7                      sewerage and sewage treatment implications

7.1                       Introduction

7.1.1                  The proposed development scheme at SHR Site, SHR Site Extension and HPR Site will generate large amount of sewage flows due to the population and employment intake. The expected impact/ implication on the existing and planned sewage systems and the proposals of sewerage infrastructure and mitigation measures to support the proposed development are discussed in this chapter.

7.2                       Design Guidelines and Standards

7.2.1                  The following established guidelines and standards are adopted for sewage flow estimation, assessment and evaluation of sewerage and sewage treatment implications of the Project:

·         DSD Sewerage Manual Part 1 (2013 Version);

·         DSD Sewerage Manual Part 2 (2013 Version);

·         DSD Technical Circulars and Practice Notes;

·         EPD Guideline for Estimating Sewage Flows (GESF) for Sewage Infrastructure Planning Version 1.0 (Report No. EPD/TP 1/05); and

·         Environmental Impact Assessment Ordinance (EIAO), Technical Memorandum on Environmental Impact Assessment Process (EIAO-TM), Annex 14 Section 6.5.

7.3                       Existing and Planned Sewage System

Record Plans and Drainage As-built Drawings

7.3.1                  Record plans and as-built drawings of the existing sewerage in the vicinity of the Sites were obtained from Mainland North Division of Drainage Services Department (DSD).  The information is adopted to assess the potential sewerage impact arising from the Development under this assignment.

Review On Relevant Completed, Current and Planned Sewerage Projects

7.3.2                  Several completed, ongoing and planned sewerage projects are being implemented in the Tuen Mun sewage catchment, as listed below:

·         PWP No. 4346DS – Upgrading of Tuen Mun Sewerage, Phase 1

·         PWP No. 4160DS – Tuen Mun Sewerage, Stage 1

·         PWP No. 4329DS – Upgrading of Pillar Point Sewage Treatment Works

·         PWP No. 4371DS – Sewerage in Western Tuen Mun

·         Contract No. DC/2009/11 – Tuen Mun Western Trunk Sewerage (Western Interceptor Sewer)

·         Contract No. DC/2010/01 – Tuen Mun Village Sewerage and Trunk Sewers at Pillar Point

·         PWP No. 4374DS – Tuen Mun Sewerage, Stage 1 – Village Sewerage in Tsing Chuen Wai and Tuen Tsz Wai (part)

7.3.3                  Relevant projects are discussed as follows:

PWP No. 4346DS – Upgrading of Tuen Mun Sewerage, Phase 1

PWP No. 4160DS - Tuen Mun Sewerage, Stage 1

7.3.4                  The project aims at providing village sewerage in Tuen Mun and constructing new trunk sewerage in Tuen Mun Siu Lam area and Tuen Mun North in order to improve the sanitary condition to cater for the planned and forecast development.

7.3.5                  Tsz Tin Tsuen, Po Tong Ha, Siu Hang Tsuen and Kei Lung Wai are planned with sewerage provision for discharge to TM54 SPS.  The proposed sewerage works are tentatively scheduled to commence in Q1 2021 for completion in Q4 2024.

PWP No. 4329DS – Upgrading of Pillar Point Sewage Treatment Works

7.3.6                  The project aims to upgrade the sewage treatment level of the Pillar Point Sewage Treatment Works (STW) from preliminary treatment to chemically enhanced primary treatment with disinfection along with an expansion of the treatment capacity from 215,000 m3/day to 241,000 m3/day [Average dry weather flow (ADWF)].  This Project was completed in 2014.

PWP No. 4371DS – Sewerage in Western Tuen Mun

7.3.7                  The project aims to provide new trunk sewerage in Tuen Mun West and improve the sanitary condition to cater for the planned and forecast development.  The project comprises the design and construction of the 1,800mm diameter Western Interceptor Sewer (WIS) along Ming Kum Road for conveying the sewage flow to the WIS SPS and subsequently to the Pillar Point STW.  This Project was completed in 2016.

