TABLE OF CONTENTS
14.2 Environmental Legislation, Standards
and Guidelines
14.4 Description of Environment
14.5 Identification of Landfill Gas
Generation, Characteristics and Hazards
14.6 Quantitative Assessment of Potential
Risk
14.7 Recommended Protection Measures
14.8 Environmental Monitoring and Audit
List of Tables
Table 14.1 Classification of Risk Category
Table 14.2 Summary of General Categorisation of
Risk
Table 14.3 Generic Protection Measures for
Planning Stage Categorisation
Table 14.4 Definition of Control Terms
Table 14.5 LFG Monitoring Results at SENT and
SENTX (April 2022 – March 2024)
Table 14.6 Source-Pathway-Target Analysis
List of Figures
Location Plan Of South East New Territories
Landfill and Its Extension |
List of Appendices
SENT
and SENTX Landfill Gas Monitoring Location and Monitoring Data |
|
Summary
of SENT and SENTX Landfill Gas Monitoring Data |
·
Section 1.1(f) in Annex 7 of the Technical Memorandum
on Environmental Impact Assessment Process (EIAO-TM);
·
Section 3.3 in Annex 19 of the EIAO-TM;
·
Landfill Gas Hazard Assessment for Development
Adjacent to Landfills
(ProPECC PN 3/96);
·
Landfill Gas Hazard Assessment Guidance Note (2022)
(EPD/TR8/97) (LFGHA Guidance Note); and
·
The Hong Kong Planning Standards and Guidelines
(HKPSG), Chapter 9.
·
Review of background information (including landfill
gas monitoring data) and studies related to the SENT and SENTX;
·
Identification of the nature and extent of the
sources, including the likely concentrations and / or amounts of hazardous
emissions which might have the potential for impacts on the Project and impacts
from the Project to the potential receivers;
·
Identification of the possible pathways through the
ground, underground cavities or groundwater and the nature of these pathways
through which the hazardous emissions must traverse if they were to reach the
Project;
·
Identification of the potentially sensitive receivers
associated with the Project which are sensitive to the impacts of the hazardous
emissions;
·
Qualitative assessment on the degree of risk which the
hazardous emissions may impose on the receivers for each the
source-pathway-receiver combinations;
·
Design and implementation of suitable level of precautionary
/ protection measures and contingency plan for the Project and the potential
receivers, if needed, in rendering the proposed development as safe as
reasonably practicable;
·
Establishment and implementation of a maintenance and
monitoring programme for ensuring the continued performance of the implemented
precautionary / protection measures.
·
Review of background information to determine the
likelihood of landfill gas having an impact on the proposed development. Such
information will include historical information about how the landfill was
engineered and operated, geological and hydrogeological data and results of any
environmental monitoring.
·
Evaluation of the nature and extent of the source(s)
of landfill gas, including the likely concentrations and volumes of hazardous
emissions which may have the potential to affect the proposed development.
·
Identification and evaluation of possible pathways
along which gas could travel from the landfill site to the development site,
through the ground, underground cavities, utilities and groundwater.
·
Identification of the different elements of the
proposed development which will be sensitive to the impacts of landfill gas.
Such potential "targets" will include building basements and ground
level rooms, underground car parks, service ducts and manholes, unventilated
excavations and other confined spaces at or below ground level.
·
A qualitative assessment of overall risk for each
Source-Pathway-Target combination into one of five risk categories (Very high,
High, Medium, Low and Very Low) using professional judgement.
·
Source – location, nature and likely quantities/
concentrations of landfill gas with potential to affect the development;
·
Pathway – the ground and groundwater conditions through which
landfill gas must pass in order to reach the development; and
·
Target – elements of a development that may be sensitive to
the effects of landfill gas.
