West Kowloon Cultural District

 

 

Environmental Impact Assessment (Final)

HTML version

July 2013

West Kowloon Cultural District Authority

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

29F, Tower 6, The Gateway, 9 Canton Road, Tsim Sha Tsui, Kowloon, Hong Kong

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Mott MacDonald, 20/F Two Landmark East, 100 How Ming Street, Kwun Tong, Kowloon, Hong Kong
T +852 2828 5757   F +852 2827 1823
,   W www.mottmac.com

 

 

 

This document is issued for the party which commissioned it and for specific purposes connected with the above-captioned project only. It should not be relied upon by any other party or used for any other purpose.

We accept no responsibility for the consequences of this document being relied upon by any other party, or being used for any other purpose, or containing any error or omission which is due to an error or omission in data supplied to us by other parties

This document contains confidential information and proprietary intellectual property. It should not be shown to other parties without consent from us and from the party which commissioned it.

 

 



                    

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Content


Chapter    Title                                                                                                                           Page

1.               Introduction_____________________________________________________________________

1.1                  Background______________________________________________________________________

1.2                  Designated Projects under the EIA Ordinance____________________________________________

1.3                  Objectives of the EIA Study__________________________________________________________

1.4                  Key Environmental Issues___________________________________________________________

1.5                  Use of Relevant Studies_____________________________________________________________

1.6                  Structure of the EIA Report___________________________________________________________

 

2.               Project Description_______________________________________________________________

2.1                  Existing Site Conditions_____________________________________________________________

2.2                  Project Components_______________________________________________________________

2.3                  Need of the Project________________________________________________________________

2.4                  Consideration of Alternative Development Options________________________________________

2.5                  Consideration of Alternative Construction Methods and Sequences of Works____________________

2.6                  Summary of Selection of Preferred Scenario_____________________________________________

2.7                  Proposed Project Programme________________________________________________________

2.8                  Concurrent Projects________________________________________________________________

 

3.               Air Quality Impact________________________________________________________________

3.1                  Introduction______________________________________________________________________

3.2                  Air Quality Legislations, Standards and Guidelines________________________________________

3.3                  Baseline Conditions________________________________________________________________

3.4                  Identification of Pollution Sources_____________________________________________________

3.5                  Air Quality Modelling Methodology_____________________________________________________

3.6                  Evaluation and Assessment of the Air Quality Impacts______________________________________

3.7                  Mitigation Measures________________________________________________________________

3.8                  Evaluation of Residual Impacts_______________________________________________________

3.9                  Environmental Monitoring and Audit___________________________________________________

3.10                Conclusion_______________________________________________________________________

 

4.               Noise Impact____________________________________________________________________

4.1                  Introduction______________________________________________________________________

4.2                  Noise Legislations, Standards and Guidelines____________________________________________

4.3                  Baseline Conditions________________________________________________________________

4.4                  Identification of Pollution Sources_____________________________________________________

4.5                  Assessment Methodology___________________________________________________________

4.6                  Evaluation of the Noise Impacts_______________________________________________________

4.7                  Mitigation Measures________________________________________________________________

4.8                  Evaluation of Residual Impacts_______________________________________________________

4.9                  Environmental Monitoring and Audit___________________________________________________

4.10                Conclusion_______________________________________________________________________

 

5.               Water Quality Impact______________________________________________________________

5.1                  Introduction______________________________________________________________________

5.2                  Water Quality Legislations, Standards and Guidelines______________________________________

5.3                  Assessment Area, Water Sensitive Receivers and Baseline Conditions_________________________

5.4                  Identification of Water Quality Impact___________________________________________________

5.5                  Assessment Methodology___________________________________________________________

5.6                  Prediction and Evaluation of the Water Quality Impact______________________________________

5.7                  Mitigation of Adverse Water Quality Impact______________________________________________

5.8                  Evaluation of Cumulative and Residual Water Quality Impact________________________________

5.9                  Water Quality Monitoring and Audit____________________________________________________

5.10                Conclusion_______________________________________________________________________

 

6.               Sewerage and Sewage Treatment Implication_________________________________________

6.1                  Introduction______________________________________________________________________

6.2                  Sewerage and Sewage Treatment Legislations, Standards and Guidelines______________________

6.3                  Baseline Conditions________________________________________________________________

6.4                  Assessment Methodology___________________________________________________________

6.5                  Evaluation and Assessment of Sewerage and Sewage Treatment Implications___________________

6.6                  Hydraulic Modelling________________________________________________________________

6.7                  Mitigation Measures________________________________________________________________

6.8                  Environmental Monitoring and Audit___________________________________________________

6.9                  Conclusion_______________________________________________________________________

 

7.               Waste Management Implication_____________________________________________________

7.1                  Introduction______________________________________________________________________

7.2                  Waste Management Legislations, Standards and Guidelines_________________________________

7.3                  Assessment Methodology___________________________________________________________

7.4                  Identification, Prediction and Evaluation of Environmental Impact_____________________________

7.5                  Mitigation of Adverse Environmental Impact_____________________________________________

7.6                  Evaluation of Residual Impact________________________________________________________

7.7                  Environmental Monitoring and Audit___________________________________________________

7.8                  Conclusion_______________________________________________________________________

 

8.               Land Contamination______________________________________________________________

8.1                  Introduction______________________________________________________________________

8.2                  Environmental Legislation, Standards and Guidelines______________________________________

8.3                  Description of the Environmental Baseline Conditions______________________________________

8.4                  Assessment Methodology___________________________________________________________

8.5                  Identification and Evaluation of Environmental Impact______________________________________

8.6                  Mitigation of Adverse Environmental Impact_____________________________________________

8.7                  Evaluation of Residual Impact________________________________________________________

8.8                  Environmental Monitoring and Audit___________________________________________________

8.9                  Conclusion_______________________________________________________________________

 

9.               Ecological Impact (Terrestrial)______________________________________________________

9.1                  Introduction______________________________________________________________________

9.2                  Ecological Legislations, Standards and Guidelines________________________________________

9.3                  Assessment Methodology___________________________________________________________

9.4                  Baseline Conditions________________________________________________________________

9.5                  Evaluation and Assessment of Ecological Impacts_________________________________________

9.6                  Mitigation Measures________________________________________________________________

9.7                  Residual Impacts__________________________________________________________________

9.8                  Environmental Monitoring and Audit___________________________________________________

9.9                  Conclusion_______________________________________________________________________

9.10                Reference_______________________________________________________________________

 

10.              Landscape and Visual Impact______________________________________________________

10.1                Introduction______________________________________________________________________

10.2                Landscape and Visual Legislations, Standards and Guidelines_______________________________

10.3                Assessment Methodology___________________________________________________________

10.4                Baseline Study____________________________________________________________________

10.5                Evaluation and Assessment of Landscape and Visual Impacts_______________________________

10.6                Considerations of Alternatives________________________________________________________

10.7                Mitigation Measures________________________________________________________________

10.8                Residual Impacts__________________________________________________________________

10.9                Environmental Monitoring and Audit___________________________________________________

10.10              Conclusion_______________________________________________________________________

 

11.              Environmental Monitoring and Audit_________________________________________________

11.1                General_________________________________________________________________________

11.2                Air Quality Impact__________________________________________________________________

11.3                Noise Impact_____________________________________________________________________

11.4                Water Quality Impact_______________________________________________________________

11.5                Sewerage and Sewage Treatment Implications___________________________________________

11.6                Waste Management Implications______________________________________________________

11.7                Land Contamination_______________________________________________________________

11.8                Ecological Impact (Terrestrial)________________________________________________________

11.9                Landscape and Visual Impact________________________________________________________

 

12.              Conclusions_____________________________________________________________________

12.1            General_________________________________________________________________________

12.2            Summary of Environmental Outcomes_______________________________________________

12.3            Air Quality Impact________________________________________________________________

12.4            Noise Impact____________________________________________________________________

12.5            Water Quality Impact______________________________________________________________

12.6            Sewerage and Sewage Treatment Implications________________________________________

12.7            Waste Management Implications____________________________________________________

12.8            Land Contamination______________________________________________________________

12.9            Ecological Impact (Terrestrial)______________________________________________________

12.10          Landscape and Visual Impact______________________________________________________

 

13.              Implementation Schedule__________________________________________________________

13.1                General_________________________________________________________________________

 

14.              EIA on Underpass Road Serving the Planned WKCD___________________________________

14.1                Introduction______________________________________________________________________

14.2                Project Description_________________________________________________________________

14.3                Air Quality Impact__________________________________________________________________

14.4                Noise Impact_____________________________________________________________________

14.5                Water Quality Impact_______________________________________________________________

14.6                Sewerage and Sewage Treatment Implication____________________________________________

14.7                Waste Management Implication_______________________________________________________

14.8                Land Contamination_______________________________________________________________

14.9                Ecological Impact__________________________________________________________________

14.10              Landscape and Visual Impact________________________________________________________

14.11              Environmental Monitoring and Audit___________________________________________________

14.12              Conclusions______________________________________________________________________

14.13              Implementation Schedule___________________________________________________________

 