PWP No. 4374DS – Tuen Mun Sewerage, Stage 1 – Village Sewerage in Tsing Chuen Wai and Tuen Tsz Wai

7.3.8                  The project aims at providing public sewerage to Tsing Chuen Wai and Tuen Tsz Wai in Tuen Mun so as to improve the water quality in nearby watercourses and Tuen Mun River Channel as well as the sanitary conditions of these unsewered village/areas.  The project comprises the construction of about 1.5km of sewers to serve part of the areas of Tsing Chuen Wai and Tuen Tsz Wai in Tuen Mun.

7.4                       Latest Sewerage Network

7.4.1                  After commissioning of the WIS, sewage in the Tuen Mun catchment would ultimately discharge to the Pillar Point STW via two routes, as discussed below and presented in Figure 7.1:

·         Sewage generated from the northern Tuen Mun catchment would convey to the proposed TM54 SPS for discharge to the WIS at Ming Kum Road and subsequently to the Pillar Point STW. 

·         Sewage generated from the northeastern and eastern Tuen Mun catchment would convey to Siu Hong Road SPS, subsequently to Pak Kok SPS for discharge to the Pillar Point STW. 

7.4.2                  Tuen Mun North SPS, with a design pumping capacity of 0.342m3/s, was originally planned to collect sewage from the local villages in the northern Tuen Mun for conveyance to the downstream TM54 SPS under PWP No. 4374DS - Upgrading of Tuen Mun Sewerage, Phase 1.  The implementation had been deleted from further development due to public objection on the location of the Tuen Mun North SPS.

Details of Sewage Pumping Stations

7.4.3                  Details of the SPSs in the Tuen Mun sewage catchment were obtained from DSD, as tabulated in Table 7.1 below:

      Table 7.1 Information of Sewage Pumping Stations in Tuen Mun Catchment

SPS

Tuen Mun Area 54 SPS

WIS SPS

Siu Hong SPS

Pak Kok SPS (Phase I)

Pak Kok SPS (Phase II)

No. of Duty Pump

3

2

3

2

1

No. of Standby Pump

1

1

1

1

1

Pump Capacity (L/s)

196

760

280

1,530

1,530

Design Capacity (m³/s)

0.589

1.52

0.84

3.06

1.53

Inlet Pipe Invert (mPD)

2.76

-5.1

0.65

-3.1

-3.1

Wet Well Invert (mPD)

-1.32

-10.4

-0.02

-3.1

-3.1

Approximate Wet Well Size

Area (m2)

2 x 55.2 = 110.4

144

49.5

19

8.6

Height (m)

8.7

16.4

1.6

3.6

3.6

Cut-In Level (mPD)

Pump 1

0.74

-8.03

0.5

-1.9

-1.5

Pump 2

0.89

-8.03

0.7

-1.1

N/A

Pump 3

1.04

N/A

0.9

N/A

N/A

Cut-Out Level (mPD)

Pump 1

0.48

-9.0

0.2

-2.3

-2.1

Pump 2

0.63

-9.0

0.4

-1.5

N/A

Pump 3

0.78

N/A

0.6

N/A

N/A

Note: The information was extracted from the Final Technical Report No. 8 – Preliminary Sewerage Impact Assessment Report prepared under Agreement No. CE 60/2013(CE) – Engineering Study for Site Formation and Infrastructural Works at Hong Po Road.

 

7.5                       Methodology and Design Criteria

Objectives and Procedures

7.5.1                  The objectives and procedures of the sewerage and sewage treatment implications impact assessment are summarised as follows:

·         Identify the scope of the development;

·         Determine the sewage generation of the development;

·         Identify the existing and planned sewerage systems within and in the vicinity of the proposed development boundary;

·         Examine the impact arising from new sewage generation from the proposed development;

·         Propose sewerage works; and

·         To identify, evaluate and recommend the necessary mitigation measures and an appropriate sewage collection, treatment and disposal proposal.

7.5.2                  The assessment has been carried out in accordance with the guidelines set out in EPD’s Technical Paper Guidelines for Estimating Sewage Flows (GESF) for Sewerage Infrastructure Planning Version 1.0 and DSD’s Sewerage Manual.

Latest Development Proposal

7.5.3                  The existing ground level of the SHR Site, SHR Site Extension and HPR Site ranges from approximately +5.3 mPD to +14.8 mPD, and +9 mPD to +16 mPD and +14 mPD to +40 mPD respectively.  The areas of the Sites currently comprises of slopes, cottage, open storage, workshop, low-rise village houses, factories, car parks, warehouses and temporary structures.