·
Minor |
Landfill sites at which gas controls have been installed
and proven to be effective by comprehensive monitoring which has demonstrated
that there is no migration of gas beyond the landfill boundary (or any
specific control measures) and at which control of gas does not rely solely
on an active gas extraction system or any other single control measure which
is vulnerable to failure; or old landfill sites where the maximum
concentration of methane within the waste, as measured at several locations
across the landfill and on at least four occasions over a period of at least
3 months (preferably longer), is less than 5% by volume (v/v). |
·
Medium |
Landfill site at which some form of gas control has
been installed (e.g. lined site or one where vents or barriers have been
retrospectively installed) but where there are only limited monitoring data
to demonstrate its efficacy to prevent migration of gas; or a landfill site
where comprehensive monitoring has demonstrated that there is no migration of
gas beyond the landfill boundary but where the control of gas relies solely
on an active gas extraction system or any other single control system which is
vulnerable to failure. |
·
Major |
Recently filled landfill site at which there is
little or no control to prevent migration of gas or at which the efficacy of
the gas control measures has not been assessed; or any landfill site at which
monitoring has demonstrated that there is significant migration of gas beyond
the site boundary. |
·
Very short / direct - Path length <50m for unsaturated permeable
strata and fissured rock or < 100m for man-made conduits
·
Moderately short / direct - Path length
of 50-100m for unsaturated permeable soil or fissured rock or 100-250m for
man-made conduits
·
Long / indirect - Path length of 100-250m for unsaturated permeable
soils and fissured rock
·
Particular permeability of the soils;
·
Spacing, tightness and direction of the
fissures/joints;
·
Topography;
·
Depth and thickness of the medium through which the
gas may migrate (which may be affected by groundwater level);
·
The nature of the strata over the potential pathway;
·
The number of different media involved; and
·
Depth to groundwater table and flow patterns.
High sensitivity |
Buildings or structures with
ground level or below ground rooms/voids or into which services enter
directly from the ground and to which members of the general public have
unrestricted access or which contain sources of ignition. This would include any developments where
there is a possibility of additional structures being erected directly on the
ground on an ad hoc basis and thereby without due regard to the potential
risks. |
Medium sensitivity |
Buildings, structures or service
voids where there is access only by authorised, well trained personnel, such
as the staff of utility companies, who have been briefed on the potential
hazards relating to landfill gas and the specific safety procedures to be
followed or deep excavations. |
Low sensitivity |
Buildings/structures which are
less prone to gas ingress by virtue of their design (such as those with a
raised floor slab). Excavations or developments which involve essentially
outdoor activities but where evolution of gas could pose potential problems. |
Table 14.1 Classification of Risk Category
Source |
Pathway |
Target Sensitivity |
Risk Category |
|
|
High |
Very
High |
|
Very
short / direct |
Medium |
High |
|
|
Low |
Medium |
|
|
High |
High |
Major |
Moderately
short / direct |
Medium |
Medium |
|
|
Low |
Low |
|
|
High |
High |
|
Long /
indirect |
Medium |
Medium |
|
|
Low |
Low |
|
|
High |
High |
|
Very
short / direct |
Medium |
Medium |
|
|
Low |
Low |
|
|
High |
High |
Medium |
Moderately
short / direct |
Medium |
Medium |
|
|
Low |
Low |
|
|
High |
Medium |
|
Long /
indirect |
Medium |
Low |
|
|
Low |
Very
Low |
|
|
High |
High |
|
Very
short / direct |
Medium |
Medium |
|
|
Low |
Low |
|
|
High |
Medium |
Minor |
Moderately
short / direct |
Medium |
Low |
|
|
Low |
Very
Low |
|
|
High |
Medium |
|
Long /
indirect |
Medium |
Low |
|
|
Low |
Very
Low |
Table 14.2 Summary of General Categorisation of Risk
Category |
Level of Risk |
Implication |
A |