15.              EIA on Austin Road Flyover Serving the Planned WKCD________________________________

15.1                Introduction______________________________________________________________________

15.2                Project Description_________________________________________________________________

15.3                Air Quality Impact__________________________________________________________________

15.4                Noise Impact_____________________________________________________________________

15.5                Water Quality Impact_______________________________________________________________

15.6                Sewerage and Sewage Treatment Implication____________________________________________

15.7                Waste Management Implication_______________________________________________________

15.8                Land Contamination_______________________________________________________________

15.9                Ecological Impact__________________________________________________________________

15.10              Landscape and Visual Impact________________________________________________________

15.11              Environmental and Monitoring Audit___________________________________________________

15.12              Conclusions______________________________________________________________________

15.13              Implementation Schedule___________________________________________________________

 


Tables

Table ‎2.1:__ Summary of Major Differences between the Conceptual Plan Option: “City Park” and the Modified Conceptual Plan       

Table ‎2.2:__ Summary of Development Plan Approach and Environmental Benefits / Dis-benefits______________

Table ‎2.3:__ Comparison of the Benefits and Dis-Benefits of Basement Construction Sequencing______________

Table ‎2.4:__ Summary of Alternative Construction Methodologies and Environmental Benefits/Dis-benefits

Table ‎2.5:__ Summary of Preferred Construction Sequence and Environmental Benefits/Dis-benefits___________

Table ‎2.6:__ Summary of Tentative Construction and Implementation Programme for Key Facilities of WKCD_____

Table ‎2.7:      List of concurrent projects for cumulative impact assessment________________________________

 

Table 3.1:      Hong Kong Air Quality Objectives______________________________________________________

Table 3.2:      Limits of air pollutant concentrations inside car parks and vehicle tunnels_______________________

Table 3.3:      Representative ASRs Identified for the Assessment________________________________________

Table 3.4:      Average Background TSP Concentrations from EPD’s Urban Air Monitoring Stations (Year 2007-2011)              

Table 3.5:      Air Quality Monitoring Results for Hong Kong Section of Guangzhou-Shenzhen-Hong Kong Express Rail Link relevant to WKCD (March 2010 – December 2012)_________________________________________________

Table 3.6:      Average Background Air Pollutant Concentrations from EPD’s Urban Air Monitoring Stations (Year 2007-2011)

Table 3.7:      Average Background Air Pollutant Concentrations from EPD’s Local Monitoring Station at WKCD Site (September 2011 – August 2012)____________________________________________________________________

Table 3.8:      Number of Odour Complaints against NYMTTS Received by EPD (2006-2013)___________________

Table 3.9:      Summary of concurrent projects during construction phase__________________________________

Table 3.10:    Key Dust Emission Factors Adopted in the Assessment_____________________________________

Table 3.11:    Summary of tentative active area calculations for Tier 2 and Annual TSP assessment______________

Table 3.12:    Vehicle Classification in the EMFAC-HK Model___________________________________________

Table 3.13:    Estimated Emission Rates of Barges at NYPCWA_________________________________________

Table 3.14:    Estimated Emission Rates of Fast Ferries at China Ferry Terminal_____________________________

Table 3.15:    Estimated Emission Rates of Cruise Ships at Ocean Terminal________________________________

Table 3.16:    Summary of 2015 and 2020 Hong Kong Emission Inventory for the PATH Model_________________

Table 3.17:    Summary of Predicted Cumulative Hourly Average TSP Concentrations for All ASRs (Tier 1 Unmitigated & Mitigated)    

Table 3.18:    Predicted Cumulative Hourly Average TSP Concentrations for ASRs with Exceedance (Tier 1 Mitigated)            

Table 3.19:    Summary of Predicted Cumulative Daily Average TSP Concentrations for All ASRs (Tier 1 Unmitigated & Mitigated)       

Table 3.20:    Summary of Predicted Cumulative Hourly Average TSP Concentrations (Tier 2 Mitigated)__________

Table 3.21:    Summary of Predicted Cumulative Annual Average TSP Concentrations for All ASRs (Unmitigated & Mitigated)              

Table 3.22:    Summary of Predicted Cumulative RSP, SO2 and NO2 Concentrations for All ASRs_______________

Table 3.23:    Breakdown of Predicted Cumulative NO2 Concentrations by Sources for ASRs with Potential Exceedance        

Table 3.24:    Breakdown of Predicted Cumulative Hourly NO2 Concentrations by Sources for Selected ASRs (for the Worst Case Year of 2015)_________________________________________________________________________

Table 3.25:    Breakdown of Predicted Cumulative Hourly NO2 Concentrations by Sources for Selected ASRs (for Year 2020)               

Table 3.26:    Estimated Odour Emission Rates for NYMTTS____________________________________________

Table 3.27:    Summary of Odour modelling Results__________________________________________________

Table 3.28:    Breakdown of Odour modelling Results under Current Scenario______________________________

Table 3.29:    Breakdown of Odour modelling Results under Mitigated Scenario A___________________________

Table 3.30:    Breakdown of Odour modelling Results under Mitigated Scenario B___________________________

Table 3.31:    Summary of Recommended Odour Mitigation Measures for NYMTTS__________________________

 

Table 4.1:      Noise Standards for Daytime Construction Activities_______________________________________

Table 4.2:      Relevant Road Traffic Noise Standards for Planning Purposes_______________________________

Table 4.3:      Area Sensitivity Rating______________________________________________________________

Table 4.4:      Acceptable Noise Level for Fixed Noise Source___________________________________________

Table 4.5       Noise Criteria of Fixed Plant Noise_____________________________________________________

Table 4.6       Noise Criteria of Fixed Plant Noise for the Outdoor Performance Venues_______________________

Table 4.7:      Ground-borne Operational Noise Level Criteria___________________________________________

Table 4.8:      Proposed Ground-borne Operational Noise Level Criteria for Special Venues in WKCD____________

Table 4.9:      Representative Noise Sensitive Receivers_______________________________________________

Table 4.10:    Adjustment Factor for Building Coupling Loss (BCF)_______________________________________

Table 4.11:    Adjustment Factor for Building Structure Attenuation (BSA)__________________________________

Table 4.12:    Building Structure Attenuation (BSA) for WKCD Study______________________________________

Table 4.13:    Building Structure Resonance (BSR) for WKCD Study______________________________________

Table 4.14:    Krad (dB) at Different Location________________________________________________________

Table 4.15:    Conversion to Noise Factors_________________________________________________________

Table 4.16:    Unmitigated Construction Airborne Noise Impact from this Project_____________________________

Table 4.17:    Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact in Year 2032 – Scenario with Interim Access at Austin Road West          

Table 4.18:    Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact in Year 2032 – Scenario with Permanent Access at Canton Road           

Table 4.19:    Summary of Fixed Plant Noise Sources_________________________________________________

Table 4.20:    SWLs of the Existing Fixed Plant and Fixed Plant from XRL projects___________________________

Table 4.21:    Maximum Allowable SWLs of the Fixed Plant within WKCD__________________________________

Table 4.22:    Predicted Outdoor Air Activity Noise Impact without Mitigation Measures________________________

Table 4.23:    Predicted Ground-borne Noise Impact from XRL EIA_______________________________________

Table 4.24:    Predicted Ground-borne Noise Impact from WR-KSL_______________________________________

Table 4.25:    Predicted Ground-borne Noise Impact from AEL/TCL______________________________________

Table 4.26:    Quieter PME Recommended for Adoption during Construction Phase__________________________

Table 4.27:    Noise Mitigation Measures for Certain PME during Construction Phase_________________________

Table 4.28:    Mitigated Construction Airborne Noise Impact from this Project_______________________________

Table 4.29:    Overall Cumulative Construction Noise Impact___________________________________________

Table 4.30:    Summary of Benefitted and Protected Planned Dwellings (Interim Access at Austin Road West)______

Table 4.31:    Summary of Benefitted and Protected Planned Dwellings (Permanent Access at Canton Road)______

Table 4.32:    Recommended At-receiver Noise Mitigation Measures for Residential Buildings__________________

Table 4.33:    Assessment of Residual Impacts during Construction Phase________________________________

 

Table ‎5.1:      Water Quality Objectives for Victoria Harbour WCZ________________________________________

Table ‎5.2:      Water Quality Objectives for the Western Buffer WCZ_______________________________________

Table ‎5.3:      Water Quality Objectives for the Eastern Buffer WCZ_______________________________________

Table ‎5.4:      WSD’s Water Quality Criteria for Flushing Water at Sea Water Intakes__________________________

Table ‎5.5:      Marine Water Quality at Victoria Harbour and Stonecutters Island in 2010_______________________

Table ‎5.6:      Marine Water Quality at Yau Ma Tei Typhoon Shelter in 2010_________________________________

Table ‎5.7:      Summary of Parameters for Thermal Plume Model (Delft3D-FLOW)___________________________

Table ‎5.8:      Diurnal pattern of cooling water discharge for proposed WKCD DCWS and the independent cooling systems   

Table ‎5.9:      Approximate distances of existing cooling water intakes and outfalls from the WKCD DCWS proposed Outfall  

Table ‎5.10:    Summary of Parameters for Modelling of Residual Chlorine (Delft3D-WAQ)_____________________