7.5.4                  The proposed site formation level of SHR Site, SHR Site Extension and HPR Site ranges from +6.0 mPD to +12.0 mPD, from +9.8 mPD to +12.2mPD and from +8.0 mPD to +21.0 mPD respectively.

7.5.5                  The location plan showing the proposed formation level of SHR Site, SHR Site Extension and HPR Site is shown in Figure 7.2.

7.6                       Development Parameters

7.6.1                  The preliminary development parameters for SHR Site, SHR Site Extension and HPR Site are shown in Table 7.2 as below:

Table 7.2 Proposed Development Parameters at SHR Site, SHR Site Extension and HPR Site

Site

Zoning on the Current OZP

Proposed Land Use

No. of Flats/ Domestic Population

Non-Domestic GFA (m2)

Target Population

 

 

 

 

 

 

SHR Site

R(E) and GB on the approved Lam Tei and Yick Yuen OZP No. S/TM-LTYY/10

 

 

&

 

 

R(E)1, GB, V and Road on the approved Tuen Mun OZP No. S/TM/35

Public Housing (PH)

9,400/ 26,300

Retail

10,620

2031

Neighbourhood Elderly Centre

1,333.2

60-p Special Child Care Centre (SCCC)

902

100-p Child Care Centre (CCC)

1,166

OPRS Office Base

363

Two kindergartens

1,000

Two 36-classroom primary schools

14,000

Others*

21,942.8

SHR Site Extension

Public Housing (PH)

1,700/ 4,700

Retail

1,000

2030

One 30-classroom secondary school

21,000

Two 36 -classroom primary schools

Others*

6,298

HPR Site

Public Housing (PH)

10,500/ 30,000

Retail

8,000

2033

150-p Residential Care Home for the Elderly (RCHE) + 30-p Day Care Unit

4,406.6

Integrated Children and Youth Services Centre (ICYSC)

1,388.2

Neighbourhood Elderly Centre (NEC)

1,333.2

Two kindergartens

1,520

Others*

21,160.5

*Allowed for provision of additional retail facilities or welfare facilities (To be reviewed in the detailed design stage)

 

Retail and Others

7.6.2                  According to the results of the Commercial and Industrial Floor Space Utilization Survey (CIFSUS) conducted by Planning Department, the number of workers per 100m2 for “Retail Trade Group” is 3.5.  In this connection, the total number of employees at SHR Site is 1,140, SHR Site Extension is 255 and HPR Site is 1,021.

Welfare Facilities

7.6.3                  According to the results of the CIFSUS, the number of workers per 100m2 for “Community, Social, and Personal Services” is 3.3.  The total number of employees at SHR Site is 124, SHR Site Extension is 0 and HPR Site is 235.

School

7.6.4                  Kindergarten - There are 2 nos. of 6-classrooms kindergartens and 2 nos. of 9-classrooms kindergartens at SHR Site and HPR Site respectively.  With a maximum of 30 students in each class, the total number of students at the kindergartens is assumed to be 900.  Based on Education Bureau’s (EDB) 2017/2018 statistics, the ratio of students to teaching staff is 8.6 to 1.  In this connection, the total number of teaching staff is assumed to be 105.

7.6.5                  Primary School - There are 2 nos. of 36-classroom primary schools located at each SHR Site and SHR Site Extension.  Taking reference to EDB’s 2017/18 statistics, 27 students are assumed in each class and the ratio of students to teaching staff is assumed to 13.8 to 1.  A total of 3,888 students and 282 teaching staff is anticipated from the 144 classes.

7.6.6                  Secondary School - There is a 30-classroom secondary school located at SHR Site Extension.  Taking reference to EDB’s 2017/18 statistics, 28 students are assumed in each class and the ratio of students to teaching staff is assumed to 11.6 to 1.  A total of 840 students and 73 teaching staff is anticipated.