Very
High (Undesirable) |
The
type of development being proposed is very undesirable
and a less sensitive form of development should be considered. At the very
least, extensive engineering measures, alarm systems and emergency action
plans are likely to be required. |
B |
High |
Significant
engineering measures will be required to protect the planned development. |
C |
Medium |
Engineering
measures will be required to protect the proposed development. |
D |
Low |
Some
precautionary measures will be required to ensure that the planned
development is safe. |
E |
Very
Low (Insignificant) |
The
risk is so low that no precautionary measures are required. |
Table 14.3 Generic Protection Measures for Planning Stage Categorisation
Category |
Generic Protection Measures |
A |
For the planned development active
control of gas, supported by barriers and detection systems. Another,
less sensitive form of development should also be considered. |
B |
Active control of gas, including
barriers and detection systems(1). |
C |
Use of 'semi active' or enhanced
passive gas controls. Detection systems in some situations. |
D |
Passive control of gas only. |
E |
No precautionary measures
required. |
Note (1): The gas protection measures required to allow the
safe development of a Category A risk development will need to be more
extensive than those for a Category B risk development
Table 14.4 Definition of Control Terms
Terms |
Definition |
Active |
Control of gas by mechanical means
e.g. ventilation of spaces with air to dilute gas, or extraction of gas from
the development site using fans or blowers. |
Semi active |
Use of wind driven cowls and other
devices which assist in the ventilation of gas but do not rely on
electrically powered fans. |
Passive |
Provision of barriers to the
movement of gas e.g. membranes in floors or walls, or in trenches, coupled
with high permeability vents such as no-fines gravel in trenches or
voids/permeable layers below structures. vents such as gravel in trenches or
a clear void/permeable layer below structures. |
Detection |
Electronic systems based upon, for
example, catalytic oxidation or infra-red measurement principles, which can
detect low concentrations of gas in the atmosphere and can be linked to
alarms and/or telemetry systems. |
·
Its concentration in air is between 5% of the Lower
Explosive Limit (LEL) and 15% of the Upper Explosive Limit (UEL);
·
the gas is in a confined space; and
·
a source of ignition exists.
Plate 14.1 Flammability Levels of Methane and Oxygen
· To eliminate risk of explosion or combustion due to the presence of LFG within, below, above and inside the landfill site;
· To eliminate hazards to flora or fauna due to toxicity or asphyxiant effects of LFG external to the landfill site;
· To minimise the effect of odours from LFG causing nuisance in the vicinity of the landfill site;
· To minimise uncontrolled egress of LFG from the landfill site;
· To eliminate migration of LFG to service ducts or enclosed/confined spaces of any onsite buildings;
· To protect any temporary or permanent structures or chambers on the landfill site;
· To prevent unnecessary air ingress into the landfill;
· To prevent unnecessary build-up of LFG pressure within the landfill;
· To relieve positive pressures of LFG at the landfill boundary and near the surface;
· To facilitate the controlled extraction of LFG from the landfill;
· To facilitate the ultimate flaring and utilisation of LFG; and
· To provide signs designating hazards and precautions to avoid on-site accidents.
Table 14.5 LFG Monitoring Results at SENT and SENTX (April 2022 – March 2024)
Range of Average Methane %v/v |
Range of Average Carbon Dioxide %v/v |
Range of Average Oxygen %v/v |
|
SENT |
0.00 -
0.65 |
0.00 -
3.32 |
3.59 -
20.68 |
SENTX |
0.01 -
7.95 |
0.00 -
1.38 |
11.35 -
19.85 |
· Government, Institution or Community (G/IC)
· Public Housing Site (RSc)
· Open Space (O)
· Education (E)
· Other Specified Uses (OU)
Table 14.6 Source-Pathway-Target Analysis
Source
|
Pathway
|
Target
Sensitivity *
|
Risk Category *
|
SENT and SENTX : there is
potential for gas generation over time, but comprehensive and proven control
measures are installed.