Table ‎5.11:   Recommended Standard of Recycled Rainwater Quality____________________________________

Table ‎5.12:   Temperature elevations at cooling water intakes__________________________________________

 

Table 6.1:      Recommended Unit Flow Factors_____________________________________________________

Table 6.2:      Peaking Factors___________________________________________________________________

Table 6.3:      Population and Sewage Flow Estimation for WCKD________________________________________

Table 6.4:      Summary of Sewage Flow for Sub-catchment____________________________________________

Table 6.5:      Sewage Flow from Different Catchments discharged to the 1350mm Trunk Sewer________________

Table 6.6:      Boundary Conditions for Hydraulic Model_______________________________________________

Table 6.7:      Summary of Hydraulic Model Results__________________________________________________

 

Table ‎7.1:      Estimates of Inert C&D materials to be Generated by WKCD Project___________________________

Table ‎7.2:      Estimates of Fill Materials to be Imported from Other Potential Projects and/or Government’s Fill

                        Banks___________________________________________________________________________

Table ‎7.3:      Estimates of Inert C&D materials to be Used by Other Potential Projects________________________

Table ‎7.4:      Estimates of Inert C&D materials to be Generated, Reused On-site, Reused Off-site and Disposed____

Table ‎7.5:      Estimation of Maximum Number of Construction Workers during Construction Phase______________

Table ‎7.6:      Summary of Waste Arising during Construction Phase_____________________________________

Table ‎7.7:      Estimation of General Refuse Generation during Operation Phase____________________________

 

Table 8.1:      Land Use History of Project Area______________________________________________________

Table 8.2:      Comparison of KSL site investigation results against RBRG criteria____________________________

Table 8.3:      Potential Contamination for the Project Area and its vicinity__________________________________

 

Table 9.1:      Habitat Evaluation_________________________________________________________________

Table 9.2:      Summary of the potential ecological impact______________________________________________

 

Table ‎10.1:    Impact significance – relationship between sensitivity and magnitude of change__________________

Table ‎10.2:    Assessment categories for residual impacts_____________________________________________

Table ‎10.3:    Impact significance – relationship between sensitivity and magnitude of change__________________

Table ‎10.4:    Landscape resources and sensitivity___________________________________________________

Table ‎10.5:    Landscape character areas and sensitivity_______________________________________________

Table ‎10.6:    Types of VSRs____________________________________________________________________

Table ‎10.7:    VSRs identified within the visual envelope_______________________________________________

Table ‎10.8:    Sensitivity of the VSRs______________________________________________________________

Table ‎10.9:    Source of impacts during construction and operation phase_________________________________

Table ‎10.10: Impacts on landscape resources during construction and operation phase______________________

Table ‎10.11: Impacts on landscape character areas during construction and operation phase__________________

Table ‎10.12: Source of visual impacts during construction phase________________________________________

Table ‎10.13: Source of visual impacts during operation phase__________________________________________

Table ‎10.14: Magnitude of change of VSRs________________________________________________________

Table ‎10.15: Assessment of visual impact during construction phase_____________________________________

Table ‎10.16: Assessment of visual impact during operation phase_______________________________________

 

Table ‎10.17: Sources of potential cumulative landscape and visual impacts from concurrent projects in the

                        surrounding areas, and affected LRs, LCAs and VSRs______________________________________

Table ‎10.18: Landscape mitigation measures during construction phase__________________________________

Table ‎10.19: Landscape mitigation measures during operation phase____________________________________

Table ‎10.20: Significance of impacts on landscape resources during construction and operation phases_________

Table ‎10.21: Significance of impacts on landscape character area during construction and operation phases (all impacts are adverse unless otherwise stated)_____________________________________________________________

Table ‎10.22: Visual mitigation measures during construction phase______________________________________

Table ‎10.23: Good design features and visual mitigation measures during operation phase___________________

Table ‎10.25: Residual impacts on existing trees during construction phase________________________________

Table ‎10.26: Residual impacts on visually sensitive receivers during operation phase________________________

 

Table 13.1:    Implementation Schedule___________________________________________________________

 

Table 14.2.1:           Comparison of environmental benefits and disbenefits of options for the main WKCD road_____

Table 14.2.2:           List of concurrent projects for cumulative impact assessment____________________________

Table 14.3.1:           Hong Kong Air Quality Objectives_________________________________________________

Table 14.3.2:           Limits of air pollutant concentrations inside car parks__________________________________

Table 14.3.3:           Representative ASRs Identified for the Assessment___________________________________

Table.14.3.4            Average Background TSP Air Pollutant Concentrations (Year 2007-2011)__________________

Table 14.3.5:           Air Quality Monitoring Results for Hong Kong Section of Guangzhou-Shenzhen-Hong Kong Express Rail Link relevant to WKCD (March 2010 – December 2012)__________________________________________

Table 14.3.6:           Average Background Air Pollutant Concentrations from EPD’s Urban Air Monitoring Stations (Year 2007-2011)     

Table 14.3.7:           Average Background Air Pollutant Concentrations from EPD’s Local Monitoring Station at WKCD Site (September 2011 – August 2012)___________________________________________________________

Table 14.3.8:           Summary of concurrent projects during construction phase_____________________________

Table 14.3.9:           Key Dust Emission Factors Adopted in the Assessment________________________________

Table 14.3.10:         Summary of tentative active area calculations for Tier 2 and Annual TSP assessment_________

Table 14.3.11:         Vehicle Classification in the EMFAC-HK Model_______________________________________

Table 14.3.12:         Estimated Emission Rates of Barges at NYPCWA_____________________________________

Table 14.3.13:         Estimated Emission Rates of Fast Ferries at China Ferry Terminal________________________

Table 14.3.14:         Estimated Emission Rates of Cruise Ships at Ocean Terminal___________________________

Table 14.3.15:         Summary of 2015 and 2020 Hong Kong Emission Inventory for the PATH Model_____________

Table 14.3.16:         Summary of Predicted Cumulative Hourly Average TSP Concentrations for All ASRs (Tier 1 Unmitigated & Mitigated)___________________________________________________________________________

Table 14.3.17:         Predicted Cumulative Hourly Average TSP Concentrations for ASRs with Exceedance (Tier 1 Mitigated)  

Table 14.3.18:         Summary of Predicted Cumulative Daily Average TSP Concentrations for All ASRs (Tier 1 Unmitigated & Mitigated)___________________________________________________________________________

Table 14.3.19:         Summary of Predicted Cumulative Hourly Average TSP Concentrations (Tier 2 Mitigated)______

Table 14.3.20:         Summary of Predicted Cumulative Annual Average TSP Concentrations for All ASRs (Unmitigated & Mitigated)    

Table 14.3.21:         Summary of Predicted Cumulative RSP, SO2 and NO2 Concentrations for All ASRs__________

Table 14.3.22:         Breakdown of Predicted Cumulative NO2 Concentrations by Sources for ASRs with Potential Exceedance             

Table 14.3.23:         Breakdown of Predicted Cumulative Hourly NO2 Concentrations by Sources for Selected ASRs (for the Worst Case Year of 2015)________________________________________________________________

Table 14.3.24:         Breakdown of Predicted Cumulative Hourly NO2 Concentrations by Sources for Selected ASRs (for Year 2020)    

Table 14.4.1:           Noise Standards for Daytime Construction Activities___________________________________

Table 14.4.2:           Relevant Road Traffic Noise Standards for Planning Purposes___________________________

Table 14.4.3:           Area Sensitivity Rating_________________________________________________________

Table 14.4.4:           Acceptable Noise Level for Fixed Noise Source______________________________________

Table 14.4.5            Noise Criteria of Fixed Plant Noise________________________________________________

Table 14.4.6            Noise Criteria of Fixed Plant Noise for the Outdoor Theatre_____________________________

Table 14.4.7:           Representative Noise Sensitive Receivers__________________________________________

Table 14.4.8:           Unmitigated Construction Airborne Noise Impact from this Project________________________

Table 14.4.9:           Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact in Year 2032 – Scenario with Interim Access at Austin Road West

Table 14.4.10:         Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact in Year 2032 – Scenario with Permanent Access at Canton Road

Table 14.4.11:         Summary of Fixed Plant Noise Sources____________________________________________

Table 14.4.12:         SWLs of the Existing Fixed Plant and Fixed Plant from XRL projects_______________________

Table 14.4.13:         Maximum Allowable SWLs of the Fixed Plant within WKCD_____________________________

Table 14.4.14          Quieter PME Recommended for Adoption during Construction Phase_____________________

Table 14.4.15          Noise Mitigation Measures for Certain PME during Construction Phase____________________

Table 14.4.16:         Mitigated Construction Airborne Noise Impact from this Project__________________________

Table 14.4.17:         Overall Cumulative Construction Noise Impact_______________________________________

Table 14.4.18:         Assessment of Residual Impacts during Construction Phase____________________________

Table 14.5.1:           Water Quality Objectives for Victoria Harbour WCZ____________________________________

Table 14.5.2:           Water Quality Objectives for the Western Buffer WCZ__________________________________

Table 14.5.3:           Water Quality Objectives for the Eastern Buffer WCZ__________________________________