7.6.7                  The population, employees and students generated from SHR Site, SHR Site Extension and HPR Site are summarized in Table 7.3 below:

Table 7.3 Population, Employees and Students Generated from SHR Site, SHR Site Extension and HPR Site

Site

Target Population Intake

Design population

No. of Employee

No. of Student

Retail & others

Welfare facilities

Teaching Staff

SHR Site

2031

26,300

1,140

124

183

(42+141)

2,304

(360+1944)

SHR Site Extension

2030

4,700

255

0

214

(141+73)

2,784

(1944+840)

HPR Site

2033

30,000

1,021

235

63

540

7.6.8                  The referenced CIFSUS for “Retail Trade Group” and “Community, Social, and Personal Services” is enclosed in Appendix 7.1.

7.7                       Interfacing Projects

Tuen Mun Area 54 (TM54)

7.7.1                  With reference to the Sewage Impact Assessment prepared for Section 16 Application in April 2017, the latest development parameters in TM54 sites are shown in Table 7.4.

Table 7.4 Development Parameters at TM54

Site Name

Design Population

No. of Employee

No. of Student

Tentative Year for Completion

Site 1 & 1A

12,000

141

180

2021/22

Site 2

13,000

234

180

2018 (completed)

Site 3/4 (East)

15,000

217

210

2021/22

Site 4A (South)

4,200

19

180

2027

Site 4A (East)

-

176

2,400

2026/27

Site 4A (West)

-

310

-

2022/23

Site 3/4 (West)

14,300

370

240

2024/25

Site 5

3,100

43

-

2027

Village Sewerage of Tsz Tin Tsuen, Po Tong Ha, Kei Lun Wai and Siu Hang Tsuen

7.7.2                  Tsz Tin Tsuen, Po Tong Ha, Siu Hang Tsuen and Kei Lun Wai are planned with sewerage provision for discharge to TM54 SPS.  The proposed sewerage works are tentatively scheduled to commence in Q1 2021 for completion in Q4 2024.

7.8                       Unit Flow Factors

7.8.1                  The unit flow factors are adopted in accordance with Environmental Protection Department’s “Guidelines for Estimating Sewage Flows for Sewage Infrastructure Planning” (GESF).  The adopted unit flow factors are summarized in Table 7.5 as follows:

Table 7.5 Recommended Unit Flow Factor

Development Type

Unit

Recommended Unit Flow Factor (l/d)

Existing

Planning for Future

Residential

Public Rental

Person

190

190

Employment

Job Types J4 (Wholesale and Retail)

Employee

280

280

Job Types J11 (Community, Social & Personal Services)

Employee

280

280

School Place

Primary, Secondary & Tertiary

Student

40

40

7.9                       Peaking Factors

7.9.1                  Peaking factors cater for seasonal/diurnal fluctuation and normal amount of infiltration and inflow.  The peaking factors shall be adopted in accordance with EPD’s GESF as shown in Table 7.6.

Table 7.6 Peaking Factors for Various Population Ranges

Population Range

Peaking Factor (including stormwater allowance) for facility with existing upstream sewerage

Peaking Factor (excluding stormwater allowance) for facility with new upstream sewerage

(a)    For sewers

<1,000

8

6

1,000 – 5,000

6

5

5,000 – 10,000

5

4

10,000 – 50,000

4

3

>50,000

Max(

Max(

(b)    Sewage Treatment Works, Preliminary Treatment Works and Pumping Stations

<10,000

4

3

10,000 – 25,000

3.5

2.5

25,000 – 50,000

3

2

>50,000

Max(

Max(

Note:

Referenced from EPD GESF Table T-5;

N = Contributing population in thousands.


 

7.10                   Sewage Flow Estimation

7.10.1              The proposed development area (PDA) is approximately 27 hectares, with a total population intake about 61,000.  Welfare and educational uses are also planned for the proposed development. This sewerage impact assessment is based on the development parameters shown in Table 7.2.

7.10.2              The estimated sewage flows generated by SHR Site, SHR Site Extension and HPR Site and the target population intake are summarised in Table 7.7.

                    Table 7.7 Average Dry Weather Flow (ADWF)

Site Name

Population

Unit Flow Factor
(l/d)

Average DWF (m3/s)

Target Population Intake

SHR Site

26,300 residents

190

0.05784

2031

1,447 employees

280

0.00469

2,304 students

40

0.00107

SHR Site Extension

4,700 residents

190

0.01034

2030

469 employees

280

0.00152

2,784 students

40

0.00129

HPR Site

30,000 residents

190

0.06597

2033

1,319 employees

280

0.00427

540 students

40

0.00025

Total ADWF:

0.14724

 

7.10.3              As shown in the Table 7.7, the target population intake will be implemented in 3 phases which is tentatively scheduled for 2030, 2031 and 2033 respectively, subject to review at the detailed design stage.  The year-by-year sewage flow build-up on the estimated sewage flows generated by each phase of the development is shown in Table 7.8.  Detailed calculations are enclosed in Appendix 7.2.

