01 |
P1-15 |
Site 1-15 |
E |
8 |
P1-15_E01 to P1-15_E05 |
P1-17 |
Site 1-17 |
R2 |
27 |
P1-17_R01 |
P1-18 |
Site 1-18 |
E |
8 |
P1-18_E01 to P1-18_E03 |
P1-19 |
Site 1-19 |
R2 |
23 |
P1-19_R01 to P1-19_R21 |
P1-21 |
Site 1-21 |
R2c |
31 |
P1-21_R01 to P1-21_R21 |
P1-22 |
Site 1-22 |
E |
8 |
P1-22_E01 to P1-22_E11 |
P2-02 |
Site 2-02 |
R3 |
6 |
P2-02_R01 to P2-02_R32 |
P2-03 |
Site 2-03 |
R3 |
6 |
P2-03_R01 to P2-03_R21 |
P2-07 |
Site 2-07 |
R3 |
6 |
P2-07_R01 to P2-07_R21 |
P2-09 |
Site 2-09 |
E |
8 |
P2-09_E01 to P2-09_E02 |
P2-10 |
Site 2-10 |
R3 |
6 |
P2-10_R01 to P2-10_R31 |
P2-11 |
Site 2-11 |
R3c |
6 |
P2-11_R01 to P2-11_R31 |
P2-14 |
Site 2-14 |
R3 |
6 |
P2-14_R01 to P2-14_R12 |
P2-15 |
Site 2-15 |
E |
8 |
P2-15_R01 |
P2-16 |
Site 2-16 |
E |
8 |
P2-16_E01 to P2-16_R15 |
P2-18 |
Site 2-18 |
RR4 |
6 |
P2-18_R01 to P2-18_R05 |
P2-19 |
Site 2-19 |
RR4 |
6 |
P2-19_R01 |
P2-24 |
Site 2-24 |
E |
8 |
P2-24_E01 to P2-24_E11 |
P2-25 |
Site 2-25 |
G |
8 |
P2-25_H01 |
P2-26 |
Site 2-26 |
E |
8 |
P2-26_E01 to P2-26_E11 |
P2-28 |
Site 2-28 |
E |
8 |
P2-28_E01 to P2-28_E02 |
P2-30 |
Site 2-30 |
RSc |
8 |
P2-30_R01 to P2-30_R21 |
P2-31 |
Site 2-31 |
R2(SSF)c |
8 |
P2-31_R01 to P2-31_R21 |
P4-01 |
Site 4-01 |
G |
25 |
P4-01_R01 to P4-01_R13 |
P4-03 |
Site 4-03 |
R2(SSF)c |
26 |
P4-03_R01 to P4-03_R11 |
P4-04 |
Site 4-04 |
RSc |
35 |
P4-04_R01 to P4-04_R24 |
P4-05 |
Site 4-05 |
RSc |
42 |
P4-05_R01 to P4-05_R14 |
P4-06 |
Site 4-06 |
R2(SSF)c |
39 |
P4-06_R01 to P4-06_R12 |
P4-08 |
Site 4-08 |
E |
8 |
P4-08_E01 to P4-08_E11 |
P4-09 |
Site 4-09 |
R1c |
40 |
P4-09_E06 |
P4-20 |
Site 4-20 |
RR4 |
3 |
P4-20_R01 to P4-20_R04 |
P4-22 |
Site 4-22 |
RSc |
33 |
P4-22_R01 to P4-22_R42 |
P4-24 |
Site 4-24 |
R2(SSF)c |
29 |
P4-24_R01 to P4-24_R46 |
P4-25a |
Site 4-25a |
OU(C&R) |
38 |
P4-25a_R01 |
P4-25b |
Site 4-25b |
OU(C&R) |
38 |
P4-25b_R01 to P4-25b_R11 |
P4-25c |
Site 4-25c |
OU(C&R) |
39 |
P4-25c_R01 to P4-25c_R11 |
P4-26 |
Site 4-26 |
R1c |
36 |
P4-26_R01 to P4-26_R21 |
P4-28 |
Site 4-28 |
RSc |
38 |
P4-28_R01 to P4-28_R44 |
P4-29 |
Site 4-29 |
OU(C&R) |
38 |
P4-29_R01 to P4-29_R31 |
P4-32 |
Site 4-32 |
G |
32 |
P4-32_R01 to P4-32_R14 |
P4-33 |
Site 4-33 |
E |
8 |
P4-33_E01 to P4-33_E03 |
P4-36 |
Site 4-36 |
E |
8 |
P4-36_E02 to P4-36_R01 |
P5-07a |
Site 5-07a |
OU(C&R) |
31 |
P5-07a_R01 - P5-07a_R21 |
P5-07b |
Site 5-07b |
OU(C&R) |
31 |
P5-07b_R01 to P5-07b_R21 |
P5-08 |
Site 5-08 |
OU(C&R) |
22 |
P5-08_R01 to P5-08_R11 |
P5-09 |
Site 5-09 |
OU(C&R) |
33 |
P5-09_R01 to P5-09_R31 |
P5-14 |
Site 5-14 |
E |
8 |
P5-14_E01 to P5-14_E11 |
P5-16 |
Site 5-16 |
R2(SSF)c |
28 |
P5-16_R01 to P5-16_R11 |
P5-17 |
Site 5-17 |
RSc |
29 |
P5-17_E04 to P5-17_R12 |
P5-21 |
Site 5-21 |
E |
8 |
P5-21_E01 to P5-21_E02 |
P5-22 |
Planned Residential Development |
R3 |
40 |
P5-22_R01 to P5-22_R03 |
P5-24 |
Site 5-24 |
R2(SSF)c |
35 |
P5-24_R01 to P5-24_R23 |
P5-26 |
Site 5-26 |
R2(SSF) |
22 |
P5-26_R01 to P5-26_R04 |
P5-28 |
Site 5-28 |
G |
8 |
P5-32_R01 to P5-32_R82 |
P5-32 |
Site 5-32 |
OU(C&R) |
29 |
P5-32_R01 to P5-32_R82 |
P5-34 |
Site 5-34 |
E |
8 |
P5-34_E01 to P5-34_E11 |
P5-37 |
Site 5-37 |
E |
8 |
P5-37_E01 to P5-37_E02 |
Note: Full names of the abbreviations of uses should be referred to
the List of Abbreviations.
Rail Noise
Table 4.12 Summary of Existing and Planned Noise
Sensitive Receivers for Rail Noise Assessment
NSR
ID |
Description |
Land
Use |
Max
mPD |
Type
of Area Containing NSR[1] |
Degree
of Influence by IF[2] |
Area
Sensitive Rating |
Criteria,
dB(A) (0700
to 2300 hrs) |
Criteria,
dB(A) |
NAP
ID |
Existing WRL NSRs |
|||||||||
E4-IB |
Premises to the southwest of Yick Yuen Tsuen |
Existing Village |
8.7 |
[i] |
Not Affected |
A |
60 |
50 |
WR-E1 |
E4-IB |
Premises to the east of Oakland Court |
Existing Village |
8.5 |
[i] |
Not Affected |
A |
60 |
50 |
WR-E2 |
E4-IA |
Premises to the southwest of Tin Sum Tsuen |
Existing Village |
7.7 |
[i] |
Not Affected |
A |
60 |
50 |
WR-E3 |
E1-IH |
Premises to the West of San Lee Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
6.5 |
[i] |
Not Affected |
A |
60 |
50 |
WR-E4 |
E1-IH |
Premises to the West of San Lee Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
9.9 |
[i] |
Not Affected |
A |
60 |
50 |
WR-E5 |
E1-IJ |
Block 3,Galore Garden |
Existing Village |
12.4 |
[i] |
Not Affected |
A |
60 |
50 |
WR-E6 |
E1-IK |
Shek Po Tsuen Village House |
Existing Village |
8.2 |
[i] |
Not Affected |
A |
60 |
50 |
WR-E7 |
Project Planned WRL NSRs |
|||||||||
P4-06 |
Residential Development in Site 4-6 |
Residential |
141 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P1 |
P4-08 |
School in Site 4-8 |
Education |
47 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
NA |
WR-P2 |
P4-10 |
Residential Development in Site 4-10 |
Residential |
166 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P3 |
P4-20 |
Residential Development in Site 4-20 |
Residential |
19 |
[iv] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P4 |
P4-22 |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
Residential |
127 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P5a |
P4-22 |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
Residential |
127 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P5b |
P4-22 |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
Residential |
127 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P5c |
P4-22 |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
Residential |
127 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P5d |
P4-22 |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
Residential |
127 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P5e |
P4-22 |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
Residential |
127 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P5f |
P4-25 |
Residential Development in Site 4-25 |
Commercial & Residential |
178 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P6a |
P4-25 |
Residential Development in Site 4-25 |
Commercial & Residential |
178 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P6b |
P4-25 |
Residential Development in Site 4-25 |
Commercial & Residential |
178 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P6c |
P4-29 |
Residential Development in Site 4-29 |
Commercial & Residential |
171 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P7a |
P4-29 |
Residential Development in Site 4-29 |
Commercial & Residential |
171 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P7b |
P4-29 |
Residential Development in Site 4-29 |
Commercial & Residential |
171 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P7c |
P4-36 |
School in Site 4-36 |
Education |
48 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
NA |
WR-P8 |
P5-17 |
Residential Development in Site 5-17 |
Residential |
111 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P9a |
P5-17 |
Residential Development in Site 5-17 |
Residential |
111 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
WR-P9b |
P5-21 |
School in Site 5-21 |
Education |
43 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
NA |
WR-P10 |
P5-34 |
School in Site 5-34 |
Education |
43 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
NA |
WR-P11 |
Existing
LRT NSRs |
|||||||||
E5-39 |
Existing Residential Development |
R3 |
21.5 |
[iii] |
Directly Affected by [a] |
C |
70 |
60 |
LR-E1 |
E5-39 |
Existing Residential Development |
R3 |
29.6 |
[iii] |
Directly Affected by [a] |
C |
70 |
60 |
LR-E2 |
E5-31 |
Existing Residential Development |
R2 |
46.4 |
[iii] |
Directly Affected by [a] |
C |
70 |
60 |
LR-E3 |
E5-31 |
Existing Residential Development |
R2 |
46.1 |
[iii] |
Directly Affected by [a] |
C |
70 |
60 |
LR-E4 |
E5-31 |
Existing Residential Development |
R2 |
46.6 |
[iii] |
Directly Affected by [a] |
C |
70 |
60 |
LR-E5 |
E5-IB_R |
Village House in Hung Uk Tsuen
facing Kiu Hung Road |
Existing Village |
14.5 |
[iii] |
Directly Affected by [a] |
C |
70 |
60 |
LR-E6 |
E4-30 |
Ling Liang Worldwide Evangelistic Mission Hung
Shui Kiu Ling Liang Church |
IC |
14.5 |
[iii] |
Directly Affected by [a] |
C |
70 |
NA |
LR-E7 |
Project Planned LRT NSRs |
|||||||||
P4-22 |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
Residential |
127 |
[iii] |
Directly Affected by [a] |
C |
70 |
60 |
LR-P1 |
P4-26 |
Residential Development in Site 4-26 |
Residential |
152 |
[iii] |
Directly Affected by [a] |
C |
70 |
60 |
LR-P2 |
P4-28 |
Residential Development in Site 4-28 |
Residential |
144 |
[iii] |
Directly Affected by [a] |
C |
70 |
60 |
LR-P3a |
P4-28 |
Residential Development in Site 4-28 |
Residential |
144 |
[iii] |
Directly Affected by [a] |
C |
70 |
60 |
LR-P3b |
P4-33 |
School in Site 4-33 |
Education |
48 |
[iii] |
Directly Affected by [a] |
C |
70 |
NA |
LR-P4 |
P5-07 |
Residential Development in Site 5-7b |
Commercial & Residential |
142 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
LR-P5a |
P5-07 |
Residential Development in Site 5-7b |
Commercial & Residential |
142 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
LR-P5b |
P5-07 |
Residential Development in Site 5-7b |
Commercial & Residential |
142 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
LR-P5c |
P5-09 |
Residential Development in Site 5-9 |
Commercial & Residential |
152 |
[iii] |
Not Affected |
B |
65 |
55 |
LR-P6 |
Notes:
[1] Type of Area Containing NSR: [i]
¡V Rural area, including country
parks or village type developments
[ii] ¡V Low density residential area consisting of low-rise or isolated
high-rise developments
[iii]
¡V Urban area (High-rise buildings within
mixture of residential, commercial and governmental institution, etc.)
[iv]
¡V Area other than [i], [ii] and [iii]
[2] Influencing Factor (IF): [a] ¡V Castle Peak
Road ¡V Hung Shui Kui Section (AADT > 30,000)
Fixed Plant Noise
Table 4.13 Representative Noise Sensitive
Receivers and Assessment Points for Fixed Plant Noise Impact Assessment
NSR ID / Site Ref. No. |
Use |
Description |
No. of |
Height, mAG |
Representative NAP ID |
E1-1A |
V |
Tseung Kong Wai |
3 |
8.2 |
E1-IA_R01 to E1-IA_R02 |
E1-IJ |
V |
San Sang Tsuen |
3 |
8.2 |
E1-IJ_R05 |
E1-IK |
V |
Shek Po Tsuen |
3 |
8.2 |
E1-IK_R04 to E1-IK_R06 |
E2-IA |
V |
Fung Kong Tsuen |
3 |
8.2 |
E2-IA_R03 |
E1-OB_E1 |
E |
YLPMSAA Tang Siu Tong Secondary School |
8 |
36 |
E1-OB_E11 |
E1-OB_R |
R |
Tin Shing Court |
35 |
100 |
E1-OB_R02 to E1-OB_R03 |
Site 1-12 |
R |
Private Residential Development |
31 |
109 |
P1-12_R01 |
Site 1-19 |
R |
Private Residential Development |
24 |
89 |
P1-19_R11 |
Site 1-21 |
R |
Private Residential Development |
|
|
P1-21_R22 |
Site 2-24 |
E |
1 Primary School & 1 Secondary School |
8 |
36 |
P2-24_E03 |
Site 2-26 |
E |
1 Primary School & 1 Secondary School |
8 |
36 |
P2-26_E11 |
Site 2-28 |
E |
1 Primary School |
8 |
36 |
P2-28_R02 |
Site 4-1 |
R |
Fire Station Staff Quarters |
30 |
134.8 |
P4-01_R02 |
Site 4-3 |
R |
Subsidised Sales Flat (with Commercial) |
26 |
92 |
P4-03_R01 to P4-03_R02 |
Site 4-4 |
R |
Public Rental Housing (with Commercial) |
42 |
143 |
P4-04_R13 |
Site 4-5 |
R |
Public Rental Housing (with Commercial) |
42 |
143 |
P4-05_R03 to P4-05_R13 |
Site 4-6 |
R |
Subsidised Sales Flat (with Commercial) |
39 |
131 |
P4-06_R11, P4-06_R12 |
Site 4-10 |
R |
Private Residential (with Commercial) |
43 |
155 |
P4-10_R01 to P4-10_R11 |
Site 4-20 |
V |
Village Resite |
3 |
8.2 |
P4-20_R01, P4-20_R05 |
Site 4-22 |
R |
Public Rental Housing (with Commercial) |
34 |
116 |
P4-22_R01 |
Site 4-25c |
C/R |
Commercial & Residential Development |
45 |
165.7 |
P4-25c_R01 to
P4-25c_R11 |
Site 4-28 |
R |
Public Rental Housing (with Commercial) |
39 |
131 |
P4-28_R41 |
Site 4-29 |
C/R |
Commercial & Residential Development |
43 |
158 |
P4-29_R21 |
Site 5-6 |
R |
Planned Subsidised Sales Flat (with Commercial) |
33 |
103 |
O5-06_R13, O5-06_R25 |
Site 5-8 |
C/R |
Commercial & Residential Development |
39 |
151.9 |
P5-08_R11 to P5-08_R31 |
Site 5-9 |
C/R |
Commercial & Residential Development |
40 |
147 |
P5-09_R32 |
Site 5-14 |
E |
1 Primary School & 1 Secondary School |
8 |
36 |
P5-14_E01 |
Site 5-16 |
R |
Subsidised Sales Flat (with Commercial) |
29 |
101 |
P5-16_R05 |
Site 5-21 |
E |
1 Secondary School |
8 |
36 |
P5-21_E01 |
Site 5-34 |
E |
1 Primary School & 1 Secondary School |
8 |
36 |
P5-34_E01 |
Note: Full names of the abbreviations of
uses should be referred to the List of Abbreviations.