SENT and SENTX is considered as a “Medium” category
source
|
The minimum separation between the landfills and
the development is 30m, which is the width of planned Wan Po Road. Depending
on the actual separation, pathways are considered to be “Very short / direct”,
“Moderately short/direct”
or “Long/indirect”.
|
Construction Phase –
Foundation construction during development may entail deep excavation where
risk of exposure of LFG can increase. However, construction works would be
undertaken by trained workers with risk assessment, safety supervision and
implementation of safe construction methodologies acting to mitigate
identified risks. Construction Phase targets are classified as Medium
Sensitivity.
|
Source Pathway Receptor
linkages classify the overall risk during construction phase to be “Low”
or “Medium”
|
Operation Phase – Open Space
(O):
Depending on the actual design of indoor
facilities (such as toilets), Open Spaces (O) will be classified as Low
Sensitivity.
|
Source Pathway Receptor
linkages classify the overall risk to be “Very Low” or “Low”
|
||
Operation Phase – Government,
Institution or Community (G/IC), Public Housing Site (RSc), Education (E):
Depending on the actual design and usage of the
buildings, all other proposed land use will be classified as either Highly
Sensitive or Medium Sensitivity. However, the actual target sensitivity will
be dependent on the actual building layout/design.
|
Source Pathway Receptor
linkages classify the overall risk to be “Low”. “Medium” or “High”,
|
||
Other Specified Uses –
Effluent Polishing Plant. Target sensitivity will be dependent on the
facility design but anticipated to be Medium - High sensitivity.
|
Source Pathway Receptor
linkages classify the overall risk to be “Medium” or “High”
|
* This operation phase classification
is intended only as preliminary guidance on the nature of protective works
anticipated for the development, and a more detailed investigation and
reassessment at the development stage will allow targeted and more accurate
design of protective measures.
Appointment of a Safety Officer
Methane |
0-100% LEL and 0-100% v/v |
Carbon dioxide |
0-100% |
Oxygen |
0-21% |
Safety Measures
· All personnel who work on site and all visitors to the site should be made aware of the possibility of ignition of gas in the vicinity of excavations. Safety notices should be posted warning of the potential hazards.
· Those staff who work in, or have responsibility for 'at risk' areas, including all excavation workers, supervisors and engineers working within the Consultation Zone, should receive appropriate training on working in areas susceptible to landfill gas, fire and explosion hazards.
· An excavation procedure or code of practice to minimise landfill gas related risk should be devised and carried out by the project proponent.
· No worker should be allowed to work alone at any time in or near to any excavation. At least one other worker should be available to assist with a rescue if needed.
· Smoking, naked flames and all other sources of ignition should be prohibited within 15m of any excavation or ground-level confined space. 'No smoking' and 'No naked flame' notices should be posted prominently on the construction site and, if necessary, special areas designated for smoking.
· Welding, flame-cutting or other hot works should be confined to open areas at least 15m from any trench or excavation.
· Welding, flame-cutting or other hot works may only be carried out in trenches or confined spaces when controlled by a “permit to work” procedure, properly authorised by the Safety Officer.
· The permit to work procedure should set down clearly the requirements for continuous monitoring for methane, carbon dioxide and oxygen throughout the period during which the hot works are in progress. The procedure should also require the presence of an appropriately qualified person, in attendance outside the 'confined area', who shall be responsible for reviewing the gas measurements as they are made, and who shall have executive responsibility for suspending the work in the event of unacceptable or hazardous conditions. Only those workers who are appropriately trained and fully aware of the potentially hazardous conditions which may arise should be permitted to carry out hot works in confined areas.
· Ground level construction plant should be fitted with vertical exhausts at least 0.6m above ground level and with spark arrestors.
· Any electrical equipment, such as motors and extension cords, should be intrinsically safe.
· During piping assembly or conduiting construction, all valves/seals should be closed immediately after installation. As construction progresses, all valves/seals should be closed as installed to prevent the migration of gases through the pipeline/conduit. All piping/conduiting should be capped at the end of each working day.
· Mobile offices, equipment stores, mess rooms etc. should be located on an area which has been proven to be gas free (by survey with portable gas detectors) and ongoing monitoring should be carried out to ensure that these areas remain gas free. The use of permanent gas detectors may be appropriate in some circumstances where there is a relatively high risk but for many developments it will be sufficient to have regular monitoring undertaken manually by the safety officer. The particular arrangements to be adopted at a specific site will need to be determined during the risk assessment/design of protection measures.