                    Table 7.8 Year-by-year Sewage Flow Build-up for the Proposed Development

Year

ADWF (m3/s)

2030

0.01315

2031

0.07677

2032

0.07677

2033

0.14724

7.11                   Proposed Sewerage Network

7.11.1              The sewage generated from the proposed developments will convey to the proposed TM 54 SPS for discharge to the WIS at Ming Kum Road and subsequently to the Pillar Point STW. New sewers are proposed to connect the proposed SHR SPS. A twin 500 diameter rising mains are proposed to connect the SHR SPS to TM 54 SPS. The proposed local sewerage network is shown in Figure 7.3.  Upon checking of the hydraulic performance as shown in Appendix 7.2, the proposed local sewerage network has adequate handling capacity to convey the sewage flow from the SHR Site, SHR Site Extension and HPR Site to the proposed SHR SPS.  The sewage flow would then be conveyed via the TM54 SPS to WIS.

7.11.2              The simulation results are presented in Table 7.9 and Appendix 7.3.

Table 7.9 Flow Build-up of SHR SPS and TM54 SPS

Site Name

ADWF
(m3/s)

Contributing Population

Peaking Factor for SPS

Peak Flow for SPS
(m3/s)

SHR SPS

SHR Site

0.0636

20,349

 

 

SHR Site Extension

0.01314

4,206

 

 

HPR Site

0.07050

22,559

 

 

Subtotal

0.147

47,115

3.04

0.45

Subtotal (with 15% contingency)

0.169

54,182

3.01

0.51

Gravity to WIS

Site 1 & 1A

0.027

8,617

 

 

Site 3/4 (West)

0.046

14,719

 

 

Site 5

0.0069

2,226

 

 

TM54 SPS

Site 2

0.029

9,417

 

 

Site 3/4 (East)

0.034

10,812

 

 

Site 4A (South)

0.009

3,002

 

 

Site 4A (East)

0.002

538

 

 

Site 4A (West)

0.001

321

 

 

Village Sewerage

0.029

9,174

 

 

Subtotal

0.104

33,265

3.00

0.31

Total

0.273

87,446

2.92

0.80

7.11.3              The design capacity of the proposed SHR SPS is proposed to be 0.52 m3/s with 2 duty and 1 standby pump system.  The SHR SPS is proposed to be constructed with the site formation works of SHR Site Extension and would come into operation in 2030.

7.11.4              The design capacity of the pumping station of the WIS, TM54 and SHR Site are shown in Table 7.10.

Table 7.10 Hydraulic Performance of SPSs

Sewage Pumping Station

Maximum Sewage Flow SPS (m3/s)

Design Capacity (m3/s)

Upgraded Design Capacity (m3/s)/(m3/day)

SHR SPS

0.51

0.52

0.52/44,928

TM Area 54 SPS

0.80

0.59

0.82/70,848

WIS SPS

1.24

1.52

-

7.11.5              As shown in Table 7.10, the design capacity of TM54 SPS would need to be further upgraded.  It is recommended to upgrade TM54 SPS from a design capacity of 0.59m3/s to approximately 0.82m3/s.

7.11.6              As discussed in Section 7.3.5, provision of village sewerage adjacent to TM54 SPS is planned for implementation in Q1 2021. It is recommended to review the implementation programme of the sewerage provision project in order to confirm the time frame/ required capacity for upgrading the TM54 SPS.

7.11.7              With the proposed upgrading of the TM54 SPS, the twin 500 diameter rising mains downstream of TM54 SPS would operate with a peak velocity of 1.83m/s which is considered adequate for sewage rising mains.  Therefore, only minor modification of internal pipework within the SPS is anticipated.  The current Environmental Permit (EP) of TM54 SPS comprises the construction and operation of a SPS with a capacity of 90,000m3/day; hence, upgrading of the TM54 SPS would not require a variation of EP.