Helicopter Noise
Table 4.14 Representative Noise Sensitive
Receivers and Assessment Points for Helicopter Noise Impact Assessment
ID / Site Ref. No. |
Use |
Description |
No. of |
Height, mAG |
Representative NAP ID |
Site 2-28 |
E |
Planned Primary School |
8 |
36 |
P2-28_E01 |
E1-IA |
V |
Existing Village - Tseung Kong Wai |
3 |
8.2 |
E1-IA_R01 |
Note: Full names of the abbreviations of
uses should be referred to the List of Abbreviations.
Construction Phase
¡P Site formation;
¡P Construction of Road P1 (DP1);
¡P Construction of Road D1, D2, D3, D4, D5, D6, D7, D8 (DP2), partly depressed and partly decked-over road located at Road D2, Road D4 and Road D6 (DP6) and local roads;
¡P Construction of slip roads: between Road D8 Junction and existing Castle Peak Road; between Junction of D8/P1 and Junction of D7/P1; and from KSWH connection to Road D3 (DP5);
¡P Construction of Road P1 and slip-road from KSWH to Road D3 partly located within the ¡§Conservation Area¡¨ of Yuen Tau Shan (DP12);
¡P Site development for residential, ¡§G/IC¡¨, commercial, industrial development and open space areas;
¡P Site development for a new district cooling system (DCS), port back-up and storage use sites, RTS, logistics and enterprise & technology park sites; and
¡P Construction of four SPSs (DP9) and associated rising mains.
Operation Phase
¡P Road traffic noise within 300 m area from the Project boundary;
¡P Rail noise (WRL, LRT and proposed EFTS within the Project);
¡P Fixed plant noise from existing fixed plant noise sources within 300 m assessment area and planned fixed plant noise sources of the Project.
Table 4.15 List of Existing and Planned Fixed
Plant Noise Sources
Types |
Noise Sources |
Reference
Location[1] |
Existing
Sources |
Pumping Stations |
Sik
Kong Tsuen, Sik Kong Wai, Lo Uk Tsuen, Kiu Tau Wai, Shung Cheung Wai, Site
1-23 |
San Wai STW |
Site
3-17 |
|
Planned
Sources |
SPSs |
Sites
2-34, 3-41, 3-48, 4-35 |
New HSK STW |
Site
3-26 |
|
Port Back-up, Storage and Workshop
Uses |
Sites
3-1, 3-4, 3-5, 3-6, 3-7, 3-8, 3-11, 3-13 and 3-14 |
|
District Cooling System (DCS) |
Sites
1-24, 4-18 |
|
Electricity Substation (ESS) |
Sites
4-23, 4-37, 5-19 |
|
Public Transport Interchange (PTI) and
Vehicle Depot |
Sites
2-23, 4-13a, 4-21, 4-29, 5-5 |
|
Sports Ground |
Site
1-29 |
|
Fire Station |
Site
4-1 |
|
Hospital |
Site
5-13 |
|
Flood Retention Facilities |
Sites
1-21, 1-32, 2-13, 2-32, 3-31, 4-11, 4-19, 5-11 and 5-43 |
|
EFTS Depot |
Site
3-18 |
|
Parking and Operational Facilities for
EFTS |
Site
2-29 |
|
Proposed HSK Station |
Site
4-34 |
|
|
Industrial Areas |
Sites
3-43, 3-44, 3-45, 3-46, 3-47, 3-50, 3-51 and 3-52 |
Notes: [1] Reference source no.
is shown in Figures 4.4.37 ¡V 4.4.51.
Assessment Approach and Methodology
Prediction and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts
Table 4.16 Summary of Unmitigated Construction
Noise Assessment Results (Existing NSRs outside the Project Area) during Normal
Daytime Working Hours
NAP ID |
NAP Description |
Criterion, dB(A) (a) |
Predicted Mitigated Construction Noise Levels, Leq (30min)
dB(A) |
Duration of Exceedance (Months) |
ETCW02 |
No. 739 Oaklands Court |
75 |
68 - 85 |
38 |
ETCW03 |
No. 703A, Chung Long Terrace |
75 |
67 - 79 |
35 |
ENW02 |
No. 202, Shun Fung Wai |
75 |
68 - 81 |
23 |
ESFW01 |
No. 332, Chung Uk Tsuen |
75 |
73 - 79 |
47 |
ESFW02 |
Village house, Nai Wai |
75 |
64 - 82 |
32 |
ESFW03 |
No. 368, Sun Fung Wai |
75 |
67 - 82 |
35 |
ESFW04 |
No. 716, Chung Uk Tsuen |
75 |
69 - 81 |
24 |
ECUT01 |
No. 16, Chung Uk Tsuen |
75 |
68 - 79 |
32 |
ECUT02 |
No. 203, Chung Uk Tsuen |
75 |
71 - 80 |
21 |
ESTC51 |
Shung Tak Catholic English College |
70 (65) |
64 - 73 |
22 |
EUPT02 |
Flat C, Tower 1, Uptown |
75 |
74 - 74 |
0 |
ELFS01 |
No. 30 Lau Fau Shan |
75 |
60 - 82 |
7 |
ELFS02 |
No. 3H, San Hing Tsuen |
75 |
65 - 83 |
7 |
ELFS03 |
No. 310 Sha Kong Wai |
75 |
61 - 82 |
25 |
ELFS04 |
Wing Jan School/Wing Jan Lutheran Church |
70 (65) |
63 - 81 |
7 |
ELFS05 |
No. 1, Lau Fau Shan Road |
75 |
65 - 81 |
29 |
ETSW01 |
Wah Yat House, Tin Wah Estate |
75 |
72 - 78 |
15 |
ETSW02 |
Caritas Lok Kan School |
75 |
67 - 79 |
18 |
ETSW03 |
Shui Lung House, Tin Shui Estate |
75 |
71 - 78 |
34 |
ETSW04 |
The Yuen Institute MFBM Nei Ming Chan Lui Chung Tak Memorial
College |
70 (65) |
69 - 78 |
23 |
ETSW05 |
Shui Fung House, Tin Shui Estate |
75 |
63 - 80 |
10 |
ETSW06 |
Oi Tao House, Tin Oi Court |
75 |
73 - 80 |
36 |
ETSW07 |
Block 7, Locwood Court |
75 |
66 - 82 |
26 |
ETSW08 |
VTC Youth College (Tin Shui Wai) |
70 (65) |
71 - 84 |
93 |
ETSW09 |
Shing Ting House, Tin Shing Court |
75 |
64 - 85 |
48 |
ETSW10 |
Shing Kan House, Tin Shing Court |
75 |
66 - 80 |
28 |
ETSW11 |
YLPMSAA Tang Siu Tong Secondary School |
70 (65) |
66 - 81 |
73 |
Notes:
(a) Construction noise assessment
criterion is 75 dB(A) for domestic premises and 70dB(A) for education
institutions (65dB(A) during examinations).
Table 4.17 Summary
of Unmitigated Construction Noise Assessment Results (Existing NSRs within the
Project Area) during Normal Daytime Working Hours
NAP ID |
NAP Description |
Criterion, dB(A) (a) |
Predicted Unmitigated Construction Noise Levels, Leq (30min)
dB(A) |
Duration of Exceedance (Months) |
ETCW01 |
No. 430, village house |
75 |
67 - 82 |
23 |
E53902 |
No. 125, Lee Fong Yuen |
75 |
68 - 84 |
42 |
E53903 |
Village house, Tin Ha Road |
75 |
69 - 84 |
42 |
ETST02 |
No. 13, Tin Sum |
75 |
65 - 78 |
11 |
ETST04 |
No.211, Tin Sum |
75 |
69 - 71 |
0 |
ETST05a |
No. 143 ,Tin Sum (South Façade) |
75 |
68 - 86 |
36 |
ETST05b |
No. 143, Tin Sum, (West Façade) |
75 |
68 - 87 |
39 |
ETST06 |
No. 290, Tin Sum |
75 |
68 - 82 |
50 |
ESLUT01 |
No. 46A, San Lee Uk Tsuen |
75 |
67 - 88 |
26 |
ESLUT03 |
No. 62, San Lee Uk Tsuen |
75 |
67 - 90 |
108 |
ESLUT04 |
No. 254, San Lee Uk Tsuen |
75 |
65 - 92 |
56 |
ESLUT05 |
No. 120, San Lee Uk Tsuen |
75 |
68 - 93 |
65 |
EBC01 |
House 15, Bellevue Court |
75 |
64 - 89 |
80 |
E53905 |
Village House, Hung Shui Kiu Tin Sam Road |
75 |
64 - 81 |
26 |
E53906 |
Flat C, Tin Sam Villa |
75 |
66 - 86 |
12 |
E53104 |
Flat C, Block 1, Aster Court |
75 |
69 - 83 |
12 |
E53106 |
Flat D, Block 1, Aster Court |
75 |
68 - 82 |
74 |
E52503 |
Hung Long House, Hung Fuk Estate |
75 |
68 - 82 |
31 |
E52504 |
Hung Yan House, Hung Fuk Estate |
75 |
66 - 82 |
26 |
E52505 |
Hung Yan House, Hung Fuk Estate |
75 |
67 - 85 |
82 |
E52506 |
Hung Shing House, Hung Fuk Estate |
75 |
63 - 81 |
95 |
EHUT01 |
No. 141, Hung Uk Tsuen |
75 |
72 - 86 |
31 |
EHUT02 |
No. 81A, Hung Uk Tsuen |
75 |
80 - 85 |
54 |
EHUT03 |
No. 112, Kiu Tau Wai |
75 |
76 - 86 |
54 |
EHUT04 |
No. 85A, Kiu Tau Wai |
75 |
76 - 87 |
23 |
ESPT01 |
No. 181, Shek Po Tsuen |
75 |
66 - 80 |
31 |
ESPT04 |
Village house, Shek Po Tsuen |
75 |
62 - 84 |
71 |
ESPT05 |
No. 215, Shek Po Tsuen |
75 |
62 - 85 |
36 |
ESPT06 |
No. 201, Shek Po Tsuen |
75 |
62 - 87 |
36 |
ESST01 |
Block L, Bun Shing Garden |
75 |
67 - 86 |
48 |
ESST06 |
Block H, Fu Lam Garden |
75 |
62 - 86 |
68 |
ESST07 |
No, 60, San Sang Tsuen |
75 |
64 - 94 |
38 |
EKLUT01 |
Village house, Kau Lee Uk Tsuen |
75 |
75 - 84 |
52 |
ESCL01 |
No. 06, Sha Chau Lei Tsuen |
75 |
65 - 89 |
55 |
ESCL03 |
No. 45, Sha Chau Lei Tsuen |
75 |
68 - 89 |
39 |
ESCL04 |
No. 18, Sha Chau Lei Tsuen |
75 |
65 - 85 |
55 |
E12501 |
No. 108, Ha Tsuen Shi |
75 |
75 - 84 |
55 |
E12502 |
No. 115, Ha Tsuen Shi |
75 |
76 - 83 |
57 |
E12503 |
No. 216, Ha Tsuen Shi |
75 |
61 - 82 |
36 |
EHTS01 |
No. 1B, San Uk Tsuen |
75 |
69 - 91 |
36 |
ELUT01 |
Block 11, Yan Wu Garden |
75 |
82 - 87 |
37 |
ESKT02 |
No. 151, Sik Kong Wai |
75 |
76 - 87 |
24 |
ETKW01 |
No.108C,
Tseung Kong Wai |
75 |
65 - 82 |
19 |
EHMT01 |
No. 411, San Wai |
75 |
61 - 88 |
21 |
ETTT01 |
Block A Luxor Garden, Tung Tau Tsuen |
75 |
69 - 85 |
43 |
ETTT02 |
No. 111, Lo Uk Tsuen |
75 |
68 - 84 |
38 |
EFKT01 |
No.61, Fung Kong Tsuen |
75 |
64 - 85 |
42 |
EFKT03 |
No.80, Fung Kong Tsuen |
75 |
64 - 82 |
54 |
EFKT04 |
No.23F, Fung Kong Tsuen |
75 |
70 - 80 |
41 |
Notes:
(a) Construction noise assessment
criterion is 75 dB(A) for domestic premises and 70dB(A) for education
institutions (65dB(A) during examinations).
Table 4.18 Summary of Unmitigated Construction
Noise Assessment Results (Planned NSRs) during Normal Daytime Working Hours
NAP ID |
NAP Description |
Criterion, dB(A) (a) |
Predicted Unmitigated Construction Noise Levels, Leq (30min)
dB(A) |
Duration of Exceedance (Months) |
10353 |
Planned School in Site 1-3 |
70 (65) |
73 - 85 |
12 |
10354 |
Planned School in Site 1-3 |
70 (65) |
72 - 83 |
10 |
11203 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 1-12 |
75 |
71 - 82 |
8 |
11556 |
Planned School in Site 1-15 |
70 (65) |
70 - 84 |
25 |
11702 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 1-17 |
75 |
68 - 83 |
8 |
21801 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 2-18 |
75 |
75 - 84 |
59 |
21802 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 2-18 |
75 |
73 - 82 |
59 |
21803 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 2-18 |
75 |
69 - 85 |
29 |
21901 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 2-19 |
75 |
64 - 75 |
0 |
23101 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 2-31 |
75 |
68 - 83 |
10 |
40305 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-3 |
75 |
80 - 84 |
16 |
40602 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-6 |
75 |
74 - 82 |
10 |
42001 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-20 |
75 |
75 - 90 |
77 |
42005 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-20 |
75 |
72 - 91 |
77 |
42006 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-20 |
75 |
74 - 93 |
80 |
42203 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
75 |
68 - 84 |
27 |
42216 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
75 |
65 - 87 |
21 |
42251 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
75 |
66 - 96 |
36 |
42806 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-28 |
75 |
73 - 87 |
42 |
42853 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-28 |
75 |
71 - 83 |
42 |
42859 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-28 |
75 |
78 - 85 |
54 |
51601 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-16 |
75 |
66 - 90 |
51 |
51602 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-16 |
75 |
74 - 80 |
37 |
51702 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-17 |
75 |
74 - 86 |
60 |
51703 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-17 |
75 |
64 - 76 |
3 |
52151 |
Planned School in Site 5-21 |
70 (65) |
62 - 84 |
49 |
52401 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-24 |
75 |
62 - 85 |
36 |
52407 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-24 |
75 |
61 - 86 |
62 |
52408 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-24 |
75 |
70 - 87 |
61 |
52602 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-26 |
75 |
68 - 85 |
60 |
52604 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-26 |
75 |
68 - 87 |
60 |
53208 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-32 |
75 |
77 - 80 |
31 |
Notes:
(a) Construction noise assessment
criterion is 75 dB(A) for domestic premises and 70dB(A) for education
institutions (65dB(A) during examinations).