Table 14.5.4:           Marine Water Quality at Victoria Harbour and Stonecutters Island in 2010___________________

Table 14.5.5:           Marine Water Quality at Yau Ma Tei Typhoon Shelter in 2010____________________________

Table 14.7.1:           Estimates of inert C&D Materials to be Generated by WKCD Project_______________________

Table 14.7.2:           Estimates of Fill Materials to be Imported from Other Potential Projects and/or Government’s Fill Banks   

Table 14.7.3:           Estimates of inert C&D Materials to be Used by Other Potential Projects____________________

Table 14.7.4            Estimates of Inert C&D Materials to be Generated, Reused On-site, Reused Off-site and Disposed            

Table 14.7.5:           Estimation of Maximum Number of Construction Workers during Construction Phase_________

Table 14.7.6            Summary of Waste Arisings during Construction Phase________________________________

Table 14.8.1:           Land Use History of Project Area_________________________________________________

Table 14.8.2:           Comparison of KSL site investigation results against RBRG criteria_______________________

Table 14.8.3:           Potential Contamination for the Project Area and its vicinity_____________________________

Table 14.9.1:           Habitat Evaluation_____________________________________________________________

Table 14.9.2:           Summary of the potential ecological impact_________________________________________

Table 14.10.1:         Impact significance - relationship between sensitivity and magnitude of change_____________

Table 14.10.2:         Assessment categories for residual impact__________________________________________

Table 14.10.3:         Impact significance – relationship between sensitivity and magnitude of change_____________

Table 14.10.4:         Landscape Resources and Sensitivity______________________________________________

Table 14.10.5:         Landscape character areas and sensitivity__________________________________________

Table 14.10.6:         Types of VSRs_______________________________________________________________

Table 14.10.7:         Brief Descriptions of the VSRs and the Existing Views_________________________________

Table 14.10.8:         Sensitivity of the VSRs_________________________________________________________

Table 14.10.9:         Source of impacts during construction and operation phase_____________________________

Table 14.10.10:      Impacts on landscape resources during construction and operation phase__________________

Table 14.10.11:      Impacts on landscape character areas during construction and operation phase_____________

Table 14.10.12:      Sources of Visual Impacts during Construction Phase_________________________________

Table 14.10.13:      Sources of Visual Impacts during Operation Phase (Day 1 and Year 10)____________________

Table 14.10.14:      Magnitude of Change of the VSRs________________________________________________

Table 14.10.15:      Significance Threshold of Visual Impact Before and After Mitigation Measures (Construction Phase)        

Table.14.10.16:      Significance Threshold of Visual Impact Before and After Mitigation Measures (Operation Phase)______

Table 14.10.17:      Landscape mitigation measures during construction phase_____________________________

Table 14.10.18:      Landscape mitigation measures during operation phase_______________________________

Table 14.10.19:      Significance of impacts on landscape resources during construction and operation phases_____

Table 14.10.20:      Significance of impacts on landscape character area during construction and operation phases (all impacts are adverse unless otherwise stated)_________________________________________________

Table 14.10.21:      Visual Mitigation Measures during Construction Phase_________________________________

Table 14.10.22:      Visual mitigation measures during Operation Phase___________________________________

Table 14.10.23:      Potential cumulative landscape and visual impacts from concurrent project_________________

Table 14.10.24:      Summary of LRs, LCAs and VSRs affected by concurrent projects________________________

Table 14.10.25:      Residual impacts on existing trees during construction phase____________________________

Table 14.10.26:      Residual impacts on landscape character areas during construction and operation phase______

Table 14.13.1:         Implementation Schedule_______________________________________________________

 

Table 15.3.1:           Hong Kong Air Quality Objectives_________________________________________________

Table 15.3.2:           Limits of air pollutant concentrations inside car parks and vehicle tunnes___________________

Table 15.3.3:           Representative ASRs Identified for the Assessment___________________________________

Table.15.3.4            Average Background TSP Air Pollutant Concentrations (Year 2007-2011)__________________

Table 15.3.5:           Air Quality Monitoring Results for Hong Kong Section of Guangzhou-Shenzhen-Hong Kong Express Rail Link relevant to WKCD (March 2010 – December 2012)__________________________________________

Table 15.3.6:           Average Background Air Pollutant Concentrations from EPD’s Urban Air Monitoring Stations (Year 2007-2011)     

Table 15.3.7:           Average Background Air Pollutant Concentrations from EPD’s Local Monitoring Station at WKCD Site (September 2011 – August 2012)___________________________________________________________

Table 15.3.8:           Summary of concurrent projects during construction phase_____________________________

Table 15.3.9:           Key Dust Emission Factors Adopted in the Assessment________________________________

Table 15.3.10:         Summary of tentative active area calculations for Tier 2 and Annual TSP assessment_________

Table 15.3.11:         Vehicle Classification in the EMFAC-HK Model_______________________________________

Table 15.3.12:         Estimated Emission Rates of Barges at NYPCWA_____________________________________

Table 15.3.13:         Estimated Emission Rates of Fast Ferries at China Ferry Terminal________________________

Table 15.3.14:         Estimated Emission Rates of Cruise Ships at Ocean Terminal___________________________

Table 15.3.15:         Summary of 2015 and 2020 Hong Kong Emission Inventory for the PATH Model_____________

Table 15.3.16:         Summary of Predicted Cumulative Hourly Average TSP Concentrations for All ASRs (Tier 1 Unmitigated & Mitigated)___________________________________________________________________________

Table 15.3.17:         Predicted Cumulative Hourly Average TSP Concentrations for ASRs with Exceedance (Tier 1 Mitigated)  

Table 15.3.18:         Summary of Predicted Cumulative Daily Average TSP Concentrations for All ASRs (Tier 1 Unmitigated & Mitigated)___________________________________________________________________________

Table 15.3.19:         Summary of Predicted Cumulative Hourly Average TSP Concentrations (Tier 2 Mitigated)_ 15-60

Table 15.3.20:         Summary of Predicted Cumulative Annual Average TSP Concentrations for All ASRs (Unmitigated & Mitigated)    

Table 15.3.21:         Summary of Predicted Cumulative RSP, SO2 and NO2 Concentrations for All ASRs__________

Table 15.3.22:         Breakdown of Predicted Cumulative NO2 Concentrations by Sources for ASRs with Potential Exceedance             

Table 15.3.23:         Breakdown of Predicted Cumulative Hourly NO2 Concentrations by Sources for Selected ASRs (for the Worst Case Year of 2015)________________________________________________________________

Table 15.3.24:         Breakdown of Predicted Cumulative Hourly NO2 Concentrations by Sources for Selected ASRs (for Year 2020)    

Table 15.4.1:           Noise Standards for Daytime Construction Activities___________________________________

Table 15.4.2:           Relevant Road Traffic Noise Standards for Planning Purposes___________________________

Table 15.4.3:           Representative Noise Sensitive Receivers__________________________________________

Table 15.4.4:           Unmitigated Construction Airborne Noise Impact_____________________________________

Table 15.4.5:           Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact in Year 2032 – Scenario with Interim Access to the Proposed Underpass of the WKCD Project at Austin Road West________________________________________________

Table 15.4.6:           Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact in Year 2032 – Scenario with Permanent Access to the Proposed Underpass of the WKCD Project at Canton Road________________________________________________

Table 15.4.7:           Cumulative Mitigated Construction Airborne Noise Impact______________________________

Table 15.5.1:           Water Quality Objectives for Victoria Harbour WCZ____________________________________

Table 15.7.1            Summary of Waste Arisings during Construction Phase________________________________

Table 15.9.1:           Habitat Evaluation_____________________________________________________________

Table 15.9.2:           Summary of the potential ecological impact_________________________________________

Table 15.10.1:         Impact significance – relationship between sensitivity and magnitude of change_____________

Table 15.10.2:         Assessment categories for residual impact__________________________________________

Table 15.10.3:         Impact significance – relationship between sensitivity and magnitude of change_____________

Table 15.10.4:         Landscape resources and sensitivity_______________________________________________

Table 15.10.5:         Landscape character areas and sensitivity__________________________________________

Table 15.10.6:         Brief descriptions of the VSRs and the existing views__________________________________

Table 15.10.7:         Sensitivity of the VSRs_________________________________________________________

Table 15.10.8:         Source of impacts during construction and operation phase_____________________________

Table 15.10.9:         Impacts on landscape resources during construction and operation phase__________________

Table 15.10.10:      Impacts on landscape character areas during construction and operation phase_____________

Table 15.10.11:      Sources of direct and indirect visual impacts during construction and operation phases________

Table 15.10.12:      Magnitude of Change of VSRs___________________________________________________

Table 15.10.13:      Assessment of Visual Impacts during Construction Phases_____________________________

Table 15.10.14:      Assessment of Visual Impacts during Operation Phase________________________________

Table 15.10.15:      Landscape mitigation measures during construction phase_____________________________

Table 15.10.16:      Landscape mitigation measures during operation phase_______________________________

Table 15.10.17:      Significance of impacts on landscape resources during construction and operation phases_____

Table 15.10.18:      Significance of impacts on landscape character area during construction and operation phases (all impacts are adverse unless otherwise stated)_________________________________________________

Table 15.10.19:      Visual Mitigation Measures during Construction Phase_________________________________

Table 15.10.20:      Visual Mitigation Measures during Operation Phase___________________________________

Table 15.10.21:      Potential cumulative landscape and visual impacts from concurrent projects________________

Table 15.10.22:      Summary of LRs, LCAs and VSRs affected by concurrent projects________________________

Table 15.10.23:      Residual impacts on existing trees during construction phase____________________________

Table 15.10.24:      Residual impacts on landscape character areas during operation phase___________________

Table 15.11.1:         Implementation Schedule_______________________________________________________

 

 


Figures

Figure 1.1             Project Area

Figure 1.2             Project Layout

Figure 1.3             Location of Designated Projects

 

Figure 2.1a           Conceptual Plan Options – ‘City Park’ by Foster + Partners

Figure 2.1b           Conceptual Plan Options – ‘Cultural Connect: Key to Sustained Vitality’ by Rocco Design Architects Ltd.