7.11.8              The upgrading works is proposed to be carried out by DSD.  The detailed construction works would be determined in the detailed design stage.

7.11.9              Sewage generated from SHR Site, SHR Site Extension and HPR Site and the nearby interfacing Tuen Mun Area 54 development is ultimately discharged to the Pillar Point STW for treatment and disposal.  The treatment capacity of Pillar Point STW is 241,000 m3/day (ADWF).

7.11.10          Based on the results from the hydraulic model, Pillar Point STW would have adequate capacity to cater for the sewage flow generated from the PDA.

7.12                   Contingency Plan for the Proposed SPS

7.12.1              In order to avoid the occurrence for emergency discharges, the design SPS shall comprise additional provisions, including:

·         Twin rising mains in case of one of the duty mains be taken out of operation, the remaining one would still be able to deliver flow;

·         Standby pumps and screens in case of unexpected breakdown of maintenance of the pumps and screens such that the standby pumps and screens could take over and allow continuous operation of the SPS;

·         Dual electricity supply from different power sub-stations or backup power supply facilities such as diesel generator in case of power failure to sustain the function of pumping facilities;

·         A storage tank with 2-hour ADWF capacity (about 1,200m3) to hold temporary discharge for a duration required to restore normal operation of the SPS to cater for breakdown and maintenance of the SPS. The proposed SHR SPS is located in urban area, maintenance team can arrive within short time to investigate the problem and resume the SPS operation as soon as possible. Detail arrangement will be formulated in later design stage;

·         Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) system and closed-circuit television (CCTV) will be provided for active monitoring in order to transmit signals showing irregularity or any operational problem of the SPS to the nearby STW or other manned SPS such that immediate actions can be taken in case of emergency; and

·         A hand-cleaned bar screen to cover the lower half of the opening of any overflow bypass to prevent the discharge of floating solids to the receiving water bodies.  The clear spacing of the bar screen should normally be 25 mm.

7.12.2              In addition, regular maintenance and plant inspection will be conducted throughout the operation of the SPS to prevent equipment failure. Regular inspection, at least once per week, should cover the essential equipment in the pumping station. With the above measures implemented, abnormality of the equipment should be identified for remedial action to be taken before failure.

7.12.3              In addition, a contingency plan to deal with the unlikely event of emergency discharge during the operation of the SPS should be developed in the detailed design stage.  The contingency plan should be prepared by referring to (i) “A Guide on Reporting Sewage Bypass Incidents in Sewage Pumping Stations and Sewers” by the EPD of March 2015 and (ii) "Contingency Plan for Incidents Possibly Encountered in Sewage Treatment Facilities having a Potential of Generating an Environmental Nuisance" by the DSD.  The contingency plan should include the following items:

·         Locations of waterbodies or WSRs in the vicinity of the emergency discharge;

·         A list of relevant government departments (including name, address, email address phone and fax number of the key persons) to be informed and their respective follow up action in the event of emergency discharge, including key contact person and telephone numbers;

·         A framework of emergency response and reporting procedures required in the event of emergency discharges; and

·         Procedures listing the most effective means in rectifying the breakdown of the SPS in order to minimize the discharge duration.

7.13                   Conclusion

7.13.1              The latest development parameters of the proposed development at SHR Site, HPR Site and SHR Site Extension, along with the latest information on the existing and planned sewerage network in Tuen Mun were obtained and reviewed.

7.13.2              The proposed SHR SPS would collect sewage from SHR Site, SHR Site Extension and HPR Site for conveyance to the downstream sewerage system.

7.13.3              Only minor impact to the downstream sewerage network is anticipated. In particular, the sewers at the upstream of the TM54 SPS (Section M15.1, M16.1, M17.1 & M18.1) are proposed to be upgraded from DN750 to DN900 and the capacity of the TM54 SPS is proposed to be upgraded from 0.59m3/s to 0.82m3/s in order to handle the sewage generated from the northern Tuen Mun catchment including the planned development in Tuen Mun Area 54 and the proposed development under this project.

7.13.4              The Pillar Point STW would have adequate treatment capacity to cater for the sewage flow generated from the planned development at TM Area 54 and the proposed development under this project.

END OF TEXT