Mitigation Measures
¡P Good site practices to limit noise emissions at the sources;
¡P Use of quiet PME;
¡P Use of construction noise barriers or enclosures to screen noise from construction plant.
Good Site Practice
¡P Only well-maintained plant should be operated on-site and plant should be serviced regularly during the construction program;
¡P Silencers or mufflers on construction equipment should be utilised and should be properly maintained during the construction program;
¡P Mobile plant, is any, should be sited as far from NSRs as possible;
¡P Machines and plant (such as trucks) that may be in intermittent use should be shut down between work periods or should be throttled down to a minimum;
¡P Plant known to emit noise strongly in one direction should, wherever possible, be orientated so that the noise is directed away from the nearby NSRs;
¡P Material stockpiles and other structures should be effectively utilised, wherever practicable, in screening noise from on-site construction activities.
Management of locations
of Workfronts
Table
4.19 Details of Workfront
Management
Works area |
Construction activity |
Workfront Management |
#0201-3 |
Construction
of Road D7 and Road D8 - part 1 |
Only
1 workfront should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the planned NSRs
within Site 4-22. Other workfront should be located more than 300 m or have
no direct line of sight from the planned NSR within Site 4-22. |
#0201-4 |
Construction
of Road D8 - part 2 |
Maximum
2 workfronts should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the planned NSR
within Site 4-22 at any one time. Other workfront should be located more than
300 m or have no direct line of sight from the planned NSR within Site 4-22. |
#0201-5 |
Construction
of Road D8 - part 3 |
Only
1 workfront should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the planned NSR
within Site 4-28 at any one time. Other workfront should be located more than
300 m or have no direct line of sight from the planned NSR within Site 4-28. |
#0209-S5 |
Site
formation for sites 4-19 and associated area |
Only
1 workfront should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the planned NSR
within Site 4-22 at any one time. Other workfront should be located more than
300 m or have no direct line of sight from the planned NSR within Site 4-22. |
#0301-2 |
Construction
of Road D2 - part 2 |
Only
1 workfront should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the existing NSRs
within Ha Tsuen Shi and Yan Wu Garden (i.e. NSR E12051, E12052 and ELUT01) at
any one time. Other workfront should be located more than 300 m or have no
direct line of sight from the these NSRs. |
#0301-2 |
Construction
of Road D2 - part 3 |
Only
1 workfront should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the existing
YLPMSAA Tang Siu Tong Secondary School and existing village houses in Shek Po
Tsuen (i.e. NSR ETSW11 and ESPT01) at any one time. Other workfront should be
located more than 300 m or have no direct line of sight from the these NSRs. |
#0302-1 |
Site
development for Site No. 2-28, 2-33,1-15,1-19,1-20,1-22 |
Maximum
2 workfronts should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the existing NSRs
within Yan Wu Garden (i.e. ELUT01) at any one time. Other workfront should be
located more than 300 m or have no direct line of sight from the NSRs. |
#0303-2 |
Construction
of Road D5 |
Only
1 workfront should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the existing NSRs
within San Uk Tsuen (i.e. NSR EHTS01) at any one time. Other workfront should
be located more than 300 m or have no direct line of sight from the NSRs. |
#0315-S1 |
Site
Development for Sites 3-24, 3-31 and 3-34 |
Only
1 workfront should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the existing NSRs
within San Sang Tsuen (i.e. NSR ESST07) at any one time. Other workfront
should be located more than 300 m or have no direct line of sight from the
NSRs. |
#0307-2 |
Revitalisation of existing HSK Main Channel |
Only
1 workfront should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the existing NSRs
within Bellevue Court, Tin Sam Villa, Aster Court and Shek Po Tsuen (i.e. NSR
EBC01, E53906, E53104, E53106, ESPT05 and ESPT06) at any one time. Other
workfront should be located more than 300 m or have no direct line of sight
from the NSRs. |
#0317-S1 |
Site
Formation for Sites 1-28, 5-34
and 2-32 (portion 2) |
Maximum
2 workfronts should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the existing NSRs
within San Lee Uk Tsuen (i.e. ESLUT04 and ESLUT05) at any one time. Other
workfront should be located more than 300 m or have no direct line of sight
from the NSRs. |
#0317-S2 |
Site
Formation for Sites 1-27 (portion 2), 1-29, 1-31,1-30 |
Maximum
2 workfronts should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the existing NSRs
within Sha Chau Lei Tsuen (i.e. ESCL01, ESCL03 and ESCL04) at any one time.
Other workfront should be located more than 300 m or have no direct line of
sight from the NSRs. |
#0308-1 |
Site
Development for Sites 1-28, 1-32, 5-34 and 2-32 (portion 2) |
Only
1 workfront should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the existing NSRs
within San Lee Uk Tsuen (i.e. ESLUT04) at any one time. Other workfront
should be located more than 300 m or have no direct line of sight from the
NSRs. |
#0309-S6 |
Site formation for Sites 5-11, 5-13, 5-14 and
5-42 |
Only
1 workfront should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the planned school
at Site 5-21 (i.e. 52151) at any one time. Other workfront should be located
more than 300 m or have no direct line of sight from the NSR. |
#0401-3 |
Removal of existing Tin Ying Road - part 3 |
Only
1 workfront should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the existing VTC
Youth College (Tin Shui Wai) (i.e. ETSW08) at any one time. Other workfront
should be located more than 300 m or have no direct line of sight from the
NSR. |
#0402-1 |
Drainage Channel Revitalisation - part 1 |
Only
1 workfront should be allowed to operate within 300 m from the existing VTC
Youth College (Tin Shui Wai) (i.e. ETSW08) at any one time. Other workfront
should be located more than 300 m or have no direct line of sight from the
NSR. |
Construction Noise Barriers
Table 4.20 Summary
of Mitigated Construction Noise Assessment Results (Existing NSRs outside the
Project area) during Normal Daytime Working Hours
NAP ID |
NAP Description |
Criterion, dB(A) (a) |
Predicted Mitigated Construction Noise Levels, Leq (30min)
dB(A) |
Duration of Exceedance (Months) (b) |
ETCW02 |
No. 739 Oaklands Court |
75 |
58 - 74 |
- |
ETCW03 |
No. 703A, Chung Long Terrace |
75 |
53 - 72 |
- |
ENW02 |
No. 202, Shun Fung Wai |
75 |
58 - 67 |
- |
ESFW01 |
No. 332, Chung Uk Tsuen |
75 |
61 - 67 |
- |
ESFW02 |
Village house, Nai Wai |
75 |
57 - 68 |
- |
ESFW03 |
No. 368, Sun Fung Wai |
75 |
58 - 69 |
- |
ESFW04 |
No. 716, Chung Uk Tsuen |
75 |
57 - 68 |
- |
ECUT01 |
No. 16, Chung Uk Tsuen |
75 |
59 - 67 |
- |
ECUT02 |
No. 203, Chung Uk Tsuen |
75 |
62 - 67 |
- |
ESTC51 |
Shung Tak Catholic English College |
70 (65) |
54 - 60 |
- |
EUPT02 |
Flat C, Tower 1, Uptown |
75 |
61 - 61 |
- |
ELFS01 |
No. 30, Lau Fau Shan |
75 |
56 - 68 |
- |
ELFS02 |
No. 3H, San Hing Tsuen |
75 |
57 - 69 |
- |
ELFS03 |
No. 310, Sha Kong Wai |
75 |
57 - 72 |
- |
ELFS04 |
Wing Jan School/Wing Jan Lutheran Church |
70 (65) |
58 - 67 |
- (1) |
ELFS05 |
No. 1, Lau Fau Shan Road |
75 |
58 - 68 |
- |
ETSW01 |
Wah Yat House, Tin Wah Estate |
75 |
60 - 65 |
- |
ETSW02 |
Caritas Lok Kan School |
75 |
57 - 64 |
- |
ETSW03 |
Shui Lung House, Tin Shui Estate |
75 |
60 - 65 |
- |
ETSW04 |
The Yuen Yuen Institute MFBM Nei Ming Chan Lui Chung Tak
Memorial College |
70 (65) |
59 - 65 |
- |
ETSW05 |
Shui Fung House, Tin Shui Estate |
75 |
59 - 70 |
- |
ETSW06 |
Oi Tao House, Tin Oi Court |
75 |
56 - 70 |
- |
ETSW07 |
Block 7, Locwood Court |
75 |
57 - 72 |
- |
ETSW08 |
VTC Youth College (Tin Shui Wai) |
70 (65) |
58 - 70 |
-
(9) |
ETSW09 |
Shing Ting House, Tin Shing Court |
75 |
54 - 69 |
- |
ETSW10 |
Shing Kan House, Tin Shing Court |
75 |
56 - 65 |
- |
ETSW11 |
YLPMSAA Tang Siu Tong Secondary School |
70 (65) |
56 - 67 |
-
(2) |
Notes:
(a) Construction noise assessment
criterion is 75 dB(A) for domestic premises and 70 dB(A) for education
institutions (65 dB(A) during examinations).
(b) For educational institutes,
number in the round bracket denotes the number of months of noise exceedance
during examination period.
Examination period assumed to be March ¡V June and December of each year.
Table 4.21 Summary of Mitigated Construction Noise
Assessment Results (Existing NSRs within the Project area) during Normal
Daytime Working Hours
NAP ID |
NAP Description |
Criterion, dB(A) |
Predicted Mitigated Construction Noise Levels, Leq (30min)
dB(A) (a)&(b) |
Duration of Exceedance (Months) |
ETCW01 |
No. 430, village house |
75 |
57 - 73 |
- |
E53902 |
No. 125, Lee Fong Yuen |
75 |
57 - 71 |
- |
E53903 |
Village house, Tin Ha Road |
75 |
58 - 71 |
- |
ETST02 |
No. 13, Tin Sum |
75 |
50 - 65 |
- |
ETST04 |
No.211, Tin Sum |
75 |
57 - 61 |
- |
ETST05a |
No. 143 ,Tin Sum (South Façade) |
75 |
58 - 73 |
- |
ETST05b |
No. 143, Tin Sum, (West Façade) |
75 |
58 - 74 |
- |
ETST06 |
No. 290, Tin Sum |
75 |
57 - 70 |
- |
ESLUT01 |
No. 46A,
San Lee Uk Tsuen |
75 |
59 - 75 |
- |
ESLUT03 |
No. 62, San
Lee Uk Tsuen |
75 |
56 - 77 |
11 |
ESLUT04 |
No. 254,
San Lee Uk Tsuen |
75 |
55 - 75 |
- |
ESLUT05 |
No. 120,
San Lee Uk Tsuen |
75 |
57 - 75 |
- |
EBC01 |
House 15,
Bellevue Court |
75 |
53 - 73 |
- |
E53905 |
Village
House, Hung Shui Kiu Tin Sam Road |
75 |
54 - 70 |
- |
E53906 |
Flat C, Tin
Sam Villa |
75 |
56 - 72 |
- |
E53104 |
Flat C,
Block 1, Aster Court |
75 |
59 - 69 |
- |
E53106 |
Flat D,
Block 1, Aster Court |
75 |
59 - 74 |
- |
E52503 |
Hung Long
House, Hung Fuk Estate |
75 |
60 - 69 |
- |
E52504 |
Hung Yan
House, Hung Fuk Estate |
75 |
52 - 69 |
- |
E52505 |
Hung Yan
House, Hung Fuk Estate |
75 |
53 - 74 |
- |
E52506 |
Hung Shing
House, Hung Fuk Estate |
75 |
52 - 73 |
- |
EHUT01 |
No. 141,
Hung Uk Tsuen |
75 |
63 - 73 |
- |
EHUT02 |
No. 81A,
Hung Uk Tsuen |
75 |
67 - 73 |
- |
EHUT03 |
No. 112,
Kiu Tau Wai |
75 |
67 - 74 |
- |
EHUT04 |
No. 85A,
Kiu Tau Wai |
75 |
67 - 75 |
- |
ESPT01 |
No. 181,
Shek Po Tsuen |
75 |
54 - 68 |
- |
ESPT04 |
Village
house, Shek Po Tsuen |
75 |
51 - 71 |
- |
ESPT05 |
No. 215,
Shek Po Tsuen |
75 |
51 - 71 |
- |
ESPT06 |
No. 201,
Shek Po Tsuen |
75 |
51 - 73 |
- |
ESST01 |
Block L,
Bun Shing Garden |
75 |
51 - 72 |
- |
ESST06 |
Block H, Fu
Lam Garden |
75 |
51 - 73 |
- |
ESST07 |
No, 60, San
Sang Tsuen |
75 |
53 - 77 |
4 |
EKLUT01 |
Village
house, Kau Lee Uk Tsuen |
75 |
59 - 70 |
- |
ESCL01 |
No. 06, Sha
Chau Lei Tsuen |
75 |
54 - 74 |
- |
ESCL03 |
No. 45, Sha
Chau Lei Tsuen |
75 |
55 - 75 |
- |
ESCL04 |
No. 18, Sha
Chau Lei Tsuen |
75 |
55 - 71 |
- |
E12501 |
No. 108, Ha
Tsuen Shi |
75 |
59 - 71 |
- |
E12502 |
No. 115, Ha
Tsuen Shi |
75 |
63 - 69 |
- |
E12503 |
No. 216, Ha
Tsuen Shi |
75 |
50 - 68 |
- |
EHTS01 |
No. 1B, San
Uk Tsuen |
75 |
58 - 76 |
10 |
ELUT01 |
Block 11,
Yan Wu Garden |
75 |
68 - 74 |
- |
ESKT02 |
No. 151,
Sik Kong Wai |
75 |
64 - 73 |
- |
ETKW01 |
No.108C, Tseung Kong Wai |
75 |
60 - 70 |
- |
EHMT01 |
No. 411,
San Wai |
75 |
52 - 71 |
- |
ETTT01 |
Block A
Luxor Garden, Tung Tau Tsuen |
75 |
53 - 74 |
- |
ETTT02 |
No. 111, Lo
Uk Tsuen |
75 |
52 - 75 |
- |
EFKT01 |
No.61, Fung
Kong Tsuen |
75 |
58 - 73 |
- |
EFKT03 |
No.80, Fung
Kong Tsuen |
75 |
58 - 71 |
- |
EFKT04 |
No.23F,
Fung Kong Tsuen |
75 |
63 - 74 |
- |
Notes:
(a) Construction noise assessment criterion
is 75 dB(A) for domestic premises and 70 dB(A) for education institutions (65
dB(A) during examinations).
(b) Bold faced value indicates the
predicted noise level exceeds the relevant noise limit.