Figure 2.1c           Conceptual Plan Options – ‘Project for a New Dimension’ by Office for Metropolitan Architecture

Figure 2.2             Modified Conceptual Plan

 

Figure 3.1a           Locations of Air Sensitive Receivers (Outside WKCD Site)

Figure 3.1b           Locations of Air Sensitive Receivers (Within WKCD Site)

Figure 3.2             Locations of XRL Air Monitoring Stations Close to the WKCD Site  

Figure 3.3a           Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources from Concrete Batching Plant and its Haul Road in Year 2013

Figure 3.3b           Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 1) in Year 2013

Figure 3.3c-1        Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources from Concrete Batching Plant (Phase 1) and its Haul Road in Year 2014

Figure 3.3c-2        Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources from Concrete Batching Plant (Phase 2) and its Haul Road in 2014

Figure 3.3c-3        Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 1) in Year 2014

Figure 3.3d           Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources from Concrete Batching Plant and its Haul Road in Year 2015 – 2016

Figure 3.3e           Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 1) in Year 2015

Figure 3.3f            Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 1) in Year 2016

Figure 3.3g           Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources from Concrete Batching Plant and its Haul Road in Year 2017 – 2020

Figure 3.3h           Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 1) in Year 2017

Figure 3.3i            Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 1) in Year 2018

Figure 3.3j            Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 1) in Year 2019

Figure 3.3k           Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 1) in Year 2020

Figure 3.4a           Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 2) for P01d-1 at the end of Year 2015

Figure 3.4b           Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 2) for ASR P53-1 at the end of Year 2015

Figure 3.4c           Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 2) for ASR P01a-1, P01b-1, P01c-1 and P01d-1 at the end of Year 2016

Figure 3.4d           Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 2) for ASR P53-1 at the end of Year 2016

Figure 3.4e           Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 2) for ASR P39-1 and P52-1 at the end of Year 2017

Figure 3.4f            Locations of Potential Construction Dust Sources (Tier 2) for ASR P52-1 at the end of Year 2018

Figure 3.5.1a        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Key Plan)

Figure 3.5.1b        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 1 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1c        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 2 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1d        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 3 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1e        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 4 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1f         Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 5 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1g        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 6 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1h        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 7 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1i         Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 8 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1j         Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 9 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1k        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 10 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1l         Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 11 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1m      Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 12 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1n        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 13 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1o        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 14 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1p        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 15 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1q        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 16 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1r         Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 17 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1s        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 18 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1t         Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 19 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1u        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 20 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1v        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 21 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1w       Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 22 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1x        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 23 of 24)

Figure 3.5.1y        Road Links within 500m Assessment Area for 2015 (Sheet 24 of 24)

Figure 3.6             Location of Emission Sources for ISCST model

Figure 3.7             Location of Marine Emission Sources

Figure 3.8             PATH grid

Figure 3.9             Odour Sampling Grids and Discharge Points

Figure 3.10           (not used)

Figure 3.11a         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2013 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.11b         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2014 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.11c         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2015 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.11d         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2016 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.11e         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2017 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.11f          Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2018 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.11g         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2019 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.11h         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2020 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.12a         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2013 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.12b         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2014 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.12c         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2015 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.12d         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2016 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.12e         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2017 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.12f          Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2018 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.12g         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2019 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.12h         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2020 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.13a         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2013 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.13b         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2014 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.13c         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2015 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.13d         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2016 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.13e         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2017 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.13f          Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2018 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.13g         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2019 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.13h         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2020 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.14a         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2013 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.14b         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2014 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.14c         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2015 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.14d         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2016 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.14e         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2017 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.14f          Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2018 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.14g         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2019 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.14h         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 1 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2020 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.15a         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 2 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground for dust sources near ASR P01d-1 at year 2015 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.15b         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 2 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground for dust sources near ASR P53-1 at year 2015 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.15c         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 2 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground for dust sources near ASR P01a-1, P01b-1, P01c-1 and P01d-1 at year 2016 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.15d         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 2 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground for dust sources near ASR P53-1 at year 2016 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.15e         Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 2 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground for dust sources near ASR P39-1, P52-1 at year 2017 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.15f          Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 2 Hourly TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground for dust sources near ASR P52-1 at year 2018 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.16           Cumulative Result – Contour of Tier 2 Daily TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground for dust sources near ASR P01b-1 and P01c-1 at year 2016 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.17a         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2013 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.17b         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2014 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.17c         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2015 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.17d         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2016 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.17e         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2017 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.17f          Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2018 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.17g         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2019 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.17h         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2020 during construction phase (unmitigated)

Figure 3.18a         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2013 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.18b         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2014 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.18c         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2015 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.18d         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2016 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.18e         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2017 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.18f          Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2018 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.18g         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2019 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.18h         Cumulative Result – Contour of Annual TSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground at year 2020 during construction phase (mitigated)

Figure 3.19           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through portal

Figure 3.20           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 2 through portal

Figure 3.21           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 3 through portal

Figure 3.22           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 4 through portal

Figure 3.23           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.24           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 2 through stack

Figure 3.25           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 3 through stack

Figure 3.26           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 4 through stack

Figure 3.27           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through portal

Figure 3.28           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 2 through portal

Figure 3.29           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 3 through portal

Figure 3.30           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 4 through portal

Figure 3.31           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.32           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 2 through stack

Figure 3.33           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 3 through stack

Figure 3.34           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 4 through stack

Figure 3.35           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through portal

Figure 3.36           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 2 through portal

Figure 3.37           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 3 through portal

Figure 3.38           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 4 through portal

Figure 3.39           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.40           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 2 through stack

Figure 3.41           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 3 through stack

Figure 3.42           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 4 through stack

Figure 3.43           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through portal

Figure 3.44           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 2 through portal

Figure 3.45           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 3 through portal

Figure 3.46           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 4 through portal

Figure 3.47           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.48           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 2 through stack

Figure 3.49           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 3 through stack

Figure 3.50           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 4 through stack

Figure 3.51           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through portal

Figure 3.52           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 2 through portal

Figure 3.53           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 3 through portal

Figure 3.54           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 4 through portal

Figure 3.55           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.56           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 2 through stack

Figure 3.57           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 3 through stack

Figure 3.58           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase for scenario 4 through stack

Figure 3.59           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.60           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.61           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.62           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 12m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.63           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 12m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.64           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 12m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.65           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 12m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.66           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 12m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.67           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 12m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.68           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 12m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.69           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 12m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.70           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 40m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.71           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 40m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.72           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 40m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.73           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 40m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.74           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 40m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.75           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 40m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.76           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 40m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.77           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 40m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.78           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 50m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.79           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 50m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.80           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 50m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.81           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 50m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.82           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 50m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.83           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 50m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.84           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 50m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.85           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 50m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.86           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 60m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.87           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 60m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.88           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual NO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 60m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.89           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 60m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.90           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual RSP Concentration (µg/m3) at 60m above ground during operational phase for scenario 1 through stack

Figure 3.91           Cumulative Results - Contour of Hourly SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 60m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.92           Cumulative Results - Contour of Daily SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 60m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.93           Cumulative Results - Contour of Annual SO2 Concentration (µg/m3) at 60m above ground during operational phase

Figure 3.94           Contour of 5-s Odour Concentration (ou/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operation phase (Background Scenario)

Figure 3.95           Contour of 5-s Odour Concentration (ou/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operation phase (Current Scenario)

Figure 3.96           Contour of 5-s Odour Concentration (ou/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operation phase (Mitigated - A 1:1 Scenario)

Figure 3.97           Contour of 5-s Odour Concentration (ou/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operation phase (Mitigated - A 1:0.75 Scenario)

Figure 3.98           Contour of 5-s Odour Concentration (ou/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operation phase (Mitigated - A 1:0.50 Scenario)

Figure 3.99           Contour of 5-s Odour Concentration (ou/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operation phase (Mitigated - A 1:0.25 Scenario)

Figure 3.100         Contour of 5-s Odour Concentration (ou/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operation phase (Mitigated - B 1:1 Scenario)

Figure 3.101         Contour of 5-s Odour Concentration (ou/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operation phase (Mitigated - B 1:0.75 Scenario)

Figure 3.102         Contour of 5-s Odour Concentration (ou/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operation phase (Mitigated - B 1:0.50 Scenario)