· Alternatively, such buildings should be raised clear of the ground. If buildings are raised clear of the ground, a minimum, clear separation distance (as measured from the highest point on the ground surface to the underside of the lowest floor joist) should be 500mm.
· During construction, adequate fire extinguishing equipment, fire-resistant clothing and breathing apparatus (BA) sets should be made available on site.
· Fire drills should be organised at not less than six monthly intervals.
· The developer should formulate a health and safety policy, standards and instructions for site personnel to follow.
Monitoring
· The monitoring frequency and areas to be monitored should be set down prior to commencement of groundworks either by the Safety Officer or by an appropriately qualified person.
· Routine monitoring should be carried out in all excavations, manholes and chambers and any other confined spaces that may have been created by, for example, the temporary storage of building materials on the site surface.
· All measurements in excavations should be made with the monitoring tube located not more than 10mm from the exposed ground surface.
Monitoring of excavations
· At the ground surface before excavation commences;
· Immediately before any worker enters the excavation;
· At the beginning of each working day for the entire period the excavation remains open; and
· Periodically through the working day whilst workers are in the excavation.
· Directly after the excavation has been completed; and
· Periodically whilst the excavation remains open.
· For excavations less than 300mm deep, monitoring may be omitted, at the discretion of the Safety Officer or other appropriately qualified person.
Actions In The Event Of Gas Being Detected
· Depending on the results of the measurements of landfill gas, actions required will vary and should be set down by the Safety Officer or other appropriately qualified person. The actions required in the event of landfill gas being detected in excavated/ confined area are as follows;
Actions in the Event of Landfill Gas Being Detected in
Excavations / Confined Areas
Parameter |
Measurement |
Action |
Oxygen |
< 19 % |
Ventilate to restore oxygen to > 19 % |
< 18 % |
Stop works Evacuate personnel/prohibit entry Increase ventilation to restore oxygen to > 19 % |
|
Methane |
> 10% LEL |
Prohibit hot works Ventilate to restore methane to < 10% LEL |
> 20% LEL |
Stop works Evacuate personnel/prohibit entry Increase ventilation to restore methane to < 10 % LEL |
|
Carbon Dioxide |
> 0.5% |
Ventilate to restore carbon dioxide to < 0.5% |
> 1.5% |
Stop works Evacuate personnel/prohibit entry Increase ventilation to restore carbon dioxide to < 0.5% |
Specific Advice Relating to the Drilling of Boreholes within the Consultation Zone
· Drilling should only proceed with adequate care and precautions against the potential hazards which may be encountered.
· Before site works begin, the drilling contractor should devise a 'method-of-working' statement covering all normal and emergency procedures and the site supervisor and all operatives must be familiar with this statement.
· number of operatives;
· experience and special skills of operatives;
· normal method of operations;
· emergency procedures, including firefighting;
· supervisors’ responsibilities;
· storage and use of safety equipment;
· safety procedures; and
· signs, barriers and guarding.
Safety Equipment and Clothing
· no smoking signs, to be placed prominently adjacent to the drilling area;
· portable fire extinguisher;
· high visibility clothing to be worn by all drilling operatives; and
· additional protective clothing should include stout industrial boots (with steel toe cap
· and insole), plastic hard hats, heavy duty waterproof industrial gloves.
Working Procedures
· On arrival at site the drilling rig should be set-up up-wind of the borehole location, 'No smoking' signs set out and the working area should be roped or coned-off.
· At the end of the working day all vehicles, the drilling rig and any hand tools should be hosed down with clean water to remove deposits of excavated spoil.
· Suitable guards or barriers should be placed around the excavation or borehole to prevent access by unauthorised persons.
Safety Procedures
· One person should be present at all times during drilling operations, with the sole responsibility of assuring the observance of all safety procedures. This person should be trained in the use of all recommended safety equipment.
· Smoking should be prohibited within 15 metres of a boring or excavation at any locations within the Consultation Zone.
· For large diameter boreholes, a working platform should be placed over the hole which will prevent accidental entry into the hole by operatives.