Table 4.22 Summary
of Mitigated Construction Noise Assessment Results (Planned NSRs) during Normal
Daytime Working Hours
NAP ID |
NSR |
Criterion, dB(A) |
Predicted Mitigated Construction Noise Levels, Leq (30min)
dB(A) (a) |
Duration of Exceedance (Months) (c) |
10353 |
Planned School in Site 1-3 |
70 (65) |
57 - 70 |
- (3) |
10354 |
Planned School in Site 1-3 |
70 (65) |
56 - 69 |
- (3) |
11203 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 1-12 |
75 |
55 - 68 |
- |
11556 |
Planned School in Site 1-15 |
70 (65) |
54 - 69 |
- (10) |
11702 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 1-17 |
75 |
56 - 68 |
- |
21801 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 2-18 |
75 |
66 - 74 |
- |
21802 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 2-18 |
75 |
66 - 72 |
- |
21803 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 2-18 |
75 |
62 - 72 |
- |
21901 |
Planned
Residential Development in Site 2-19 |
75 |
57 - 63 |
- |
23101 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 2-31 |
75 |
58 - 68 |
- |
40305 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-3 |
75 |
69 - 72 |
- |
40602 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-6 |
75 |
64 - 69 |
- |
42001 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-20 |
75 |
64 - 75 |
- |
42005 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-20 |
75 |
62 - 74 |
- |
42006 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-20 |
75 |
63 - 77 |
8 |
42203 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
75 |
57 - 69 |
- |
42216 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
75 |
54 - 69 |
- |
42251 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
75 |
59 - 77 |
12 |
42806 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-28 |
75 |
64 - 72 |
- |
42853 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-28 |
75 |
61 - 70 |
- |
42859 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-28 |
75 |
68 - 73 |
- |
51601 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-16 |
75 |
53 - 75 |
- |
51602 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-16 |
75 |
59 - 66 |
- |
51702 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-17 |
75 |
56 - 74 |
- |
51703 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-17 |
75 |
53 - 62 |
- |
52151 |
Planned School in Site 5-21 |
70 (65) |
51 - 70 |
- (8) |
52401 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-24 |
75 |
51 - 70 |
- |
52407 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-24 |
75 |
50 - 74 |
- |
52408 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-24 |
75 |
57 - 75 |
- |
52602 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-26 |
75 |
55 - 72 |
- |
52604 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-26 |
75 |
55 - 74 |
- |
53208 |
Planned Residential Development in Site 5-32 |
75 |
59 - 67 |
- |
Notes:
(a)
Construction
noise assessment criterion is 75 dB(A) for domestic premises and 70 dB(A) for
education institutions (65 dB(A) during examinations).
(b)
Bold
faced value indicates the predicted noise level exceeds the relevant noise
limit.
(c)
For
educational institutes, number in the round bracket denotes the number of
months of noise exceedance during
examination period. Examination period assumed to be March ¡V June and December of
each year.
(d) Further Noise Mitigation Measures.
(e)
Table
4.23
Detail of Noise Exceedance
NAP |
NAP ID |
Range of exceedance, dB(A) |
Duration of Noise Exceedance |
Critical Construction Activities (Work area) lead to the
Exceedance |
Wing Jan School/Wing Jan Lutheran Church |
ELFS04 |
2 (during
examination) |
Dec 2031 |
Site formation for Sites 2-1, 2-2, 2-3, 2-4, 2-5, 2-7 and
2-35 (#0407-1) |
VTC Youth College (Tin Shui Wai) |
ETSW08 |
1-5 (during
examination) |
Dec 2033, Mar ¡V Jun 2034 Dec 2035 Mar ¡V May 2036 |
Tim Sam Channel (#0307-1) Tin Ying Road - part 3 (#0401-3) Channel revitalisation - part 1 (#0402-1) Site formation for a new DCS at site 1-24 (#0405) Site formation for Sites 1-8, 1-9, 1-10, 1-11, 1-13, 1-14
and 1-16 (#0407-5) |
YLPMSAA Tang Siu Tong Secondary School |
ETSW11 |
2 (during
examination) |
Dec 2031 and Mar 2032 |
Construction of Road D2 - part 3 (#0301-3) |
No. 62, San Lee Uk Tsuen |
ESLUT03 |
2 |
Mar 2025 ¡V Jan 2026 |
Site formation for Site 5-36, 5-37 and 5-38 (#0016-2) |
No, 60, San Sang Tsuen |
ESST07 |
2 |
June ¡V Sept 2033 |
Site development for Sites 3-24, 3-31 and 3-34 (#0315-S1) |
No. 1B, San Uk Tsuen |
EHTS01 |
1 |
Aug 2032 - May 2033 |
Construction of Road D5 (#0303-2) |
Planned School in Site 1-3 |
10353 |
5 (during
examination) |
Apr ¡VJune 2033 |
Site formation for Sites 1-2, 1-4, 1-5, 1-6 and 1-7 (#0407-4) |
Planned School in Site 1-3 |
10354 |
4 (during
examination) |
Apr ¡VJune 2033 |
Site formation for Sites 1-2, 1-4, 1-5, 1-6 and 1-7 (#0407-4) |
Planned School in Site 1-15 |
11556 |
2
-4 (during
examination) |
Dec 2033 Mar ¡V Jun 2034 Dec 2037 Mar ¡V Jun 2038 |
Site formation for Sites 1-8, 1-9, 1-10, 1-11, 1-13, 1-14
and 1-16 (#0407-5) Site development for Sites 1-10, 1-11 and 1-14 (#0408-4) |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-20 |
42006 |
2 |
Nov 2028 - Jun 2029 |
Construction of Road D7 and Road D8 - part 1 (#0201-3) |
Planned Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
42251 |
2 |
Jan ¡V Dec 2028 |
Site formation for sites 4-19 and associated area (#0209-S5) |
Planned School in Site 5-21 |
52151 |
3-5 (during examination) |
Dec 2031 Mar 2032 Dec 2034 Mar ¡V June, Dec 2035 |
Site formation for Sites 5-11, 5-13, 5-14 and 5-42 (#0309-S6) Site development for S3 (Site No.
1-1,1-3,2-25,5-11,5-14,5-13,2-31) (#0302-3) Construction of Road D5 (#0303-2) |
Evaluation of Residual Environmental Impacts
Assessment Approach and Methodology
4.7.1
Road traffic noise
impact is predicted using the methodology provided in the UK Department of
Transport Calculation of Road Traffic Noise (CRTN) 1988. The computer model RoadNoise 2000 which
complies with the CRTN is used for the prediction. The noise levels are presented in terms
of noise levels exceeded for 10% of the one-hour period during the peak traffic
flow, i.e. L10(1hour) dB(A).
4.7.3
The following scenarios are studied in the assessment:
¡P Unmitigated scenario in Year 2048;
¡P Mitigated scenario in Year 2048; and
¡P Prevailing scenario in Year 2018 for indirect technical remedies eligibility assessment.
(a)
KSWH and Yuen Long Highway:
80 km per hour;
(b)
Tin Ying Road (for
prevailing scenario only), Hung Tin Road and certain sections of Castle Peak
Road: 70 km per hour; and
(c)
Concerned roads other than
those listed in (a) and (b)
above: 50 km per hour.
¡P The predicted overall noise level from the Project roads, together with other traffic noise in the vicinity must be above a specified noise level (for example, 70 dB(A) for domestic premises and 65 dB(A) for educational institutions. All are in L10 (1hour));
¡P The predicted overall noise level is at least 1.0 dB(A) more than the prevailing traffic noise level, i.e. the total traffic noise level existing before the works to construct Project roads were commenced; and
¡P The contribution to the increase in the predicted overall noise level from the Project roads must be at least 1.0 dB(A).
Prediction and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts
Table 4.24 Summary
of Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Assessment Results (Existing NSRs outside the
Project Area)
NSR ID |
Description |
Existing / Planned Use |
NAP ID |
Criteria, dB(A) |
Predicted Unmitigated Overall Noise Level, dB(A) |
Compliance of Noise Criteria |
E1-OA |
Tin Wah Estate |
Existing Residential |
E1-OA_R01 |
70 |
66-67 |
Yes |
E1-OB_R |
Tin Shing Court |
Existing Residential |
E1-OB_R01 |
70 |
67-68 |
Yes |
E1-OB_E0 |
Q.E.S. Old Students¡¦ Association Branch
Primary School |
Existing Educational |
E1-OB_E01 to E1-OB_E02 |
65 |
56-74 |
No |
E1-OB_E1 |
YLPMSAA Tang Siu Tong Secondary School |
Existing Educational |
E1-OB_E11 to E1-OB_E12 |
65 |
61-74 |
No |
E1-OB_E2 |
Lions Clubs International Ho Tak Sum Primary
School |
Existing Educational |
E1-OB_E21 |
65 |
57-69 |
No |
E2-OA |
Village House at Lau Fau Shan |
Existing Village |
E2-OA_R01 |
70 |
66-67 |
Yes |
E2-OB |
San Hing Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E2-OB_R01 to E2-OB_R03 |
70 |
71-72 |
No |
E2-OC |
Sha Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
E2-OC_R01 to E2-OC_R04 |
70 |
71-76 |
No |
E2-OD |
Tin Yan Estate |
Existing Residential |
E2-OD_R01 |
70 |
66-67 |
Yes |
E4-OA |
Tsing Cheun Wai |
Existing Village |
E4-OA_R01 to E4-OA_R04 |
70 |
71-73 |
No |
E4-OB |
Nai Wai |
Existing Village |
E4-OB_R01 |
70 |
77 |
No |
E4-OC |
Sun Fung Wai |
Existing Village |
E4-OC_R01 to E4-OC_R03 |
70 |
72-80 |
No |
E4-OD |
Chung Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E4-OD_R01 to E4-OD_R04 |
70 |
74-78 |
No |
E5-OA |
Tong Fong Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-OA-R01 & E5-OA-R02 |
70 |
67-79 |
No |
E5-OB |
Hang Mei Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-OB-R01 |
70 |
75 |
No |
E5-OC |
Tai Tao Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-OC-R01 |
70 |
71 |
No |
E5-OD |
Uptown |
Existing Residential |
E5-OD_R01 |
70 |
71-76 |
No |
E5-OE |
Shung Tak Catholic English College |
Existing Educational |
E5-OE_E01 |
65 |
73-74 |
No |
E5-OF |
Treasure Court |
Existing Residential |
E5-OF_R01 |
70 |
73 |
No |
E5-OG |
Lai Hung Garden |
Existing Residential |
E5-OG_R01 |
70 |
74 |
No |
E5-OH |
Bauhinia Garden |
Existing Residential |
E5-OH_R01 |
70 |
74-75 |
No |
Note: Full names of the abbreviations of uses should be referred to
the List of Abbreviations.
Table 4.25 Summary of Unmitigated Road Traffic
Noise Assessment Results (Existing NSRs within the Project Area)
NSR ID |
Description |
Use |
NAP ID |
Criteria, dB(A) |
Predicted Unmitigated Overall Noise Level,
dB(A) |
Compliance of Noise Criteria |
E1-IA |
Tseung Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
E1-IA_R01 |
70 |
76 |
No |
E1-IB |
Hong Mei Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IB_R01 |
70 |
54-55 |
Yes |
E1-IC |
Tung Tau Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IC_R01 to |
70 |
64-69 |
Yes |
E1-ID |
Lo Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-ID_R01 |
70 |
59 |
Yes |
E1-IE |
Sik Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
E1-IE_R01 |
70 |
69-70 |
Yes |
E1-IF |
Ha Tsuen Shi |
Existing Village |
E1-IF_R01 to |
70 |
64-76 |
No |
E1-IG |
San Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IG_R01 to |
70 |
65-69 |
Yes |
E1-IH |
Sha Chau Lei |
Existing Village |
E1-IH_R01 to |
70 |
66-70 |
Yes |
E1-IJ |
San Sang Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IJ_R01 to |
70 |
68-73 |
No |
E1-IK |
Shek Po Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IK_R01 to |
70 |
64-73 |
No |
E2-IA |
Fung Kong Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E2-IA_R01 to |
70 |
72-76 |
No |
E4-IA |
Tin Sum Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E4-IA_R01 to |
70 |
72-73 |
No |
E4-IB |
Tsing Chuen Wai |
Existing Village |
E4-IB_R01 |
70 |
69-72 |
No |
E5-IA |
Kiu Tau Wai |
Existing Village |
E5-IA_R01 |
70 |
64-69 |
Yes |
E5-IB_R |
Hung Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-IB_R01 to |
70 |
63-74 |
No |
E5-IB_C |
Chinese Mission Seminary |
Existing Church |
E5-IB_C01 |
65 |
73-74 |
No |
E5-IC |
San Lee Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-IC_R01 |
70 |
73 |
No |
E1-26 |
Existing Homes for the Elderly (Yeung Chun Pui
and Ching Chung) |
IC |
E1-26_H01 to |
70 |
59-63 |
Yes |
E4-30 |
Ling Liang Worldwide Evangelistic Mission Hung Shui Kiu Ling
Liang Church |
IC |
E4-30_C01 |
65 |
72 |
No |
E5-23 |
Sheffield
Villas |
R3 |
E5-23_R01 to |
70 |
64-66 |
Yes |
E5-25 |
Hung
Fuk Estate |
RSc |
E5-25_R01 to |
70 |
59-73 |
No |
E5-31 |
Existing Residential Development |
R2 |
E5-31_R01 to |
70 |
61-73 |
No |
E5-35 |
Bellevue
Court |
R4 |
E5-35_R01 |
70 |
64-73 |
No |
E5-39 |
Existing Residential Development |
R3 |
E5-39_R01 to |
70 |
68-77 |
No |
E5-44 |
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day
Saints (Hung Shui Kiu) |
R3 |
E5-44_C01 to |
65 |
68-71 |
No |
O5-06 |
Committed Subsidised Sales Flat |
R2(SSF)c |
O5-06_R01 to |
70 |
59-75 |
No |
O5-33 |
Committed Residential Development |
R2 |
O5-33_R01 to |
70 |
72-73 |
No |
Note: Full names of the abbreviations of uses should be referred to
the List of Abbreviations.
