|
This
study provides a means of supplementing existing data
on marine environmental contamination and can also serve
as a baseline for establishing the effects of development
and other impacts over time on marine resources. Measurement
of tissue contamination levels in marine species provides
a clear indication of the quantities of contaminants
that are passing from the environment into the food
chain. For the purposes of this baseline Study it was
considered important that when selecting the target
species for the analyses that they have a degree of
relevance to human health and, therefore, species from
the inshore commercial fishery were analysed(2)). It
was initially suggested that a fixed list of target
species be established for both the surveys in the wet
and dry seasons and for all of the sampling stations.
However, given that fisheries resources in Hong Kong
are known to vary markedly both over time and between
areas, it was decided that the most numerous species
in each catch should be analysed. Initially it was also
thought that preference should be given to larger individuals
for the following reasons:
-
larger
individuals would have been exposed to contaminants
in the marine environment for longer periods of
time, and therefore, may potentially contain higher
body burdens (this assumes that the organisms have
limited ability to remove contaminants from their
bodies through excretion);
-
larger
individuals are more likely to have had more exposure
to benthic sediments (contaminant sink) through
direct contact as they occur in the lower half of
the water column or through consumption of benthic
dwelling organisms; and,
-
the
larger individuals in fish catches are those more
likely to be sold for human consumption and are
therefore more relevant when discussing issues pertaining
to human health.
Marine
resources in Hong Kong waters are known to have become
depleted over time through overfishing, and in certain
areas, such as North Lantau, through the effects of
habitat loss, coastal development and pollution(3)).
What was once a fishery dominated by large, slow growing
and high value fish species is now dominated by small,
short-lived, fast growing and low value species.
The
nature of the Hong Kong fishery, therefore, poses constraints
on surveys of tissue contamination in fish species.
It has become difficult to collect sufficient quantities
of tissues for laboratory analysis due to the small
size of catches and lack of large individuals. The resultant
catches tend to be composed of a small number of mainly
young (small) individuals of a variety of different
species. However, this is not necessarily a disadvantage
to the current work, as analyses of smaller organisms
may provide the basis for a worst-case contamination
scenario of local marine biota because of the reasons
outlined below:
-
smaller
individuals have larger surface area to volume ratios
and thus have proportionally higher body burdens
than larger individuals;
-
enzymes
involved in contaminant detoxification are often
not fully developed in younger organisms; and,
-
there
is a contaminant dilution effect in larger individuals.
This
baseline Study is structured to focus on various organic
contaminants which owing to technical difficulties in
their measurement, are not frequently analysed in Hong
Kong's monitoring programmes. As described in the methodology
(see Sections 2 and 3), analysis of Total Polychlorinated
Biphenyls (PCB), Total Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons
(PAH), organochlorine pesticide (Total DDT) and Tributyltin
was undertaken for tissues, and analysis of organochlorine
pesticides (Total DDT) and Tributyltin measured in sediments.
|