· No worker should be allowed to work alone at any time near the edge of the well under construction. Another worker should always be present, beyond the area considered to be subject to the possible effects of landfill gas or cave-in.
· Periodically during the well construction, the work areas should be monitored for levels of methane.
· If the well construction is not completed by the end of the working day, the hole should be covered with a plate of sufficient overlap to prevent access to the hole and sufficient structural strength to support expected loads. The plate should be weighted down to discourage removal and, on landfill sites, the edges of the plate should be covered with sufficient depth of wet soil to prevent escape of gas.
· All pipes or casings should be capped at the end of each working day.
· Engine-driven rigs should have vertical exhaust stacks discharging not less than 1.5m above ground level and should have overspeed limits to prevent engine run away on ingested gas.
· Diesel engine air-intakes should also be located not less than 1.5m above ground level.
· Any electrical equipment should be intrinsically safe.
· Additional safety advice and guidance may be found in 'Investigation into Establishing an Effective Practical Safe Working Practice When Drilling in Landfill Sites and Adjacent Areas and Contaminated Ground and Adjacent Areas' compiled by the British Drilling Association (1993).
Utility Protection Design Measures (applicable to construction phase)
· For all service runs, the aim should be to provide a protective barrier at the point where the trenches pass through the perimeter of the consultation zone such that trench excavations do not form a route for gas migration to or from unprotected utilities beyond the Consultation Zone.
· For service runs within the consultation zone these may remain “unprotected” as the general public may not have access to such underground features, however ducts, manholes and chambers to utility services within the consultation zone should be sealed from the surrounding ground to prevent gas entry and provided with vented covers to allow any gas that enters to dissipate to atmosphere.
· The service run should be designated as a “special route” and utility companies should be informed to that effect so that they may implement precautionary measures. Precautionary measures should include ensuring that staff members are aware of the potential hazards of working in confined spaces such as manholes and service chambers, and that appropriate monitoring procedures are in place to prevent hazards due to asphyxiating atmospheres in confined spaces. Detailed guidance on entry into confined spaces is given in Code of Practice on Safety and Health at Work in Confined Spaces (Labor Department, Hong Kong).
· Above ground (minor) termination features e.g. transformers, gas kiosks and telecom cabinets should be considered to be “buildings” and should be protected by e.g. membrane barriers to minimise the possibility of gas ingress.
· Any future works such as maintenance or extensions should be subject to the recommendations specified in the LFGHA Guidance Note.
· Gas-resistant polymeric membranes which can be incorporated into floor or wall construction as a continuous sealed layer. Membranes should be able to demonstrate low gas permeability and resistance to possible chemical attack, and may incorporate aluminium wafers to improve performance;
· Other building materials such as dense well-compacted concrete or steel shuttering which provide a measure of resistance to gas permeation;
· Creation of a clear void under the structure which is ventilated by natural air movements such that any emissions of gas from the ground are mixed and diluted by air;
· Synthetic composite geotextiles which provide a free-venting cellular structure and provide preferential pathways for release of gas.
· A void under the structure, which is continuously ventilated by mechanical fans, such that any emissions of gas from the ground are mixed and diluted in the air flow before discharge to atmosphere;
· Construction of a granular layer incorporating perforated collector pipes which is continuously ventilated by mechanical fan, such that any emissions of gas from the ground are drawn towards the end of the pipes and diluted in the air flow before discharge to atmosphere;
· Creation of a positive pressure zone below the building structure by injection of air from a blower into the granular layer; and
· Creation of positive air pressure zones within building structures to counteract possible leakage of gas into the building from the ground.
· For any newly built permanent building structures (e.g. basement plant rooms in buildings into which operators frequently enter) within the 250m Consultation Zone, forced ventilation should be installed in such rooms or buildings. Gas detection systems with audible alarm should also be installed in such area of the development in order to monitor internal spaces inside buildings. The gas detection systems should be calibrated and maintained at regular basis in according to the recommendation of manufacturer’s instruction. The operators at the development should also make sure that the gas detection systems are always in functions during the operational phase of the development.