Table 4.26 Summary of Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Assessment Results (Planned NSRs within the Project Area)
NSR ID |
Use |
Description |
NAP ID |
Criteria, dB(A) |
Predicted Unmitigated Overall Noise Level, dB(A) |
Compliance of Noise Criteria |
P1-02 |
R2(SSF)c |
Site 1-02 |
P1-02_R01 to P1-02_R31 |
70 |
57-75 |
No |
P1-03 |
E |
Site 1-03 |
P1-03_E01 to P1-03_E11 |
65 |
53-64 |
Yes |
P1-04 |
R2c |
Site 1-04 |
P1-04_R01 |
70 |
47-60 |
Yes |
P1-05 |
R2c |
Site 1-05 |
P1-05_R01 to P1-05_R11 |
70 |
57-67 |
Yes |
P1-06 |
R2c |
Site 1-06 |
P1-06_R01 to P1-06_R11 |
70 |
64-70 |
Yes |
P1-08 |
R2c |
Site 1-08 |
P1-08_R01 to P1-08_R22 |
70 |
66-74 |
No |
P1-09 |
R2c |
Site 1-09 |
P1-09_R01 to P1-09_R12 |
70 |
68-75 |
No |
P1-12 |
R2 |
Site 1-12 |
P1-12_R01 |
70 |
68-73 |
No |
P1-15 |
E |
Site 1-15 |
P1-15_E01 to P1-15_E05 |
65 |
65-73 |
No |
P1-17 |
R2 |
Site 1-17 |
P1-17_R01 |
70 |
57-63 |
Yes |
P1-18 |
E |
Site 1-18 |
P1-18_E01 to P1-18_E03 |
65 |
57-68 |
No |
P1-19 |
R2 |
Site 1-19 |
P1-19_R01 to P1-19_R21 |
70 |
69-76 |
No |
P1-21 |
R2c |
Site 1-21 |
P1-21_R01 to P1-21_R21 |
70 |
54-69 |
Yes |
P1-22 |
E |
Site 1-22 |
P1-22_E01 to P1-22_E11 |
65 |
63-79 |
No |
P2-02 |
R3 |
Site 2-02 |
P2-02_R01 to P2-02_R32 |
70 |
61-67 |
Yes |
P2-03 |
R3 |
Site 2-03 |
P2-03_R01 to P2-03_R21 |
70 |
52-65 |
Yes |
P2-07 |
R3 |
Site 2-07 |
P2-07_R01 to P2-07_R21 |
70 |
62-66 |
Yes |
P2-09 |
E |
Site 2-09 |
P2-09_E01 to P2-09_E02 |
65 |
57-66 |
No |
P2-10 |
R3 |
Site 2-10 |
P2-10_R01 to P2-10_R31 |
70 |
62-70 |
Yes |
P2-11 |
R3c |
Site 2-11 |
P2-11_R01 to P2-11_R31 |
70 |
66-74 |
No |
P2-14 |
R3 |
Site 2-14 |
P2-14_R01 to P2-14_R12 |
70 |
62-68 |
Yes |
P2-15 |
E |
Site 2-15 |
P2-15_R01 |
70 |
62-64 |
Yes |
P2-16 |
E |
Site 2-16 |
P2-16_E01 to P2-16_R15 |
65 |
63-69 |
No |
P2-18 |
RR4 |
Site 2-18 |
P2-18_R01 to P2-18_R05 |
70 |
69-71 |
No |
P2-19 |
RR4 |
Site 2-19 |
P2-19_R01 |
70 |
66-67 |
Yes |
P2-24 |
E |
Site 2-24 |
P2-24_E01 to P2-24_E11 |
65 |
59-70 |
Yes |
P2-25 |
G |
Site 2-25 |
P2-25_H01 |
70 |
69-71 |
No |
P2-26 |
E |
Site 2-26 |
P2-26_E01 to P2-26_E11 |
65 |
63-70 |
No |
P2-28 |
E |
Site 2-28 |
P2-28_E01 to P2-28_E02 |
65 |
60-68 |
No |
P2-30 |
RSc |
Site 2-30 |
P2-30_R01 to P2-30_R21 |
70 |
48-70 |
Yes |
P2-31 |
R2(SSF)c |
Site 2-31 |
P2-31_R01 to P2-31_R21 |
70 |
61-68 |
Yes |
P4-01 |
G |
Site 4-01 |
P4-01_R01 to P4-01_R13 |
70 |
64-75 |
No |
P4-03 |
R2(SSF)c |
Site 4-03 |
P4-03_R01 to P4-03_R11 |
70 |
61-76 |
No |
P4-04 |
RSc |
Site 4-04 |
P4-04_R01 to P4-04_R24 |
70 |
56-71 |
No |
P4-05 |
RSc |
Site 4-05 |
P4-05_R01 to P4-05_R14 |
70 |
65-72 |
No |
P4-06 |
R2(SSF)c |
Site 4-06 |
P4-06_R01 to P4-06_R12 |
70 |
66-74 |
No |
P4-08 |
E |
Site 4-08 |
P4-08_E01 to P4-08_E11 |
65 |
61-65 |
Yes |
P4-09 |
R1c |
Site 4-09 |
P4-09_E06 |
70 |
62-68 |
Yes |
P4-17 |
OU |
Site 4-17 |
P4-17_E01 to P4-17_E06 |
65 |
57-73 |
No |
P4-20 |
RR4 |
Site 4-20 |
P4-20_R01 to P4-20_R04 |
70 |
64-72 |
No |
P4-22 |
RSc |
Site 4-22 |
P4-22_R01 to P4-22_R42 |
70 |
52-71 |
No |
P4-24 |
R2(SSF)c |
Site 4-24 |
P4-24_R01 to P4-24_R46 |
70 |
66-75 |
No |
P4-25a |
OU(C&R) |
Site 4-25a |
P4-25a_R01 |
70 |
65-69 |
Yes |
P4-25b |
OU(C&R) |
Site 4-25b |
P4-25b_R01 to P4-25b_R11 |
70 |
61-71 |
No |
P4-25c |
OU(C&R) |
Site 4-25c |
P4-25c_R01 to P4-25c_R11 |
70 |
52-60 |
Yes |
P4-26 |
R1c |
Site 4-26 |
P4-26_R01 to P4-26_R21 |
70 |
64-71 |
No |
P4-28 |
RSc |
Site 4-28 |
P4-28_R01 to P4-28_R44 |
70 |
54-73 |
No |
P4-29 |
OU(C&R) |
Site 4-29 |
P4-29_R01 to P4-29_R31 |
70 |
50-71 |
No |
P4-32 |
G |
Site 4-32 |
P4-32_R01 to P4-32_R14 |
70 |
63-73 |
No |
P4-33 |
E |
Site 4-33 |
P4-33_E01 to P4-33_E03 |
65 |
67-75 |
No |
P4-36 |
E |
Site 4-36 |
P4-36_E02 to P4-36_R01 |
65 |
66-70 |
No |
P5-07a |
OU(C&R) |
Site 5-07a |
P5-07a_R01 ¡V P5-07a_R21 |
70 |
55-71 |
No |
P5-07b |
OU(C&R) |
Site 5-07b |
P5-07b_R01 to P5-07b_R21 |
70 |
60-73 |
No |
P5-08 |
OU(C&R) |
Site 5-08 |
P5-08_R01 to P5-08_R11 |
70 |
69-73 |
No |
P5-09 |
OU(C&R) |
Site 5-09 |
P5-09_R01 to P5-09_R31 |
70 |
60-71 |
No |
P5-14 |
E |
Site 5-14 |
P5-14_E01 to P5-14_E11 |
65 |
67-74 |
No |
P5-16 |
R2(SSF)c |
Site 5-16 |
P5-16_R01 to P5-16_R11 |
70 |
58-79 |
No |
P5-17 |
RSc |
Site 5-17 |
P5-17_E04 to P5-17_R12 |
65 |
54-75 |
No |
P5-21 |
E |
Site 5-21 |
P5-21_E01 to P5-21_E02 |
65 |
61-66 |
No |
P5-22 |
Site 5-22 |
R3 |
P5-22_R01 to P5-22_R03 |
70 |
65-77 |
No |
P5-24 |
R2(SSF)c |
Site 5-24 |
P5-24_R01 to P5-24_R23 |
70 |
43-68 |
Yes |
P5-26 |
R2(SSF) |
Site 5-26 |
P5-26_R01 to P5-26_R04 |
70 |
63-74 |
No |
P5-28 |
G |
Site 5-28 |
P5-28_H01 to P5-32_R01 to P5-32_R82 |
70 |
64-72 |
No |
P5-32 |
OU(C&R) |
Site 5-32 |
P5-32_R01 to P5-32_R82 |
70 |
62-80 |
No |
P5-34 |
E |
Site 5-34 |
P5-34_E01 to P5-34_E11 |
65 |
60-73 |
No |
P5-37 |
E |
Site 5-37 |
P5-37_E01 to P5-37_E02 |
65 |
70-74 |
No |
Note: Full names of the abbreviations of uses should be referred to
the List of Abbreviations.
Table 4.27 Locations of Proposed Low Noise
Road Surfacing
ID |
Road |
Length,
m |
LNS1 |
Not used |
- |
LNS2 |
Tin Wah
Road |
350 |
LNS3 |
Proposed
Roundabout at Junction J2 |
210 |
LNS4 |
Proposed
Road D1 |
500 |
LNS5 |
Proposed
Road near Site2-26 |
280 |
LNS6 |
Proposed
Road D1 |
400 |
LNS7 |
Proposed
Road D1 |
640 |
LNS8 |
Proposed
Road D1 (Depressed Section) |
120 |
LNS9 |
Proposed
Road L1 |
670 |
LNS10 |
Proposed
Road P1 |
560 |
LNS11 |
Proposed
Road L5 |
440 |
LNS12 |
Proposed
Road D2 |
280 |
LNS13 |
Proposed
Road D2 (Depressed Section) |
180 |
LNS14 |
Proposed
Road D2 |
1260 |
LNS15 |
Proposed
Road L3 |
390 |
LNS16 |
Proposed
Road D2 |
370 |
LNS17 |
Proposed
Roundabout at Junction J8 |
190 |
LNS18 |
Ping Ha
Road |
110 |
LNS19 |
Not used |
- |
LNS20 |
Kiu Fat
Street |
280 |
LNS22 |
Proposed
Road near Site 5-13 |
730 |
LNS23 |
Hung Chi
Road / Proposed Road L5 |
340 |
LNS24 |
Not used |
- |
LNS25 |
Note used |
- |
LNS26 |
Not used |
- |
LNS27 |
Proposed
Road near Site 4-24 |
140 |
LNS28 |
Not used |
- |
LNS29 |
Proposed
Road L2 |
670 |
LNS30 |
Proposed
Road near Site 4-29 |
270 |
LNS31 |
Not used |
- |
LNS32 |
Proposed
Road P1 |
790 |
LNS33 |
Proposed
Road P1 |
380 |
LNS34 |
Proposed
Road P1 |
610 |
LNS35 |
Proposed
Road D8 |
480 |
LNS36 |
Proposed
Road near Site 4-33 |
210 |
Table 4.28 List of Proposed Traffic Noise
Mitigation Measures
Noise Barrier ID |
Location |
Barrier Type |
Height, mAG |
Length, m |
CB1 |
Proposed Road D2 |
Cantilever |
6+4.2 m at 45 degree |
50 |
CB2 |
Not Used |
- |
- |
- |
CB3a |
Proposed Road P1 |
Cantilever |
5.5+2.5 m at 45 degree |
80 |
CB3b |
Proposed Road P1 |
Cantilever |
5.5+2.5 m at 45 degree |
130 |
CB4 |
Not Used |
- |
- |
- |
CB5 |
Proposed Road D2, near Site 1-22 |
Cantilever |
6+4.2 m at 45 degree |
130 |
VB2 |
Tin Wah Road / Lau Fau Shan Road |
Vertical |
5 |
140 |
VB3 |
Proposed Road D1 |
Vertical |
3 |
120 |
VB4 |
Proposed Road D2 |
Vertical |
5 |
140 |
VB5 |
Proposed Road D1 |
Vertical |
5 |
90 |
VB6 |
Proposed Road D1 |
Vertical |
5 |
150 |
VB7 |
Proposed Road D3 |
Vertical |
4 |
60 |
VB8 |
Proposed Road D3 |
Vertical |
4 |
50 |
VB9 |
Proposed Road D3 |
Vertical |
4 |
50 |
VB10 |
Proposed Road D2 |
Vertical |
4 |
180 |
VB11 |
Not
used |
- |
- |
- |
VB12 |
Proposed Road D2 |
Vertical |
6 |
110 |
VB13 |
Not
used |
- |
- |
- |
VB14 |
Not
used |
- |
- |
- |
VB15 |
Proposed Road D2 |
Vertical |
5 |
30 |
VB16 |
Proposed Road D2 |
Vertical |
5 |
60 |
VB17 |
Proposed Road D2 |
Vertical |
5 |
20 |
VB18 |
Proposed Road D2 |
Vertical |
4 |
60 |
VB19 |
Not used |
- |
- |
- |
VB20 |
Proposed Road L3 |
Vertical |
7 |
110 |
VB21 |
Proposed Road D2/ Ping Ha Road |
Vertical |
7 |
50 |
VB22 |
Not used |
- |
- |
- |
VB23 |
Proposed Road D2/ Ping Ha Road |
Vertical |
7 |
130 |
VB24 |
Ping Ha Road |
Vertical |
7 |
160 |
VB25 |
Not used |
- |
- |
- |
VB26 |
Proposed Road L1 |
Vertical |
5 |
70 |
VB27 |
Not used |
- |
- |
- |
VB28 |
Hung Tin Road |
Vertical |
5 |
90 |
VB29 |
Hung Tin Road |
Vertical |
7 |
80 |
VB30 |
Not used |
- |
- |
- |
VB31 |
Hung Tin Road |
Vertical |
7 |
60 |
VB32 |
Not
used |
- |
- |
- |
VB33 |
Not
used |
- |
- |
- |
VB34 |
Not
used |
Vertical |
7 |
30 |
VB35 |
Proposed Road D5 |
Vertical |
5 |
80 |
VB36 |
Proposed Road D5 |
Vertical |
5 |
70 |
VB37 |
Proposed Road D5 |
Vertical |
3 |
70 |
VB38 |
Proposed Road D5 |
Vertical |
3 |
80 |
VB39 |
Proposed Road P1 |
Vertical |
3 |
100 |
VB40 |
Proposed Road P1 |
Vertical |
3 |
130 |
VB41 |
Proposed Road D2 |
Vertical |
5 |
130 |
VB42 |
Not used |
- |
- |
- |
Table 4.29 Details of Proposed Boundary Wall for Planned Education Institutes
Boundary Wall ID |
Location |
Barrier Type |
Height, mAG |
Length, m |
VB1 |
Boundary Wall at Site 2-9 |
Vertical |
3 |
65 |
VB43 |
Boundary wall at Site 4-36 |
Vertical |
3 |
60 |
VB44 |
Boundary wall at Site 4-36 |
Vertical |
3 |
120 |
VB45 |
Boundary wall at Site 4-33 |
Vertical |
3 |
200 |
VB46 |
Boundary wall at Site 5-34 |
Vertical |
3 |
150 |
VB47 |
Boundary wall at Site 5-34 |
Vertical |
3 |
160 |
Table 4.30 Summary of Mitigated Road Traffic Noise
Assessment Results (Existing NSRs outside the Project area)
NSR ID |
Description |
Existing / Planned Use |
NAP ID |
Criteria, dB(A) |
Predicted Mitigated Overall Noise
Level, dB(A) |
Major
Noise Source causing Exceedance |
E1-OA |
Tin Wah Estate |
Existing
Residential |
E1-OA_R01 |
70 |
65-67 |
- |
E1-OB |
Tin
Shing Court |
Existing
Residential |
E1-IB_R01 |
70 |
62-66 |
- |
E1-OB_E0 |
Q.E.S. Old Students'
Association Branch Primary School |
Existing
Educational |
E1-OB_E01 to
E1-OB_E02 |
65 |
56-74 |
Ping Ha Road (East of Hung Tin Road) |
E1-OB_E1 |
YLPMSAA Tang Siu
Tong Secondary School |
Existing
Educational |
E1-OB_E11 to
E1-OB_E12 |
65 |
61-74 |
Ping Ha Road (East of Hung Tin Road). Hung Tin Road |
E1-OB_E2 |
Lions Clubs
International Ho Tak Sum Primary School |
Existing
Educational |
E1-OB_E21 |
65 |
54-65 |
- |
E2-OA |
Village House at
Lau Fau Shan |
Existing Village |
E2-OA_R01 |
70 |
66-67 |
- |
E2-OB |
San Hing Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E2-OB_R01 to
E2-OB_R03 |
70 |
71-72 |
Lau Fau Shan Road |
E2-OC |
Sha Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
E2-OC_R01 to
E2-OC_R04 |
70 |
64-70 |
- |
E2-OD |
Tin
Yan Estate |
Existing
Residential |
E2-OD_R01 |
70 |
66-67 |
- |
E4-OA |
Tsing Cheun Wai |
Existing Village |
E4-OA_R01 to E4-OA_R04 |
70 |
68-70 |
- |
E4-OB |
Nai Wai |
Existing Village |
E4-OB_R01 |
70 |
76-77 |
Castle Peak Road |
E4-OC |
Sun Fung Wai |
Existing Village |
E4-OC_R01 to E4-OC_R03 |
70 |
72-78 |
Castle Peak Road |
E4-OD |
Chung Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E4-OD_R01 to E4-OD_R04 |
70 |
74-78 |
Castle Peak Road |
E5-OA |
Tong Fong Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-OA-R01 &
E5-OA-R02 |
70 |
66-79 |
Ping Ha Road (East of Hung Tin Road) |
E5-OB |
Hang Mei Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-OB-R01 |
70 |
75 |
Ping Ha Road (East of Hung Tin Road) |
E5-OC |
Tai Tao Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-OC-R01 |
70 |
71 |
Castle Peak Road, Hung Tin Road |
E5-OD |
Uptown |
Existing
Residential |
E5-OD_R01 |
70 |
72-76 |
Castle Peak Road, Hung Tin Road |
E5-OE |