Figure 3.103         Contour of 5-s Odour Concentration (ou/m3) at 1.5m above ground during operation phase (Mitigated - B 1:0.25 Scenario)

 

Figure 4.1              Noise Impact Study Area

Figure 4.2a           Locations of All Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) for Construction Noise Impact Assessment

Figure 4.2b           Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Construction Area between October 2013 and March 2014

Figure 4.2c           Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Construction Area between April 2014 and March 2015

Figure 4.2d           Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Construction Area between April 2015 and March 2016

Figure 4.2e           Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Construction Area between April 2016 and March 2017

Figure 4.2f            Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Construction Area between April 2017 and March 2018

Figure 4.2g           Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Construction Area between April 2018 and March 2019

Figure 4.2h           Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Construction Area between April 2019 and March 2020

Figure 4.2i            Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Construction Area between April 2020 and December 2020

Figure 4.2j            Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Construction Area in Year 2021 and Before FQ Relocation

Figure 4.2k           Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Construction Area after 2022 during Excluded Area Construction

Figure 4.2l             Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Construction Area after 2030

Figure 4.3              Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers for Road Traffic Noise Impact Assessment

Figure 4.4a           Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Noise Sources for Fixed Plant Noise Impact Assessment (Sheet 1 of 2)

Figure 4.4b           Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers (NSRs) and Noise Sources for Fixed Plant Noise Impact Assessment (Sheet 2 of 2)

Figure 4.5              Photos of Existing Noise Sensitive Receivers

Figure 4.6              Locations of Baseline Noise Measurement

Figure 4.7a           Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers for Ground-borne Noise Impact Assessment

Figure 4.7b           Locations of Ground-borne Vibration Monitoring

Figure 4.8              Locations of Marine Traffic Noise Monitoring

Figure 4.9              Schematic Configuration of Movable Noise Barrier

Figure 4.10           Schematic Configuration of Full Noise Enclosure for PME

Figure 4.11           Conceptual Design of Building Isolation

Figure 4.12           Conceptual Design of Box-in-Box Installation

Figure 4.13           Locations of Facades Recommended for At-receivers Noise Mitigation Measures

Figure 4.14           Typical Layout of At-receivers Noise Mitigation Measures

Figure 4.15           Conceptual Design of Balcony

Figure 4.16           Conceptual Design of Non-openable Windows

Figure 4.17           Locations of Underpass Portal Recommended for Acoustic Treatment

 

Figure 5.1              Locations of Water Control Zones

Figure 5.2              Locations of Key Water Sensitive Receivers

Figure 5.3              Tentative Location of Marine Features

Figure 5.4              Tentative General Arrangement of Possible Piers

Figure 5.5              Tentative Piling Arrangement of Possible Piers

Figure 5.6              (Not used)

Figure 5.7              Typical Drainage Pipe Outfall

 

Figure 6.1              Layout Plan of WKCD and the Surrounding Development

Figure 6.2              Existing Sewerage System

Figure 6.3              Proposed Sewerage Sub-catchment Plan

Figure 6.4              Proposed Sewerage System

Figure 6.5              Access to Proposed Sewerage System

Figure 6.6              InfoWorks Network

Figure 6.7              Proposed Sewerage Layout Plan (Key Plan)

Figure 6.8              Proposed Sewerage Layout Plan (Sheet 1 of 11)

Figure 6.9              Proposed Sewerage Layout Plan (Sheet 2 of 11)

Figure 6.10           Proposed Sewerage Layout Plan (Sheet 3 of 11)

Figure 6.11           Proposed Sewerage Layout Plan (Sheet 4 of 11)

Figure 6.12           Proposed Sewerage Layout Plan (Sheet 5 of 11)

Figure 6.13           Proposed Sewerage Layout Plan (Sheet 6 of 11)

Figure 6.14           Proposed Sewerage Layout Plan (Sheet 7 of 11)

Figure 6.15           Proposed Sewerage Layout Plan (Sheet 8 of 11)

Figure 6.16           Proposed Sewerage Layout Plan (Sheet 9 of 11)

Figure 6.17           Proposed Sewerage Layout Plan (Sheet 10 of 11)

Figure 6.18           Proposed Sewerage Layout Plan (Sheet 11 of 11)

Figure 6.19           Proposed Sewerage System Manhole Schedule

 

Figure 9.1              Habitat Map

Figure 9.2              Transect Route for Ecological Survey

 

Figure 10.1           Baseline Landscape Resources within the Assessment Area (Reference Plan)

Figure 10.1a         Baseline Landscape Resources within the Assessment Area (Sheet 1 of 4)

Figure 10.1b         Baseline Landscape Resources within the Assessment Area (Sheet 2 of 4)

Figure 10.1c         Baseline Landscape Resources within the Assessment Area (Sheet 3 of 4)

Figure 10.1d         Baseline Landscape Resources within the Assessment Area (Sheet 4 of 4)

Figure 10.2a         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 1 of 20)

Figure 10.2b         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 2 of 20)

Figure 10.2c         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 3 of 20)

Figure 10.2d         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 4 of 20)

Figure 10.2e         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 5 of 20)

Figure 10.2f          Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 6 of 20)

Figure 10.2g         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 7 of 20)

Figure 10.2h         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 8 of 20)

Figure 10.2i          Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 9 of 20)

Figure 10.2j          Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 10 of 20)

Figure 10.2k         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 11 of 20)

Figure 10.2l          Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 12 of 20)

Figure 10.2m        Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 13 of 20)

Figure 10.2n         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 14 of 20)

Figure 10.2o         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 15 of 20)

Figure 10.2p         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 16 of 20)

Figure 10.2q         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 17 of 20)

Figure 10.2r          Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 18 of 20)

Figure 10.2s         Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 19 of 20)

Figure 10.2t          Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 20 of 20)

Figure 10.3           Broad Brush Tree Survey Plan

Figure  10.4          Baseline Landscape Character Area within the Assessment Area

Figure 10.5a         Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 1 of 8)

Figure 10.5b         Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 2 of 8)

Figure 10.5c         Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 3 of 8)

Figure 10.5d         Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 4 of 8)

Figure 10.5e         Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 5 of 8)

Figure 10.5f          Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 6 of 8)

Figure 10.5g         Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 7 of 8)

Figure 10.5h         Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 8 of 8)

Figure 10.6           Zoning of the Site and  Surrounding Areas

Figure 10.7           Building Height Limits of the Proposed WKCD Development

Figure 10.8           Locations of VSRs Located within the Visual Envelope (Outside the Primary Zone of Visual Influence)

Figure 10.9           Aerial Photo of the Site

Figure 10.10         Zoning of Surrounding Areas & Location of VSRs Located within the Primary Zone of Visual Influence

Figure 10.11         Baseline VSRs Located on Hong Kong Island

Figure 10.12a       Baseline VSR 1 to VSR 4

Figure 10.12b       Baseline VSR 5 to VSR 8

Figure 10.12c       Baseline VSR 9 to VSR 12

Figure 10.12d       Baseline VSR 13 to VSR 17

Figure 10.12e       Baseline VSR 18 to VSR 21

Figure 10.12f        Baseline VSR 22 to VSR 26

Figure 10.12g       Baseline VSR 27 to VSR 30

Figure 10.12h       Baseline VSR 31 to VSR 34

Figure 10.12i        Baseline VSR 35 to VSR 38

Figure 10.12j        Baseline VSR 39 to VSR 42

Figure 10.12k       Baseline VSR 43

Figure 10.13         Location Plan of the 10 Selected Viewpoints for the Photomontages

Figure 10.13a       Photomontages 1A & 1B Viewpoint 1 (Sun Yat Sen Memorial Park)

Figure 10.13b       Photomontages 1C & 1D Viewpoint 1 (Sun Yat Sen Memorial Park)

Figure 10.14a       Photomontages 2A & 2B Viewpoint 2 (Central Star Ferry Pier No. 7)

Figure 10.14b       Photomontages 2C & 2D Viewpoint 2 (Central Star Ferry Pier No. 7)

Figure 10.15a       Photomontages 3A & 3B Viewpoint 3 (Hong Kong Convention and Exhibition Centre)

Figure 10.15b       Photomontages 3C & 3D Viewpoint 3 (Hong Kong Convention and Exhibition Centre)

Figure 10.16a       Photomontages 4A & 4B Viewpoint 4 (The Peak)

Figure 10.16b       Photomontages 4C & 4D Viewpoint 4 (The Peak)

Figure 10.17a       Photomontages 5A & 5B Viewpoint 5 (Hoi Fei Road Waterfront)

Figure 10.17b       Photomontages 5C & 5D Viewpoint 5 (Hoi Fei Road Waterfront)

Figure 10.18a       Photomontages 6A & 6B Viewpoint 9 (The Elements)

Figure 10.18b       Photomontages 6C & 6D Viewpoint 9 (The Elements)

Figure 10.19a       Photomontages 7A & 7B Viewpoint 19 (Western Harbour Crossing Toll Plaza)

Figure 10.19b       Photomontages 7C & 7D Viewpoint 19 (Western Harbour Crossing Toll Plaza)

Figure 10.20a       Photomontages 8A & 8B Viewpoint 19 (Wai On Building & Wai Hang Building)