Shung Tak Catholic
English College |
Existing
Educational |
E5-OE_E01 |
65 |
73-74 |
Castle Peak Road,
Hung Tin Road |
E5-OF |
Treasure Court |
Existing
Residential |
E5-OF_R01 |
70 |
73 |
Castle Peak Road |
E5-OG |
Lai Hung Garden |
Existing
Residential |
E5-OG_R01 |
70 |
74 |
Castle Peak Road |
E5-OH |
Bauhinia Garden |
Existing
Residential |
E5-OH_R01 |
70 |
74-75 |
Castle Peak Road |
Table 4.31
Summary of Mitigated Road Traffic Noise Assessment Results (Existing NSRs
within the Project area)
NSR ID |
Description |
Use |
NAP ID |
Criteria |
Predicted Overall Noise Level, dB(A) |
Major
Noise Source causing Exceedance |
E1-IA |
Tseung Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
E1-IA_R01 |
70 |
69-70 |
- |
E1-IB |
Hong Mei Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IB_R01 |
70 |
54-55 |
- |
E1-IC |
Tung Tau Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IC_R01 to |
70 |
61-67 |
- |
E1-ID |
Lo Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-ID_R01 |
70 |
56 |
- |
E1-IE |
Sik Kong Wai |
Existing Village |
E1-IE_R01 |
70 |
66-68 |
- |
E1-IF |
Ha Tsuen Shi |
Existing Village |
E1-IF_R01 to |
70 |
62-67 |
- |
E1-IG |
San Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IG_R01 to |
70 |
61-66 |
- |
E1-IH |
Sha Chau Lei |
Existing Village |
E1-IH_R01 to |
70 |
66-70 |
- |
E1-IJ |
San Sang Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IJ_R01 to |
70 |
68-73 |
Tin
Ha Road |
E1-IK |
Shek Po Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E1-IK_R01 to |
70 |
64-72 |
Hung
Tin Road, Hung Chi Road |
E2-IA |
Fung Kong Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E2-IA_R01 to |
70 |
67-68 |
- |
E4-IA |
Tin Sum Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E4-IA_R01 to |
70 |
72-73 |
Tin
Ha Road |
E4-IB |
Tsing Chuen Wai |
Existing Village |
E4-IB_R01 |
70 |
67-70 |
- |
E5-IA |
Kiu Tau Wai |
Existing Village |
E5-IA_R01 |
70 |
61-66 |
- |
E5-IB_R |
Hung Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-IB_R01 to |
70 |
61-69 |
- |
E5-IB_C |
Chinese Mission Seminary |
Existing Church |
E5-IB_C01 |
65 |
73-74 |
Castle
Peak Road |
E5-IC |
San Lee Uk Tsuen |
Existing Village |
E5-IC_R01 |
70 |
73 |
Tin
Ha Road |
E1-26 |
Existing Homes for the Elderly (Yeung Chun Pui
and Ching Chung) |
Homes for the Elderly |
E1-26_H01 to |
70 |
58-60 |
- |
E4-30 |
Ling Liang Worldwide Evangelistic Mission Hung Shui Kiu Ling
Liang Church |
Place
of Worship |
E4-30_C01 |
65 |
72 |
Castle
Peak Road |
E5-23 |
Sheffield Villas |
Residential |
E5-23_R01 to |
70 |
64-66 |
- |
E5-25 |
Hung
Fuk Estate |
Residential |
E5-25_R01 to |
70 |
61-74 |
Hung
Tin Road, Hung Chi Road |
E5-31 |
Existing Residential Development |
Residential |
E5-31_R01 to |
70 |
64-73 |
Castle
Peak Road |
E5-35 |
Bellevue Court |
Residential |
E5-35_R01 |
70 |
67-71 |
Castle
Peak Road |
E5-39 |
Existing Residential Development |
Residential |
E5-39_R01 to |
70 |
59-75 |
Castle
Peak Road |
E5-44 |
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day
Saints (Hung Shui Kiu) |
Residential |
E5-44_C01 to |
65 |
72-73 |
Castle
Peak Road, Tin Ha Road |
O5-06 |
Committed Subsidised Sales Flat |
Residential |
O5-06_R01 to |
70 |
58-72 |
Ping Ha Road (East of Hung Tin Road) |
O5-33 |
Committed Residential Development |
Residential |
O5-33_R01 to |
70 |
68-77 |
Hung Shui Kiu Tin Sum Road |
Table 4.32
Summary of Mitigated Road Traffic Noise Assessment Results (Planned NSRs within the Project area)
NSR ID |
Use |
Description |
NAP ID |
Criteria |
Mitigated Overall Noise Level, dB(A) |
Require Additional Mitigation Measures |
P1-02 |
Residential |
Site 1-02 |
P1-02_R01 to P1-02_R31 |
70 |
54-72 |
Yes |
P1-03 |
Educational |
Site 1-03 |
P1-03_E01 to P1-03_E11 |
65 |
51-62 |
No |
P1-04 |
Residential |
Site 1-04 |
P1-04_R01 |
70 |
44-58 |
No |
P1-05 |
Residential |
Site 1-05 |
P1-05_R01 to P1-05_R11 |
70 |
56-66 |
No |
P1-06 |
Residential |
Site 1-06 |
P1-06_R01 to P1-06_R11 |
70 |
64-70 |
No |
P1-08 |
Residential |
Site 1-08 |
P1-08_R01 to P1-08_R22 |
70 |
63-70 |
No |
P1-09 |
Residential |
Site 1-09 |
P1-09_R01 to P1-09_R12 |
70 |
58-69 |
No |
P1-12 |
Residential |
Site 1-12 |
P1-12_R01 |
70 |
66-70 |
No |
P1-15 |
Educational |
Site 1-15 |
P1-15_E01 to P1-15_E05 |
65 |
60-66 |
Yes |
P1-17 |
Residential |
Site 1-17 |
P1-17_R01 |
70 |
54-60 |
No |
P1-18 |
Educational |
Site 1-18 |
P1-18_E01 to P1-18_E03 |
65 |
53-65 |
No |
P1-19 |
Residential |
Site 1-19 |
P1-19_R01 to P1-19_R21 |
70 |
60-70 |
No |
P1-21 |
Residential |
Site 1-21 |
P1-21_R01 to P1-21_R21 |
70 |
52-67 |
No |
P1-22 |
Educational |
Site 1-22 |
P1-22_E01 to P1-22_E11 |
65 |
49-69 |
Yes |
P2-02 |
Residential |
Site 2-02 |
P2-02_R01 to P2-02_R32 |
70 |
61-67 |
No |
P2-03 |
Residential |
Site 2-03 |
P2-03_R01 to P2-03_R21 |
70 |
52-65 |
No |
P2-07 |
Residential |
Site 2-07 |
P2-07_R01 to P2-07_R21 |
70 |
62-66 |
No |
P2-09 |
Educational |
Site 2-09 |
P2-09_E01 to P2-09_E02 |
65 |
58-65 |
No |
P2-10 |
Residential |
Site 2-10 |
P2-10_R01 to P2-10_R31 |
70 |
61-69 |
No |
P2-11 |
Residential |
Site 2-11 |
P2-11_R01 to P2-11_R31 |
70 |
65-70 |
No |
P2-14 |
Residential |
Site 2-14 |
P2-14_R01 to P2-14_R12 |
70 |
62-67 |
No |
P2-15 |
Educational |
Site 2-15 |
P2-15_R01 |
70 |
62-64 |
No |
P2-16 |
Educational |
Site 2-16 |
P2-16_E01 to P2-16_R15 |
65 |
60-63 |
No |
P2-18 |
Residential |
Site 2-18 |
P2-18_R01 to P2-18_R05 |
70 |
68-70 |
No |
P2-19 |
Residential |
Site 2-19 |
P2-19_R01 |
70 |
65-67 |
No |
P2-24 |
Educational |
Site 2-24 |
P2-24_E01 to P2-24_E11 |
65 |
54-65 |
No |
P2-25 |
Residential
Home for the Elderly |
Site 2-25 |
P2-25_H01 |
70 |
67-69 |
No |
P2-26 |
Educational |
Site 2-26 |
P2-26_E01 to P2-26_E11 |
65 |
59-66 |
Yes |
P2-28 |
Educational |
Site 2-28 |
P2-28_E01 to P2-28_E02 |
65 |
55-63 |
No |
P2-30 |
Residential |
Site 2-30 |
P2-30_R01 to P2-30_R21 |
70 |
47-70 |
No |
P2-31 |
Residential |
Site 2-31 |
P2-31_R01 to P2-31_R21 |
70 |
60-67 |
No |
P4-01 |
Staff
Quarters |
Site 4-01 |
P4-01_R01 to P4-01_R13 |
70 |
62-72 |
Yes |
P4-03 |
Residential |
Site 4-03 |
P4-03_R01 to P4-03_R11 |
70 |
58-70 |
No |
P4-04 |
Residential |
Site 4-04 |
P4-04_R01 to P4-04_R24 |
70 |
54-70 |
No |
P4-05 |
Residential |
Site 4-05 |
P4-05_R01 to P4-05_R14 |
70 |
56-72 |
Yes |
P4-06 |
Residential |
Site 4-06 |
P4-06_R01 to P4-06_R12 |
70 |
61-70 |
No |
P4-08 |
Educational |
Site 4-08 |
P4-08_E01 to P4-08_E11 |
65 |
61-64 |
No |
P4-10 |
Residential |
Site 4-10 |
P4-10_R01 |
70 |
61-68 |
No |
P4-20 |
Residential |
Site 4-20 |
P4-20_R01 to P4-20_R04 |
70 |
62-70 |
No |
P4-22 |
Residential |
Site 4-22 |
P4-22_R01 to P4-22_R42 |
70 |
52-70 |
No |
P4-24 |
Residential |
Site 4-24 |
P4-24_R01 to P4-24_R46 |
70 |
63-75 |
Yes |
P4-25a |
Other Use (Commercial and Residential) |
Site 4-25a |
P4-25a_R01 |
70 |
63-67 |
No |
P4-25b |
Other Use (Commercial and Residential) |
Site 4-25b |
P4-25b_R01 to P4-25b_R11 |
70 |
60-69 |
No |
P4-25c |
Other Use (Commercial and Residential) |
Site 4-25c |
P4-25c_R01 to P4-25c_R11 |
70 |
52-60 |
No |
P4-26 |
Residential |
Site 4-26 |
P4-26_R01 to P4-26_R21 |
70 |
61-71 |
Yes |
P4-28 |
Residential |
Site 4-28 |
P4-28_R01 to P4-28_R44 |
70 |
54-71 |
Yes |
P4-29 |
Other Use (Commercial and Residential) |
Site 4-29 |
P4-29_R01 to P4-29_R31 |
70 |
50-69 |
No |
P4-32 |
Staff Quarters |
Site 4-32 |
P4-32_R01 to P4-32_R14 |
70 |
61-70 |
No |
P4-33 |
Educational |
Site 4-33 |
P4-33_E01 to P4-33_E03 |
65 |
59-73 |
Yes |
P4-36 |
Educational |
Site 4-36 |
P4-36_E02 to P4-36_R01 |
65 |
58-65 |
No |
P5-07a |
Other Use (Commercial and Residential) |
Site 5-07a |
P5-07a_R01 - P5-07a_R21 |
70 |
53-68 |
No |
P5-07b |
Other Use (Commercial and Residential) |
Site 5-07b |
P5-07b_R01 to P5-07b_R21 |
70 |
57-73 |
Yes |
P5-08 |
Other Use (Commercial and Residential) |
Site 5-08 |
P5-08_R01 to P5-08_R11 |
70 |
66-70 |
No |
P5-09 |
Other Use (Commercial and Residential) |
Site 5-09 |
P5-09_R01 to P5-09_R31 |
70 |
57-69 |
No |
P5-14 |
Educational |
Site 5-14 |
P5-14_E01 to P5-14_E11 |
65 |
66-72 |
Yes |
P5-16 |
Residential |
Site 5-16 |
P5-16_R01 to P5-16_R11 |
70 |
55-74 |
Yes |
P5-17 |
Residential |
Site 5-17 |
P5-17_E04 to P5-17_R12 |
65 |
53-73 |
Yes |
P5-21 |
Educational |
Site 5-21 |
P5-21_E01 to P5-21_E02 |
65 |
61-66 |
Yes |
O5-22 |
Committed Residential Development (Site 5-22) |
Residential |
O5-22_R01 to O5-22_R03 |
70 |
65-77 |
Yes |
P5-24 |
Residential |
Site 5-24 |
P5-24_R01 to P5-24_R23 |
70 |
43-68 |
No |
P5-26 |
Residential |
Site 5-26 |
P5-26_R01 to P5-26_R04 |
70 |
56-70 |
No |
P5-28 |
Residential Home for the Elderly |
Site 5-28 |
P5-28_H01 |
70 |
64-72 |
Yes |
P5-32 |
Other Use (Commercial and Residential) |
Site 5-32 |
P5-32_R01 to P5-32_R82 |
70 |
63-77 |
Yes |
P5-34 |
Educational |
Site 5-34 |
P5-34_E01 to P5-34_E11 |
65 |
48-71 |
Yes |
P5-37 |
Educational |
Site 5-37 |
P5-37_E01 to P5-37_E02 |
65 |
70-74 |
Yes |
Hung Chi Road
Hung Shui Kiu Tin Sam
Road (East Section)
Hung Shui Kiu Tin Sam
Road (South of San Lee Uk Tsuen)
Castle Peak Road
Ping Ha Road
Lau Fau Shan Road
Tin Ha Road
Hung Tin Road
Table 4.33 Proposed Additional Mitigation Measures
at Planned Sites
Site Ref. No. |
Use |
Proposed Additional Mitigation Measures |
Applied
to |
Figure Reference |
1-2 |
Residential |
Acoustic Windows |
1
- 17/F |
Figure
4.7.19 |
1-15 |
Educational |
Blank Façade |
1
edge of 1 building |
Figure
4.7.21 |
1-22 |
Educational |
Noise Insulated Windows and Air Conditioning |
1
school |
Figure
4.7.21 |
2-26 |
Educational |
Blank Façade |
1
edge of 1 building |
Figure
4.7.20 |
4-1 |
Staff Quarters |
Acoustic Windows |
1
- 25/F |
Figure
4.7.25 |
Blank Façade |
1
edge of 2 buildings |
|||
4-5 |
Residential |
Acoustic Windows |
20
- 42/F |
Figure
4.7.25 |
4-24 |
Residential |
Acoustic Windows |
1
- 20/F |
Figure
4.7.26 |
4-26 |
Residential |
Acoustic Windows |
3
- 11/F |
Figure
4.7.26 |
4-28 |
Residential |
Acoustic Windows |
1
- 2/F |
Figure
4.7.26 |
4-33 |
Educational |
Noise Insulated Windows and Air Conditioning |
1
school |
Figure
4.7.27 |
5-7b |
Residential/
Commercial |
Acoustic Windows |
1
¡V 9/F |
Figure
4.7.22 |
5-14 |
Educational |
Noise Insulated Windows and Air Conditioning |
2
schools |
Figure
4.7.23 |
5-16 |
Residential |
Acoustic Windows |
3
¡V 22/F |
Figure
4.7.21 |
5-17 |
Residential |
Acoustic Windows |
4
¡V 29/F |
Figure
4.7.22 |
5-21 |
Educational |
Noise Insulated Windows and Air Conditioning |
1
school |
Figure
4.7.23 |
5-22 |
Residential |
Acoustic Balcony |
1
- 21/F |
Figure
4.7.24 |
5-28 |
Residential Home for the Elderly |
Noise Insulated Windows and Air Conditioning(a) |
1 Residential Home for the Elderly |
Figure
4.7.24 |
5-32 |
Residential/ Commercial |
Acoustic Windows |
1
- 28/F |
Figure
4.7.24 |
Acoustic Balcony |
1
¡V 9/F |
|||
5-34 |
Educational |
Blank Façade |
1
edge of 1 building |
Figure
4.7.24 |
Noise Insulated Windows and Air Conditioning |
1
school |
|||
5-37 |
Educational |
Noise Insulated Windows and Air Conditioning |
1
school |
Figure
4.7.24 |
Note:
(a) For Site 5-28, the need of
additional mitigation measures would subject to whether the LNRS can apply on
Hung Shui Kiu Tin Sam Road (East Section).