Figure 10.20b       Photomontages 8C & 8D Viewpoint 19 (Wai On Building & Wai Hang Building)

Figure 10.21a       Photomontages 9A & 9B Viewpoint 26 (Gateway Hong Kong)

Figure 10.21b       Photomontages 9C & 9D Viewpoint 26 (Gateway Hong Kong)

Figure 10.22a       Photomontages 10A & 10B Viewpoint 31 (Ocean Terminal)

Figure 10.22b       Photomontages 10C & 10D Viewpoint 31 (Ocean Terminal)

Figure 10.23         Location of the Temporary Landscaped Area

Figure 10.24         Location of Proposed Wind Turbines

Figure 10.25a       Site Section and Building Height Profile

Figure 10.25b       Stepped Height Profile of the WKCD development & S Curve Concept

Figure 10.26a       Good Design Feature – Visual Permeability

Figure 10.26b       Artist’s Impression of View from WKT

Figure 10.26c       Artist’s Impression of View Corridor along an Alleyway

Figure 10.26d       Artist’s Impression of View from Central Square

Figure 10.27a       Proposed Landscape Concept Plan

Figure 10.27b       Landscape Concept Plan for Park

Figure 10.27c       Landscape Concept for Park - Section 01 and Section 02

Figure 10.27d       Landscape Concept for Waterfront Promenade

Figure 10.27e       Landscape Concept for Waterfront Promenade - Section A – A

Figure 10.27f        Landscape Concept for the Avenue

Figure 10.27g       Landscape Concept for Landscape Deck Connecting WKT

Figure 10.27h       Landscape Concept for Austin Road West Section A – A

Figure 10.28         Artist’s Impression of Aerial View

 

Figure 14.1.1        Project Layout

Figure 14.2.1        Detailed WKCD Basement Layout

Figure 14.2.2a     Road C Alignment And Setting Out Data (Sheet 1 of 4)

Figure 14.2.2b     Road C Alignment And Setting Out Data (Sheet 2 of 4)

Figure 14.2.2c      Road C Alignment And Setting Out Data (Sheet 3 of 4)

Figure 14.2.2d     Road C Alignment And Setting Out Data (Sheet 4 of 4)

Figure 14.2.2e     Interim Road C4 – Layout Plan and Profile

Figure 14.2.2f      Road C1 – Road Profile

Figure 14.2.2g     Road C2 – Road Profile

Figure 14.2.2h     Road C3 – Road Profile (Sheet 1 of 2)

Figure 14.2.2i       Road C3 – Road Profile (Sheet 2 of 2)

Figure 14.2.2j       Road C5 – Road Profile

Figure 14.5.1        Locations of Water Control Zones

Figure 14.5.2        Locations of Key Water Sensitive Receivers

Figure 14.9.1        Habitat Map

Figure 14.9.2        Transect Route for Ecological Survey

Figure 14.10.1     Baseline Landscape Resources within the Assessment Area of Underpass Road

Figure 14.10.2     (not used)

Figure 14.10.3a   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 1 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3b   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 2 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3c   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 3 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3d   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 4 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3e   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 5 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3f    Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 6 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3g   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 7 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3h   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 8 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3i    Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 9 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3j    Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 10 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3k   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 11 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3l    Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 12 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3m  Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 13 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3n   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 14 of 15)

Figure 14.10.3o   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 15 of 15)

Figure 14.10.4     Broad Brush Tree Survey Plan

Figure 14.10.5     Baseline Landscape Character Area within the Assessment Area of Underpass Road

Figure 14.10.6     (not used)

Figure 14.10.7a   Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 1 of 8)

Figure 14.10.7b   Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 2 of 8)

Figure 14.10.7c   Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 3 of 8)

Figure 14.10.7d   Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 4 of 8)

Figure 14.10.7e   Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 5 of 8)

Figure 14.10.7f    Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 6 of 8)

Figure 14.10.7g   Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 7 of 8)

Figure 14.10.7h   Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 8 of 8)

Figure 14.10.8     Locations of VSRs located within the Primary Zone of Visual Influence

Figure 14.10.9a   Photos of VSR 1 to VSR 4

Figure 14.10.9b   Photos of VSR 5 to VSR 9

Figure 14.10.9c   Photos of VSR 10 to VSR 11

Figure 14.10.9d   Photos of VSR 12 to VSR 16

Figure 14.10.9e   Photos of VSR 18 to VSR 21

Figure 14.10.10   Location of Ventilation Exhaust/ Shaft for Underpass Road during Transition Period

Figure 14.10.11   Section of Completed Buildings and Ventilation Shafts for Underpass Road during Transition Period

Figure 14.10.12   Locations and Sections of Notional Louvres within the Buildings at the WKCD

Figure 14.10.13a Photomontages 1A & 1B - Viewpoint 14 (Gateway Tower)

Figure 14.10.13b Photomontages 1C & 1D - Viewpoint 14 (Gateway Tower)

Figure 14.10.14   List of Landscape Mitigation Measure for Underpass Road

Figure 14.10.15   Proposed Landscape Concept Plan

Figure 14.10.16   Landscape Concept Plan for Park

Figure 14.10.17   Landscape Concept for the Avenue

Figure 14.10.18   Landscape Concept for Landscape Deck Connecting WKT

 

Figure 15.1.1        Project Layout

Figure 15.2.1        Proposed Austin Road Flyover Profile of Layout Plan (Sheet 1 of 4)

Figure 15.2.2        Proposed Austin Road Flyover Profile of Layout Plan (Sheet 2 of 4)

Figure 15.2.3        Proposed Austin Road Flyover Profile of Layout Plan (Sheet 3 of 4)

Figure 15.2.4        Proposed Austin Road Flyover Profile of Layout Plan (Sheet 4 of 4)

Figure 15.3.1        Locations of Air Sensitive Receivers (outside WKCD Site)

Figure 15.3.2        Locations of Air Sensitive Receivers (within WKCD Site)

Figure 15.4.1        Locations of Noise Sensitive Receivers for Flyover

Figure 15.5.1        Locations of Water Control Zones

Figure 15.5.2        Locations of Key Water Sensitive Receivers

Figure 15.9.1        Habitat Map

Figure 15.9.2        Transect Route for Ecological Survey

Figure 15.10.1     Baseline Landscape Resources within the Assessment Area of Austin Road Flyover

Figure 15.10.2     (not used)

Figure 15.10.3a   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 1 of 6)

Figure 15.10.3b   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 2 of 6)

Figure 15.10.3c   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 3 of 6)

Figure 15.10.3d   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 4 of 6)

Figure 15.10.3e   Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 5 of 6)

Figure 15.10.3f    Baseline Landscape Resources Photo Record (Sheet 6 of 6)

Figure 15.10.4     Broad Brush Tree Survey Plan

Figure 15.10.5     Baseline Landscape Character Area within the Assessment Area of Austin Road Flyover

Figure 15.10.6     (not used)

Figure 15.10.7a   Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 1 of 6)

Figure 15.10.7b   Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 2 of 6)

Figure 15.10.7c   Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 3 of 6)

Figure 15.10.7d   Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 4 of 6)

Figure 15.10.7e   Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 5 of 6)

Figure 15.10.7f    Baseline Landscape Character Area Photo Record (Sheet 6 of 6)

Figure 15.10.8     Locations of the VSRs located within the Primary Zone of Visual Influence

Figure 15.10.9     Photos of VSR 1 to VSR 4

Figure 15.10.10   Photos of VSR 5 to VSR 8

Figure 15.10.11a Photomontages 1A & 1B - Viewpoint 1 (International Commerce Centre at Podium Level)

Figure 15.10.11b Photomontages 1C & 1D - Viewpoint 1 (International Commerce Centre at Podium Level)

Figure 15.10.12a Photomontages 2A & 2B - Viewpoint 5 (Western Harbour Crossing Toll Plaza)

Figure 15.10.12b Photomontages 2C & 2D - Viewpoint 5 (Western Harbour Crossing Toll Plaza)

Figure 15.10.13a Photomontages 3A & 3B - Viewpoint 6 (Pedestrian at the Footbridge Crossing Western Harbour Crossing Toll Plaza)

Figure 15.10.13b Photomontages 3C & 3D - Viewpoint 6 (Pedestrian at the Footbridge crossing Western Harbour Crossing Toll Plaza)

Figure 15.10.14   List of Landscape Mitigation Measures for Austin Road Flyover

Figure 15.10.15   Proposed Landscape Concept Plan

Figure 15.10.16   Landscape Concept Plan for Park

Figure 15.10.17   Landscape Concept for Austin Road West Section A – A

 

 


Appendices

Appendix 2.1        Summary of Desirable Features for Consideration in Modified CP

Appendix 2.2        Changes to the Findings of the Preliminary Environmental Assessment arising from the Modified Conceptual Plan

Appendix 2.3        Summary of Views Received in Stage 3 PE Exercise

Appendix 2.4        Tentative Construction Programme

 

Appendix 3.1        Details of Dust Emission Sources for 1-hour and Daily TSP Assessment (Tier 1) from Year 2013 – 2020

Appendix 3.2        Details of Dust Emission Sources for 1-hour and Daily TSP Assessment (Tier 2) from Year 2015 – 2020