Indirect Mitigation Measures for Existing NSRs
Evaluation of Residual Environmental Impacts
Assessment Approach and Methodology
Train Noise Source Term for Rail Noise Assessment
¡P Rolling noise from train wheel and rail interaction;
¡P Noise from air conditioning unit on top of the each train cars; and
¡P Structure re-radiated noise from the viaduct structure during train passing.
WRL Source Terms Reference Review
LRT Source Terms Reference Review
Rail Noise Assessment Procedures
Table
4.34 Rail Noise Assessment Procedures
Description |
Assumptions / Remarks |
Ref. |
Locate the NAPs which would
most likely be affected by air-borne noise from the rail operation |
The first layer of existing/planned NSRs located in the vicinity of
WRL and LRT, have been selected as representative NAPs for rail noise
prediction and evaluation |
Section 4.4 |
Identify the train noise sources origination |
The rolling noise source is
located from the gap between the train and the walkway on the viaduct. Part
of the train wheel rail interaction noise had been absorbed by a multi-plenum
system and the effect of the system has been included in the source
measurement in previous study A/C noise located on the roof
of each car and source level was measured in previous study Structural re-radiated noise
generated from the vibration of the viaduct during event was measured in
previous study |
|
Identify the train frequency and make appropriate frequency correction |
+10 log10 (N) where N = Train frequency per
30 min per Direction |
A |
Identify the train speed for correction |
+20 log10 (V/Vref) where V = Train speed, Vref =
Reference train speed |
A |
Identify the distance from the NSR to the train and make distance
correction |
-10 log10 (d¡¦/dref) where d¡¦ = Slant distance from
track to NSR and dref = Reference distance |
A |
Identify the train type and the source term of the train |
Relevant noise level referred
to previous study |
B & C |
Identify the angle of view and make appropriate angle of view
correction |
+10 log10 (p£c/180 ¡V cos2 £\ sin£c) -5 where £c= Angle of View and £\=
Acute angle between a line drawn through the NSR, parallel to the track, and
the line bisecting the angle of view, £c |
A |
Incorporate Façade Correction |
+2.5 dB(A) |
A |
Incorporate Track Wear
Correction |
+3 dB(A) |
A |
Incorporate Joint/Turnout
Correction |
With conservative assumption,
+7.0dB(A) for a representative 20 m segment |
A |
Incorporate Barrier Correction |
Shadow Zone: -21dB(A) for £_ > 2.5 m where £_ is the Path Difference
in metre -7.75 log10 (5.2 + 203 £_) dB(A) for 0≤ £_ <2.5 m Illuminated Zone: 0dB(A) for £_ > 0.4 m 0.88 + 2.14 log10 (10-3 + £_)
dB(A) for 0≤ £_ <0.4 m |
Chart 6(a) of A |
Calculate the overall noise level from all rail segments including
rolling noise, A/C noise and structural re-radiated noise |
Standard acoustic principal |
- |
Calculate the Lmax |
SEL = Lmax + 10log(L/V) +10.5 ¡V
10log[(4D/(4D2+1)) + 2tan-1(1/(2D))] |
Equation 15.21 of D |
Calculate the Leq, 24hr |
Standard acoustic principal |
- |
Model validation |
On site measurement was carried
out to record the in-situ noise level and compared against the modelled
results. |
Reference:
A - Calculation of Railway Noise (1995).
B - ¡§West Rail Operation Noise Assessment Report¡¨
prepared by MTR Corporation Limited in July 2015.
C - ¡§Light Rail Transit (LRT) works for Tin Shui Wai
Reserve Zone and Grade Separation of the LRT with Pui To Road and Tsing Lun
Road in Tuen Mun¡¨ under a EIA Study Brief No: ESB-027/1999.
D - Transportation Noise Reference Book.
Table 4.35 Rail Noise Assessment Input Summary
Parameters |
WRL |
LRT |
|
Train Type
and No. of Car |
SP1900, 9
cars total 225 m in accordance with the VEP-45/2001 |
LRV, 2 cars of total 40 m as conservative scenario |
|
Rolling Noise |
SEL Northbound = 81.4 dB(A) [a] SEL Southbound = 80.7 dB(A) [a] (8 cars running 130kph at 25 m) |
Lmax = 65
dB(A) [b] (2 cars running 50kph at 25 m) |
|
Air Conditioning Noise |
Lmax at Viaduct = 48.8 dB(A) [a] Lmax at Station = 54.8 dB(A) [a] (8 cars at 25 m) |
Not
applicable as insignificant contribution |
|
Structure Re-radiated Noise |
Leq 30mins = 40.6 dB(A) Viaduct [a] |
Not
applicable as LRT in HSK is at grade |
|
Train
Frequency per 30 min per Direction |
14 number
during peak daytime; 10 number
during peak night-time |
Between Nai
Wai LRT Station to HSK LRT Station: Southbound: 20 number
during peak daytime; 13 number during peak night-time Northbound: 20 number
during peak daytime; 24 number during peak night-time From Tin
Shui Wai LRT Station to Hang Mei Tsuen LRT Station: Southbound: 14 number
during peak daytime; 13 number during peak night-time Northbound: 14 number
during peak daytime; 18 number during peak night-time |
|
Train
Frequency per 24hrs both directions |
680 trains |
Between Nai
Wai LRT Station to HSK LRT Station: 917 trains From Tin
Shui Wai LRT Station to Hang Mei Tsuen LRT Station: 717 trains |
|
Train Speed |
Refer to
speed profile in Appendix 2.1 in [a] ¡P
Station
speed, 50 kph ¡P
Approach
and leaving Station, 80 kph ¡P
Other
viaduct section, 100 kph |
LRT speed
was measured on site. ¡P
Section
near planned NSR, 60 kph ¡P
Section
approaching and leaving junctions and stations, 40 kph ¡P
Section
near NAP LR-E1, 50 kph ¡P
Section
near NAP LR-E2, 36 kph |
|
Notes:
[a] ¡§West
Rail Operation Noise Assessment Report¡¨ prepared by MTR Corporation Limited in
July 2015.
[b] ¡§Light
Rail Transit (LRT) works for Tin Shui Wai Reserve Zone and Grade Separation of
the LRT with Pui To Road and Tsing Lun Road in Tuen Mun , 1999¡¨.
Proposed HSK Station
Phasing of HSK Development
Prediction and Evaluation of Noise Impacts
WRL Noise
Table 4.36
WRL
Noise Calculation Summary ¡V Unmitigated
NAP |
Description |
Area Sensitivity Rating |
Noise Criteria, dB(A) |
mPD |
Leq, 30min, dB(A) |
Lmax, dB(A) |
Leq, 24 hrs, dB(A) |
||
0700-2300 hrs |
2300-0700 hrs |
0700-2300 hrs |
2300-0700 hrs |
||||||
Existing WRL NSRs |
|||||||||
WR-E1 |
Premises to the southwest of Yick Yuen Tsuen |
A |
60 |
50 |
8.7 |
50 |
48 |
57 |
49 |
WR-E2 |
Premises to the east of Oakland Court |
A |
60 |
50 |
8.5 |
48 |
47 |
54 |
48 |
WR-E3 |
Premises to the southwest of Tin Sum Tsuen |
A |
60 |
50 |
7.7 |
43 |
41 |
48 |
43 |
WR-E4 |
Premises to the West of San Lee Uk Tsuen |
A |
60 |
50 |
6.5 |
47 |
46 |
51 |
47 |
WR-E5 |
Premises to the West of San Lee Uk Tsuen Block 3,Galore Garden |
A |
60 |
50 |
6.9-9.9 |
47-48 |
46-47 |
52-54 |
47-48 |
WR-E6 |
Shek Po Tsuen Village House Premises to the southwest of Yick Yuen Tsuen Premises to the east of Oakland Court |
A |
60 |
50 |
6.4-15.4 |
47-49 |
45-47 |
51-54 |
47-49 |
WR-E7 |
Premises to the southwest of Tin Sum Tsuen |
A |
60 |
50 |
5.2-8.2 |
45 |
44 |
46-47 |
45 |
Project Planned WRL NSRs |
|||||||||
WR-P1 |
Residential Development in Site 4-6 |
B |
65 |
55 |
10.0-141.0 |
42-52 |
41-51 |
42-53 |
42-52 |
WR-P2 |
School in Site 4-8 |
B |
65 |
[a] |
11.0-47.0 |
42-47 |
[a] |
41-48 |
42-48 |
WR-P3 |
Residential Development in Site 4-10 |
B |
65 |
55 |
11.0-166.0 |
43-54 |
41-52 |
43-55 |
43-54 |
WR-P4 |
Residential Development in Site 4-20 |
B |
65 |
55 |
11.0-19.0 |
50-54 |
48-53 |
56-62 |
49-54 |
WR-P5a |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
B |
65 |
55 |
11.0-127.0 |
42-53 |
41-52 |
48-62 |
40-53 |
WR-P5b |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
B |
65 |
55 |
11.0-127.0 |
41-53 |
40-51 |
49-64 |
40-53 |
WR-P5c |
Residential Development in Site 4-2 |
B |
65 |
55 |
11.0-127.0 |
39-49 |
39-48 |
45-60 |
36-49 |
WR-P5d |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
B |
65 |
55 |
11.0-127.0 |
45-58 |
44-56 |
51-67 |
44-58 |
WR-P5e |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
B |
65 |
55 |
11.0-127.0 |
46-58 |
45-57 |
51-65 |
45-58 |
WR-P5f |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
B |
65 |
55 |
11.0-127.0 |
47-59 |
46-58 |
52-66 |
47-59 |
WR-P6a |
Residential Development in Site 4-25 |
B |
65 |
55 |
12.0-178.0 |
39-52 |
38-51 |
40-57 |
37-52 |
WR-P6b |
Residential Development in Site 4-25 |
B |
65 |
55 |
12.0-178.0 |
39-52 |
37-51 |
39-57 |
37-52 |
WR-P6c |
Residential Development in Site 4-25 |
B |
65 |
55 |
12.0-178.0 |
38-51 |
37-49 |
37-55 |
37-51 |
WR-P7a |
Residential Development in Site 4-29 |
B |
65 |
55 |
13.0-171.0 |
44-56 |
43-55 |
49-63 |
44-56 |
WR-P7b |
Residential Development in Site 4-29 |
B |
65 |
55 |
13.0-171.0 |
47-59 |
45-57 |
50-64 |
47-59 |
WR-P7c |
Residential Development in Site 4-29 |
B |
65 |
55 |
13.0-171.0 |
45-57 |
44-56 |
50-64 |
45-57 |
WR-P8 |
School in Site 4-36 |
B |
65 |
[a] |
12.0-48.0 |
43-52 |
[a] |
46-56 |
43-52 |
WR-P9a |
Residential Development in Site 5-17 |
B |
65 |
55 |
7.0-111.0 |
42-54 |
41-53 |
48-61 |
42-54 |
WR-P9b |
Residential Development in Site 5-17 |
B |
65 |
55 |
7.0-111.0 |
44-55 |
42-54 |
49-62 |
44-55 |
WR-P10 |
School in Site 5-21 |
B |
65 |
[a] |
6.0-43.0 |
49-67 |
[a] |
56-74 |
48-67 |
WR-P11 |
School in Site 5-34 |
B |
65 |
[a] |
7.0-43.0 |
42-46 |
[a] |
42-47 |
42-46 |
Notes:
[a] Educational
use is not considered as a night-time NSR.
Numbers
in bold denote exceedances of the noise criteria.