Appendix 3.3        Details of Dust Emission Sources for Annual TSP Assessment from Year 2013 – 2020

Appendix 3.4        Data Input of Tier 1 Dust Sources for Unmitigated and Mitigated Scenario including their Coordinates, Dimensions and Estimated Emission Rates

Appendix 3.5        Data Input of Tier 2 Dust Sources including their Coordinates, Dimensions and Estimated Emission Rates

Appendix 3.6        Data Input of Annual Dust Sources for Unmitigated and Mitigated Scenario including their Coordinates, Dimensions and Estimated Emission Rates

Appendix 3.7        Detailed Estimation of the Percentages Active Work Areas

Appendix 3.8        Calculation of Dust Suppression Efficiency

Appendix 3.9        Letter from Traffic Department regarding Traffic Forecast Data

Appendix 3.10     24-Hour Traffic Pattern

Appendix 3.11     Vehicle Age Distribution in Base Year 2010

Appendix 3.12     Lengths of Individual Road Links of Connecting Road

Appendix 3.13     24-hour VKT values for All Vehicle Classes in each of the Model years 2015, 2020, 2025 and 2030

Appendix 3.14     Trip Estimation

Appendix 3.15     24-hour variations of Annual Averages of Temperature and Relative Humidity

Appendix 3.16     24-hour speed fractions

Appendix 3.17     Calculation of Emission Factors for Each Model Year

Appendix 3.18a   Calculation of emission rate for scenario 1 through portal for ISCST3 model input (for 2015 traffic forecast)

Appendix 3.18b   Calculation of emission rate for scenario 2 through portal for ISCST3 model input (for 2015 traffic forecast)

Appendix 3.18c   Calculation of emission rate for scenario 3 through portal for ISCST3 model input (for 2015 traffic forecast)

Appendix 3.18d   Calculation of emission rate for scenario 4 through portal for ISCST3 model input (for 2015 traffic forecast)

Appendix 3.18e   Calculation of emission rate for scenario 1 through stack for ISCST3 model input (for 2015 traffic forecast)

Appendix 3.18f    Calculation of emission rate for scenario 2 through stack for ISCST3 model input (for 2015 traffic forecast)

Appendix 3.18g   Calculation of emission rate for scenario 3 through stack for ISCST3 model input (for 2015 traffic forecast)

Appendix 3.18h   Calculation of emission rate for scenario 4 through stack for ISCST3 model input (for 2015 traffic forecast)

Appendix 3.19     Calculation of emission rate for scenario 1 through stack for ISCST3 model input (for 2020 traffic forecast)

Appendix 3.20     Summary data for EPD's WKCD air quality monitoring station

Appendix 3.21     (not used)

Appendix 3.22     (not used)

Appendix 3.23     Composition Emission factor in Year 2015

Appendix 3.24     Composition Emission factor in Year 2020

Appendix 3.25     Marine emission calculations

Appendix 3.26a   Odour Patrol Report

Appendix 3.26b   Report on Expert Review of New Yau Ma Tei Typhoon Shelter (NYMTTS) Odour Source Measurement

Appendix 3.26c   Estimation of Odour Emission Rates

Appendix 3.27     XRL EM&A TSP monitoring data

Appendix 3.28     Tier 1 TSP Screening Results for Unmitigated and Mitigated Scenarios including Background Contribution

Appendix 3.29     Tier 2 TSP Results for Mitigated Scenario including Background Contribution

Appendix 3.30     Annual TSP Results for Unmitigated and Mitigated Scenarios including Background Contribution

Appendix 3.31     Modelling results for SO2, NO2 and RSP during operation phase (for traffic forecast and background concentrations in 2015)

Appendix 3.32     Modelling results for NO2 during operation phase (for traffic forecast and background concentrations in 2020)

Appendix 3.33     Estimation of Odour Emission Reduction by Improvement of DWFI Interception Efficiency

Appendix 3.34     Estimated Odour Emission Rates for Background, Current, Mitigated Scenario A and Mitigated Scenario B

Appendix 3.35     Odour Modelling Results for Background, Current, Mitigated Scenario A and Mitigated Scenario B

Appendix 3.36     Review of Government’s Existing and Planned Measures for New Yau Ma Tei Typhoon Shelter

 

 

Appendix 4.1        Measured Background Noise Levels

Appendix 4.1a     Methodology of identification of Sound Power Levels for Existing Fixed Plant Noise Sources

Appendix 4.1b     Measurement Results and Calculation of Sound Power Levels for Existing Noise Sources adopted in the Fixed Plant Noise Impact Assessment

Appendix 4.1c      Measurement Locations for Sound Power Levels of Existing Fixed Plant Noise Sources (Sheet 1 of 2)

Appendix 4.1d     Measurement Locations for Sound Power Levels of Existing Fixed Plant Noise Sources (Sheet 2 of 2)

Appendix 4.2a     Peak Hour Traffic Forecast

Appendix 4.2b     Key Plan for WKCD External Road Links 2032

Appendix 4.2c      Key Plan for WKCD Internal Road Links 2032

Appendix 4.2d     Key Plan for WKCD External Road Links 2032 without Project

Appendix 4.2e     Key Plan for WKCD External Road Links 2013 (Prevailing Scenario)

Appendix 4.2f      Letter from Traffic Department regarding Traffic Forecast Data

Appendix 4.3a     Details for Helicopter Noise Assessment

Appendix 4.3b     Details for Helicopter Noise Measurement

Appendix 4.4a     Unmitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2013 and 2014

Appendix 4.4b     Unmitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2014 and 2015

Appendix 4.4c      Unmitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2015 and 2016

Appendix 4.4d     Unmitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2016 and 2017

Appendix 4.4e     Unmitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2017 and 2018

Appendix 4.4f      Unmitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2018 and 2019

Appendix 4.4g     Unmitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2019 and 2020

Appendix 4.4h     Unmitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2020

Appendix 4.4i       Unmitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2021 and after

Appendix 4.5a     Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact (Year 2032) – Interim Access at Austin Road West

Appendix 4.5b     Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact (Year 2032) – Permanent Access at Canton Road

Appendix 4.5c      Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact (Year 2032 – without Project)

Appendix 4.5d     Prevailing Road Traffic Noise Impact (Year 2013)

Appendix 4.5e     Layout of Road Plots

Appendix 4.5f      Sample Calculations of Road Traffic Noise Modelling

Appendix 4.6        Fixed Plant Noise Assessment

Appendix 4.7a     Open Air Entertainment Activity Noise Assessment

Appendix 4.7b     Measurement Details for Open Air Entertainment Activity Noise from Music Concert conducted in WKCD in October 2011

Appendix 4.8        Railway Ground-borne Noise Impact Assessment

Appendix 4.9        Marine Traffic Noise Impact Assessment

Appendix 4.10a   Mitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2013 and 2014

Appendix 4.10b   Mitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2014 and 2015

Appendix 4.10c   Mitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2015 and 2016

Appendix 4.10d   Mitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2016 and 2017

Appendix 4.10e   Mitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2017 and 2018

Appendix 4.10f    Mitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2018 and 2019

Appendix 4.10g   Mitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2019 and 2020

Appendix 4.10h   Mitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2020

Appendix 4.10i    Mitigated Construction Plant Inventory and Noise Impact in Year 2020 and after

Appendix 4.11     Geological Information of WKCD

Appendix 4.12     Trackform Information of AEL/TCL at WKCD

 

Appendix 5.1        Delft3D Model Setup

Appendix 5.2        Predicted Temperature Elevation at Surface Water (Dry Season & Wet Season)

Appendix 5.3        Predicted Depth-averaged Residual Chlorine Concentration (Dry Season & Wet Season)

 

Appendix 6.1        Sewerage Catchment Plan for the sewer at Canton Road

Appendix 6.2        Hydraulic Assessment for Existing and Proposed Sewerage System

Appendix 6.3        Breakdown of Sewage Flow Estimation at Upstream of Canton Road

 

Appendix 7.1        Relevant drillholes at various Zones and  ground investigation records for Zone 1

Appendix 7.2        Previous site investigation records for Zone 2a

Appendix 7.3        Previous site investigation records for Zone 2b

Appendix 7.4        Previous site investigation records for Zones 3 and 4

Appendix 7.5       Copies of relevant correspondences with potential projects

 

Appendix 8.1        Contamination Assessment Plan for WKCD

 

Appendix 9.1        Plates

Appendix 9.2        List of Avifauna recorded within the Study Area

 

Appendix 12.1     Documentation of Key Assessment Assumptions, Limitation of Assessment Methodologies and related Prior Agreement(s) with the Director

 

Appendix 14.4.1  Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact (Year 2032) – Interim Access at Austin Road West

Appendix 14.4.2  Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact (Year 2032) – Permanent Access at Canton Road

Appendix 14.4.3  Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact (Year 2032 – without Project)

 

Appendix 15.4.1  Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact (Year 2032) – Interim Access at Austin Road West

Appendix 15.4.2  Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact (Year 2032) – Permanent Access at Canton Road

Appendix 15.4.3  Unmitigated Road Traffic Noise Impact (Year 2032 – without Project)

Appendix 15.4.4  Peak Hour Flow (2032) – without Proposed Flyover