LRT Noise
Table 4.37 LRT Noise Calculation Summary ¡V
Unmitigated
NAP |
Site No. |
Area Sensitivity Rating |
Noise Criteria, dB(A) |
mPD |
Leq, 30min, dB(A) |
Lmax, dB(A) |
Leq, 24 hrs, dB(A) |
||
0700-2300 Hrs |
2300-0700 hrs |
0700-2300 hrs |
2300-0700 hrs |
||||||
Existing LRT NSRs |
|||||||||
LR-E1 |
Parkview Garden Block 24 - 27 |
C |
70 |
60 |
12.5-21.5 |
60-61 |
60 |
71-72 |
59 |
LR-E2 |
Tak Cheung Building |
C |
70 |
60 |
11.6-29.6 |
57-60 |
57-60 |
66-70 |
56-59 |
LR-E3 |
Beauty Court Block 1 |
C |
70 |
60 |
10.4-46.4 |
54-57 |
54-57 |
61-66 |
53-56 |
LR-E4 |
Coronet Court |
C |
70 |
60 |
10.1-46.1 |
55-58 |
55-58 |
62-67 |
54-57 |
LR-E5 |
Park Nara Tower 1 |
C |
70 |
60 |
10.6-46.6 |
55-58 |
54-58 |
62-68 |
53-57 |
LR-E6 |
Village House in Hung Uk Tsuen
facing Kiu Hung Road |
C |
70 |
60 |
5.5-14.5 |
58 |
58 |
64 |
57 |
LR-E7 |
Ling Liang Church |
C |
70 |
[a] |
13.5-16.5 |
58 |
[a] |
66 |
56-57 |
Project Planned LRT NSRs |
|||||||||
LR-P1 |
Residential Development in Site 4-22 |
C |
70 |
60 |
11.0-127.0 |
48-51 |
48-51 |
49-55 |
46-50 |
LR-P2 |
Residential Development in Site 4-26 |
C |
70 |
60 |
12.0-152.0 |
49-54 |
48-54 |
48-58 |
47-52 |
LR-P3a |
Residential Development in Site 4-28 |
C |
70 |
60 |
13.0-144.0 |
51-57 |
51-57 |
55-66 |
50-55 |
LR-P3b |
Residential Development in Site 4-28 |
C |
70 |
60 |
13.0-144.0 |
50-58 |
50-57 |
55-68 |
49-56 |
LR-P4 |
School in Site 4-33 |
C |
70 |
[a] |
12.0-48.0 |
59-64 |
[a] |
69-78 |
58-63 |
LR-P5a |
Residential Development in Site 5-7b |
B |
65 |
55 |
5.0-142.0 |
50-55 |
50-56 |
49-61 |
50-55 |
LR-P5b |
Residential Development in Site 5-7b |
B |
65 |
55 |
5.0-142.0 |
49-55 |
49-55 |
49-60 |
49-55 |
LR-P5c |
Residential Development in Site 5-7b |
B |
65 |
55 |
5.0-142.0 |
48-54 |
49-55 |
50-62 |
49-54 |
LR-P6 |
Residential Development in Site 5-9 |
B |
65 |
55 |
5.0-152.0 |
50-56 |
51-56 |
52-63 |
50-56 |
Notes:
[a] Educational
use and church is not considered as a night-time NSR.
Numbers
in bold denote exceedances of the noise criteria.
Rail Noise Mitigation Measures Options
Architectural Fins
Non-Sensitive Use or Fixed Glazing
Layout Setback
Table 4.38 Rail Noise Calculation Summary ¡V Mitigated
NAP |
Proposed
Mitigation Measures |
Noise Criteria, dB(A) |
mPD |
Leq, 30min, dB(A) |
Lmax, dB(A) |
Leq, 24 hrs, dB(A) |
||
Daytime /evening |
Night-time |
0700-2300 hrs |
2300-0700 hrs |
|||||
WR-P5d |
2 m Architectural fin |
65 |
55 |
11.0-127.0 |
42-51 |
41-50 |
45-60 |
37-51 |
WR-P5e.1 |
1.5 m Architectural fin + Relocation to non-sensitive use or fixed
glazing |
65 |
55 |
11.0-127.0 |
43-55 |
42-54 |
49-63 |
43-55 |
WR-P5f.1 |
Relocation to non-sensitive use or fixed glazing |
65 |
55 |
11.0-127.0 |
45-57 |
43-55 |
51-65 |
44-57 |
WR-P7b |
Layout Set Back to 70 m from WRL |
65 |
55 |
13.0-171.0 |
45-57 |
44-55 |
48-61 |
45-57 |
WR-P7c |
Layout Set Back to 70 m from WRL |
65 |
55 |
13.0-171.0 |
44-56 |
43-54 |
48-61 |
44-56 |
WR-P10 |
Layout Set Back to 25 m from WRL |
65 |
[a] |
6.0-43.0 |
48-63 |
[a] |
54-70 |
47-63 |
LR-P5a |
2 m Architectural fin |
65 |
55 |
5.0-142.0 |
49-54 |
49-55 |
49-61 |
49-54 |
LR-P6.1 |
Relocation to non-sensitive use or fixed glazing |
65 |
55 |
5.0-152.0 |
48-53 |
49-54 |
53-63 |
48-53 |
LR-P6.2 |
1.3 m Architectural fin + Relocation to non-sensitive use or fixed
glazing |
65 |
55 |
5.0-152.0 |
47-53 |
48-54 |
51-62 |
47-53 |
LR-P6.3 |
Relocation to non-sensitive use or fixed glazing |
65 |
55 |
5.0-152.0 |
49-55 |
49-55 |
52-63 |
49-55 |
Notes:
[a] Educational
use is not considered as a night-time NSR.
Rail Noise Impact Assessment for Development Sites
Environmentally Friendly Transport Services
Table 4.39
Rail based EFTS Reference
Scheme
Items
|
Description
|
Type
of source
|
Automated
guideway transit, steel wheel, welded rail
|
Noise
source level
|
SEL
80 dB(A) at 50 feet and 50 mph
Ref:
Table 5-1 Transit Noise and Vibration Impact Assessment FTA-VA-90-1003-06 May
2006 by Office of Planning and Environment Federal Transit Administration
|
NSR
Distance from track
|
10 m
|
Operating
speed
|
Assumed
40 kph
|
Frequency
|
Assumed
5 trains per headway
|
Calculated
Noise level at NSR boundary
|
57.2
dB(A) > night-time noise criteria of 55 dB(A)
|
Track
enhancement
|
¡P
Embedded rail of 3 dB(A) reduction
¡P
Green track with vegetation 2 dB(A) reduction
Reference
material as shown in Appendix 4.8.6
|
Noise
level at NSR after track enhancement
|
<
55 dB(A) complied with night-time noise criteria of HSKNDA
|
Evaluation of Residual Environmental Impacts
Assessment Approach and Methodology
¡P Determine the assessment area;
¡P Identify and locate representative NSRs that may be affected by the noise sources;
¡P Determine the noise criteria for both daytime and night-time;
¡P Use standard acoustic principle for attenuation and directivity;
¡P Adopt correction of tonality, impulsiveness and intermittency as stipulated in TM-places;
¡P Calculate the noise impacts using assumed plant inventories and utilisation schedule, if available; and
¡P Calculation repeats for various levels from the fixed plant noise sources
Prediction and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts
Upgraded San Wai STW
Existing Pumping Stations
Table 4.40 Corrected
Noise Levels of the Existing Pumping Stations
Source ID |
Pumping
Stations |
Maximum Corrected SPL, |
||
Daytime |
Evening-time |
Night-time |
||
EPS1 |
Sik Kong Tsuen Stormwater Pumping Station |
65 |
64 |
64 |
EPS2 |
Sik Kong Wai Stormwater Pumping Station |
66 |
63 |
63 |
EPS3 |
Lo Uk Tsuen Stormwater Pumping Station |
57 |
56 |
59 |
EPS4 |
Kiu Tau Wai Stormwater Pumping Station |
62 |
63 |
65 |
EPS5 |
Sheung Cheung Wai Floodwater Pumping Station |
69 |
61 |
67 |
ESP6 |
Ha Tsuen SPS |
82 |
85 |
84 |
Remarks:
- Corrections for
tonality, impulsiveness and intermittency have been considered.
- Free-field
measurements were made at 1 m from louvre of the SPSs.
Table 4.41 Predicted
Sound Pressure Level at Planned NSRs for Existing Pumping Stations
Source ID |
Nearest Planned NSR |
AP |
ASR |
Shortest Distance
from the Source (m) |
Max Predicted SPL, Leq30mins dB(A)
[Criteria, dB(A)] |
|||
Day
time |
Evening
time |
Night-time |
|
|||||
EPS1 |
1-19 |
P1-19_R11 |
B |
210 |
24(1) [60] |
22(1) [60] |
22(1) [50] |
|
EPS2 |
1-19 |
P1-19_R11 |
B |
310 |
24(1) [60] |
22(1) [60] |
22(1) [50] |
|
EPS3 |
1-12 |
P1-12_R01 |
B |
75 |
18 [60] |
17 [60] |
20 [50] |
|
EPS4 |
5-9 |
P5-9_R32 |
B |
115 |
32(1) [60] |
32(1) [60] |
28(1) [50] |
|
EPS5 |
5-6 |
O5-06_R25 |
B |
150 |
54(1) [60] |
54(1) [60] |
44(1) [50] |
|
EPS6 |
5-16 |
P5-16_R01 |
B |
40 |
55(1) [60] |
55(1) [60] |
48(1) [50] |
|
Remarks:
(1) Cumulative impact from other fixed noise sources has
been considered.
Planned Sewage Pumping
Stations (DP9)
¡P SPS (Site 2-34): Nearest NSR at about 135 m;
¡P SPS (Site 3-41): Nearest NSR at about 90 m;
¡P SPS (Site 3-48): Nearest NSR at about 100 m; and
¡P SPS (Site 4-35): Nearest NSR at about 10 m.
Table 4.42 Summary of Maximum Allowable SWL
for Planned Sewage Pumping
Stations
Plant Item |
Maximum Allowable SWL, dB(A) |
||
Day time |
Evening time |
Night-time |
|
SPS (Site 2-34)(1) |
95 |
95 |
90 |
SPS (Site 3-41)(1) |
95 |
95 |
85 |
SPS (Site 3-48)(1) |
103 |
103 |
93 |
SPS (Site 4-35)(1) |
100 |
100 |
90 |
Planned Sewage Treatment Works
Planned Port Back-up, Storage
and Workshop Uses
Table 4.43 Summary
of Maximum Allowable SWL for Planned Port Back-up, Storage and Workshop Uses
Plant Item |
Maximum Allowable SWL, dB(A) |
||
Day time |
Evening time |
Night-time |
|
PBU+SWU (Site 3-1) (1) |
85 |
80 |
73 |
PBU+SWU (Site 3-4) (1) |
106 |
101 |
94 |
Note:
Planned District Cooling System
¡P DCS (Site 1-24): Nearest NSR at about 80 m; and
¡P DCS (Site 4-18): Nearest NSR at about 150 m.
Table 4.44 Summary
of Maximum Allowable SWL for Planned Cooling System
Plant Item |
Maximum Allowable SWL, dB(A) |
||
Day time |
Evening time |
Night-time |
|
DCS (Site 1-24)(1) |
102 |
102 |
92 |
DCS (Site 4-18)(1) |
106 |
106 |
96 |
Note:
(1)
Cumulative impact arising from other fixed noise sources are included.
Planned Electricity Substation
Table 4.45 Summary
of Maximum Allowable SWL for Planned Electricity Substation
Plant Item |
Maximum Allowable SWL, dB(A) |
||
Day time |
Evening time |
Night-time |
|
ESS (Site 4-23) (1) |
89 |
89 |
79 |
ESS (Site 4-37) |
94 |
94 |
84 |
ESS (Site 5-19)(1) |
94 |
94 |
84 |
Note:
(1)
Cumulative impact arising from other fixed noise sources are included.
Planned Public Transport
Interchange and Vehicle Depot
¡P PTI (Site 2-23): Nearest NSR at about 10 m;
¡P PTI (Site 4-13a): Nearest NSR at about 170 m;
¡P PTI (Site 4-29): Nearest NSR at about 35 m;
¡P PTI (Site 5-5): Nearest NSR at about 35 m; and
¡P Vehicle depot (Site 4-21): Nearest NSR at about 5 m.
Table 4.46 Summary
of Maximum Allowable SWL for Planned Public Transport Interchange
Plant Item |
Maximum Allowable SWL, dB(A) |
||
Day time |
Evening time |
Night-time |
|
PTI (Site 2-23)(1) |
85 |
85 |
75 |
PTI (Site 4-13a)(1) |
99 |
99 |
89 |
PTI (Site 4-29)(1) |
96 |
96 |
86 |
PTI (Site 5-5)(1) |
96 |
96 |
86 |
Vehicle Depot (Site 4-21)(1) |
87 |
87 |
77 |
Note:
(1)
Cumulative impact arising from other fixed noise sources are included.
Planned Sports Ground
¡P To use a cluster of small power loudspeakers instead of a few large power loudspeakers;
¡P To use directional loudspeakers and orientate them to point towards the audience and away from the nearby NSRs; and
¡P To include a ¡§Limiter¡¨ device in the system to set the upper bound of the output sound level.
Planned Fire Station
Table 4.47 Summary
of Maximum Allowable SWL for Planned Fire Station
Plant Item |
Maximum Allowable SWL, dB(A) |
||
Day time |
Evening time |
Night-time |
|
Fire Station (Site 4-1)(1) |
98 |
98 |
88 |
Note:
(1)
Cumulative impact arising from other fixed noise sources are included.
Planned Hospital
Planned EFTS Depot
Planned Parking and
Operational Facilities for EFTS
Planned West Rail HSK Station
Planned Industrial Area
Table 4.48 Summary
of Maximum Allowable SWL for Industrial Area
Plant Item |
Maximum Allowable SWL, dB(A) |
||
Day time |
Evening time |
Night-time |
|
Site 3-43 |
106 |
106 |
96 |
Site 3-44 |
106 |
106 |
96 |
Site 3-45 |
104 |
104 |
94 |
Site 3-46 |
104 |
104 |
94 |
Site 3-47 |
105 |
105 |
95 |
Site 3-50 |
104 |
104 |
94 |
Site 3-51 |
No NSR within 300 m assessment area |
||
Site 3-52 |
104 |
104 |
94 |
Mitigation Measures
¡P All the pumps and noisy plants should be enclosed inside the building structure;
¡P Proper selection of quiet plant aiming to reduce the tonality at NSRs;
¡P Installation of silencer/acoustic enclosure/acoustic louvre for the exhaust of ventilation system; and
¡P Openings of ventilation systems should be located away from NSRs as far as practicable.
Evaluation of Residual Environmental Impacts
Identification of Helicopter Noise Source
Helicopter Fleet
Noise Performance of H175
Helicopter
Emergency Night-time Operation
¡P Air ambulance - GFS provides a 24 hours air ambulance service. After receiving emergency callouts from clinics throughout the territory, GFS helicopters can arrive on scene within 20 minutes for locations within Island Zone such as Hong Kong Island, Cheung Chau, Hei Ling Chau, Lantau, Peng Chau and Soko Islands, and 30 minutes for elsewhere within the Hong Kong territory.
¡P Search and rescue ¡V The GFS has the duty to perform offshore search and rescue operations up to 700 nm south of Hong Kong, including dawn searches for lost or injured hikers and climbers. Such operations sometimes require the winching of people from inaccessible places in the rocky hills of the New Territories or from the many outlying islands, often under bad weather conditions.
¡P Law enforcement operation support - GFS provides 24/7 emergency response to law enforcement operations, and such operations are often short notice, time critical and situation dictated. This involves providing flying support to various police operations for law enforcement purposes and for maintaining law and order.
Assessment Approach and Methodology
Noise Level Difference
(dB) = 20 log10 (d1/d2)
Prediction and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts
Mitigation Measures
Evaluation of Residual Environmental Impacts
¡P DP3 - Construction of new West Rail HSK Station (Site 4-34)
¡P DP4 - Construction of EFTS ¡V Potential DP subject to further review
¡P DP7 - Construction of a new container back-up and storage area (Site 3-1, 3-4, 3-5, 3-13 and 3-14) ¡V Potential DP subject to further review
¡P DP8 - Construction of new HSK STW (Site 3-26 and part of the existing San Wai STW)
¡P DP10 - Construction of flushing water service reservoirs for reuse of reclaimed water in Fung Kong Tsuen and Tan Kwai Tsuen (Sites 3-3 and 5-40)
¡P DP11 - Construction of one RTS (Site 3-12)
Operation Phase
[1] Upgrading
and expansion of San Wai STW and expansion of Ha Tsuen Pumping Station (Register
No.: AEIAR-072/2003) was approved on 12 May 2013